As Andy Warhol may need mentioned if he’d been slightly extra particular together with his pop cultural prophecies: “Sooner or later, each well-known character actor might be John Wick for quarter-hour.”
Lesley Manville solely will get about 10 in Kasia Adamik’s Warsaw-set “The Winter of the Crow,” and the motion cleaves a lot nearer to the stuff of Jason Bourne than to the gun-fu of the Baba Yaga. However the sight of the “Phantom Thread” star choking a thuggish member of Poland’s Army Council of Nationwide Salvation with a wire clothesline is hardly the one spotlight of this usually gripping and richly immersive political thriller, most of which takes place within the hours after a navy junta declares martial legislation over the nation on the evening of December 13, 1981.
The useless communist doesn’t reside to remorse underestimating Manville’s character, however others will — albeit much less for her functionality than for her willingness to struggle again. A British psychiatry professor who’s risen to the highest of a area dominated by males (and maintains an comprehensible chip on her shoulder about how troublesome it was for her to get there), Dr. Joan Andrews may not appear to pose a lot of a menace. However she’s as powerful a buyer as they arrive; frostier than a Polish winter, and simply as detached to the chilling impact she has on anybody inside her attain.
The beginning of the movie sees Joan journey to the awful and bleary capital with a view to give a career-topping lecture about schizophrenia at an area college, and she or he’s none too happy when a gaggle of scholar activists instantly disturbs her speech with a blitz of bathroom paper and sloganeering. “How can a sick society present psychological care?” considered one of them asks after bumping the professor off the rostrum. Regardless of the character of her life’s work, Joan couldn’t presumably carry herself to care about that query. Incapable of ever sustaining a relationship for longer than six months, she’s extra serious about learning afflictions than sympathizing with individuals — not to mention the political causes that may yoke them collectively.
When the shit hits the fan on her first evening on the town (cellphone strains reduce, tanks within the streets, police grabbing dissidents from their houses with impunity), Joan’s solely thought is to get the fuck out of Dodge, and bearing witness to an extrajudicial homicide solely makes her wish to flee the nation that a lot quicker. Evidently, that proves simpler mentioned than carried out (particularly as soon as the junta realizes that she has photographic proof of their crimes), and the frantic path dwelling will pressure her to acknowledge that her analysis is barely of worth to a world wholesome sufficient to need it.
Mercifully, “The Winter of the White Crow” is much extra dreamlike than didactic, with Adamik preferring to emphasise the hallucinatory onset of totalitarianism over the “Save the Cat!”-like steps of a passive character turning right into a extra energetic one. (The Army Council of Nationwide Salvation was abbreviated to WRON in Polish, which lent it to puns primarily based round “wrona,” the language’s phrase for crow.) Tailored from a brief story by Nobel Prize-winning creator Olga Tokarczuk, and government produced by “Inexperienced Border” auteur Agnieszka Holland (who is aware of a factor or two about tactfully mining cinematic suspense from the stuff of actual geopolitical horror), “The Winter of the Crow” is instantly arresting for its ambiance of visceral desolation. Whereas everybody else has adjusted their eyes to the darkness of life within the Jap Bloc, Joan is experiencing the grayscale drudgery of Soviet period Warsaw for the primary time, a chance this film seizes upon to see the town as a semi-heightened concrete labyrinth whose design displays the Kafkaesque nature of its political equipment.
At a time when most budget-conscious interval items are undone by the glossiness of contemporary digital codecs, “Winter of the Crow” appears like nothing lower than a small miracle of evocation. Tomasz Naumiuk’s soup-thick cinematography is textured sufficient to see the sterile air of the movie’s brutalist interiors, and to get misplaced within the hopeless void of the Warsaw streets at evening. Aleksandra Kierzkowska’s manufacturing design is equally lifeless and lived-in abruptly, as the town’s barren tower blocks appear painted into the skyline but in addition actual sufficient to the touch — like a lot of this movie, they blur the road between actuality and one thing even worse, solely sharpening into focus as Joan begins to acknowledge the foundations of the sport and the stakes at play.
The brilliantly textured ambiance lends a harrowing sense of horror to the story at hand, and the fundamental nightmare of Joan’s predicament assumes sufficient urgency to make you shiver with the secondhand unease of somebody who’s caught in a spot they don’t perceive. Frigid as she could be, nevertheless, Joan finds that she isn’t fairly as alone as she thinks. Her younger liaison, Alina (Zofia Wichłacz), a scholar deeply enmeshed within the pro-democratic Solidarity motion, might not be overly involved with Joan’s consolation given the disaster at hand. Nonetheless, she does what she will to rearrange the self-absorbed professor’s protected passage dwelling. As a direct results of that hospitality, the ladies’s respective causes quickly develop into extra aligned than both Joan or Alina would have wished, and any hurt visited upon considered one of them ultimately threatens to doom the opposite as effectively.
“Winter of the Crew” is sprinkled with occasional moments of violence (together with a short automotive chase that compensates for its lack of crashes with a number of hyper-involving digital camera angles), however that is in no way an motion film, and it’s a testomony to the enjoyable of watching Manville chip and thaw that it stays so thrilling because the WRON closes in on Joan. Sandra Buchta’s script manages to remain on the correct aspect of plausibility even because the scenario escalates. Whereas the movie’s plot is crammed with all method of thriller mishegoss that was nowhere to be discovered within the authentic story (together with a minorly affecting ethical victory of the “they’ve tanks, we’ve got one another” selection), a late cameo from Tom Burke because the British Ambassador provides some much-needed rigidity to a slack third act.
Better of all, Burke’s one scene dramatizes a key facet of Joan’s character growth (particularly, her rising consciousness of tips on how to beat the WRON at their very own recreation), and does so in a means that is sensible of telling this story from a fish-out-of-water perspective. There’s at all times the chance of cheapening a historic movie by focusing it on a fictional outsider (normally somebody white who speaks English as a primary language), however “Winter of the Crow” builds to its climax by centering the ethical obligation that outsiders have to make use of their relative security as a protect for the oppressed. Joan might not look very similar to a hero, and she or he definitely doesn’t act like one a lot of the time both, however she will get the job carried out when it counts.
Grade: B
“Winter of the Crow” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Pageant. It’s presently looking for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Overview by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the perfect new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.