It’s Musicals Week at IndieWire. With “Depraved” about to glitter over theaters, we’re celebrating one of the best of the movie-musical style.
We’ll get the large query out of the way in which first: Do it is advisable to have seen “Depraved” on the stage to understand and perceive Jon M. Chu’s long-promised cinematic adaptation of the smash-hit musical? No. And sure. Both method, this spin on the magical story of a kinda magical land will push its viewers to hit the Wikipedia (the Wickie-pedia?) lengthy and laborious after it wraps up its stretched-to-the-breaking-point two-hour-and-40-minute working time. Even which may not assist contextualize all the mythology at play on this newest journey to the Land of Oz, however — ideally — it’s going to assist gloss over a few of the movie‘s extra awkward elements and crystallize the achievements inside Chu’s huge swing of a two-part epic.
And there are certainly achievements right here: Cynthia Erivo‘s singing is unparalleled, Ariana Grande is splendidly humorous, and the musical sequences should not simply handsomely, however whimsically mounted. You don’t have to have affection for the stage present to thrill in Jonathan Bailey spinning round a magical library whereas principally imploring everybody to be a egocentric asshole, although it could actually’t damage. By way of uncooked spectacle, the all-singing, all-dancing meat-and-potatoes of the musical, “Depraved” completely delivers. Each present followers and newbies will swoon over the long-lasting bangers, just like the fizzy enjoyable of “Well-liked” or the hovering energy of “Defying Gravity.”
However what of the remainder of it? A lot has been manufactured from the (nonetheless considerably secretive) option to divide the movie into two full motion pictures, releasing a 12 months aside (that we’re all nonetheless calling this primary movie merely “Depraved” positive doesn’t assist any simmering confusion). On paper, Stephen Schwartz and Winnie Holzman’s wildly profitable stage musical has a pure break — it’s known as an intermission, and it runs about quarter-hour for a cause — however one which proves a lot tougher to promote in cinematic trend.
The compromise? An elongated working time for each movies, with Chu’s first providing working almost so long as the whole stage musical. With all that added time: Beefier storylines, amped-up emotional bonds, greater backstories, extra of all that epic storytelling that made this “Wizard of Oz” prequel such a permanent entry on the Broadway boards and past. Properly, that was the concept.
The center of the story stays, even when it by no means feels as appropriately expanded (or expansive). To wit, the movie opens the identical method the musical does, with the dying of The Depraved Witch of the West (who we are going to come to know as Elphaba Thropp, performed by Erivo), which is being celebrated loudly and proudly throughout your entire kingdom of Oz. She, was, in any case depraved! Proper? Proper?! Cue bubble-aided entrance of the beloved Glinda the Good (Grande), who descends upon Munchkinland to smile wanly on the celebrants.
However when one of many Munchkins dares ask Glinda if there’s any fact to the rumor she and the Depraved Witch have been, gasp, mates, Chu’s movie kicks into precise gear, pulling us again in time to satisfy our two major witches once they have been youthful and, sure, about to develop into buddies. For Elphaba (performed as a baby by Karis Musongole), life isn’t a mattress of roses (or, as is extra seemingly in Oz, tulips). Ostensibly the daughter of the governor of Munchkinland, she’s actually the love baby of her hard-partying mother and a touring salesman, and due to causes we are going to study within the subsequent movie, she’s inexperienced. Due to the circumstances of her beginning and look, her “father” hates her, her youthful sister Nessarose (Marissa Bode) can by no means get too near her, and he or she’s the butt of fixed ridicule.
She’s additionally, as we see from the second she’s born, naturally gifted in magic. However when she and Nessarose alight for Shiz College, Ouncess premier magical college, Elphaba isn’t anticipated to attend. As an alternative, she’s there merely to ship Nessarose off to security and return to her ho-hum existence. Not so ho-hum? Galinda Upland (Grande), a queen bee of the best selection, who swans into Shiz like she owns the place. She may as nicely, and Grande’s cracking comedic timing and legendary pipes make her unattainable to hate, even when she’s making Elphaba really feel so very small.
However when Elphaba’s magical nature reveals itself in entrance of your entire college — together with headmistress Madame Morrible (Michelle Yeoh) and one of many few remaining Animal (that uppercase means he’s possessed of human language, enjoyable truth) professors within the type of a goat voiced by Peter Dinklage — she’s quickly enrolled within the joint, and positioned as Morrible’s primo scholar. Oh, and he or she has to room with Galinda, who takes it in addition to may be anticipated.
Sound like quite a bit? We’re about quarter-hour into the movie at this level, and a really good distance off from the formation of the true emotional heart of the movie — Elphaba and Galinda turning into BFF — that’s essential to make any of this really feel like greater than natty window-dressing.
What, we have now to surprise, do these folks need? Galinda says she needs to be a sorceress, however we all know she actually simply needs folks to suppose she’s “good.” Elphaba needs to satisfy the Wizard so she will be able to get her coronary heart’s need granted, a need that adjustments often all through the run of the movie: She doesn’t need to be inexperienced, she needs to be revered, she needs to avoid wasting the Animals. She’s finally politically activated as a result of she is aware of what it’s prefer to be made enjoyable of, however the trigger she takes up for Animal rights runs a lot, a lot deeper than that.
Everybody may titter at Fireyo (Bailey) for studying as so very shallow, however it’s Elphaba and Galinda who want to go searching, look exterior, and actually make a change “for good.” And, sure, they do (form of, although we anticipate the second movie will likely be way more devoted to some true character evolutions), although their fortunes and fears stay so sure up in one another that it’s powerful to gauge how this can all fly once they’re thrust into the broader world. With a virtually doubled working time from its supply materials, that world higher wager wider, and shortly.
Even with such an growth afoot, odd missteps, hinky plotholes, and confounding questions nonetheless abound. For example, Wikipedia certainly tells this critic that there are 4 major areas within the Land of Oz. In Chu’s movie, we don’t study a lot about any of them, not to mention the 2 which might be by no means seen (deepest apologies to each Winkie Nation and Quadling Nation). And, sure, this critic needed to flip to the web to study the place Shiz College is situated (it’s Gillikin Nation, positive).
And whereas Chu and his assuredly very gifted manufacturing group often trot out some gorgeous areas — the temporary glimpses of Muchkinland are pleasant, Shiz College is a gem, and the Emerald Metropolis is splendidly alive — a lot of the movie is devoid of the sort of scale and scope we’d hope to see on the large display. How do you so grievously biff imparting a way of place once we’re speaking in regards to the Land of Oz?
Additionally worrisome: the bigger place of magic on this intermittently magical land. Here’s a world by which magic is so frequent that there’s a whole college devoted to educating it, however the hows and whys of what magic is, the place it comes from, what its limits are, who will get it, the way it impacts the world round them, all of those questions should not solely not answered, they’re barely even requested. (We do anticipate, nevertheless, to study extra about Elphaba’s magical pedigree within the second movie, so there may be not less than that to look ahead to.)
Blowing out the story into two elements does enable for extra time spent with some characters, like Jonathan Bailey’s delectably himbo-coded Fiyero, whereas others must do with out ever having their very own names a lot as uttered (Bowen Yang, you might be, as ever, so humorous, however I had no thought you performed “Pfannee”). And nearly as good as Erivo and Grande are collectively — particularly when they’re singing and dancing by way of the musical’s iconic songbook and including their very own magic to those characters — it appears like, simply as their important bond is blossoming, we’re rolling credit.
And, sure, once more, that’s a part of the issue with dividing this story into two elements. It’s troublesome to totally and precisely choose this story with literal half-measures. Musicals are supposed to be huge, expansive, overstuffed, emotionally wealthy, so consuming that the idea of singing and dancing about it make all of the sense on this planet. Simply as “Depraved” begins hitting its highest notes, it’s over. For now. For an additional 12 months. And never for good.
Grade: B-
Common Footage will launch “Depraved” in theaters on Friday, November 12.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up one of the best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.