Some FBI fanatics have been clamoring for Nina Chase (Shantel VanSanten) to return to FBI ever because the heartbreaking information of FBI: Most Needed’s cancellation.
I get why. Nina and Scola are some of the strong {couples} within the FBI franchise, plus Scola can’t appear to discover a everlasting work companion.
However although it feels like a good suggestion on paper, Shantel VanSanten shouldn’t return to FBI as Nina.
Nina’s Return to FBI Would Undo The Most Necessary Purpose She Left
Nina and Scola prioritize their younger son, which is one cause they work in separate items.
Granted, Nina was not one in all TV’s greatest moms when she first conceived Dougie.
She wasn’t going to even inform Scola that she was pregnant, and he needed to combat to be a part of the household slightly than Nina elevating Dougie totally on her personal.
Nonetheless, as soon as they acquired over that hurdle, the couple started to think about severely how greatest to handle Dougie collectively, and that’s why they should keep in separate items.
Working individually isn’t nearly avoiding the looks of impropriety or shedding the flexibility to be goal out within the subject, although these are vital.
No, they need to be certain that somebody is all the time there for Dougie.
In a worst-case situation, each of Dougie’s dad and mom may very well be killed in the event that they went on a mission collectively.
There’s additionally a much less morbid, extra pragmatic cause: in the event that they aren’t working for a similar unit, Nina and Scola can stagger their schedules so that somebody is all the time house with Dougie.
On FBI: Most Needed it established that’s precisely what they do — if Nina has an enormous case, Scola makes positive to stay near house and vice versa.
That’s the most important cause that Shantel VanSanten shouldn’t return to FBI.
It could undo all of their planning for Dougie’s care in the event that they had been immediately thrown collectively once more.
That might additionally make them look like flaky dad and mom, and nobody desires that.
FBI Wants To Keep Targeted On Circumstances
The FBI isn’t a cleaning soap opera. It’s procedural, which suggests circumstances needs to be the primary focus.
For years, there have been debates about whether or not Maggie and OA needs to be a pair, and a few followers need extra Scola and Nina drama.
I’m not concerned with any of that. There’s nothing fallacious with romance in procedurals — a bit of that form of stuff retains issues attention-grabbing — however when you watch any of the Chicago exhibits, you understand what occurs when Dick Wolf exhibits get overrun by romantic subplots.
It’s so unhealthy that typically I’m unsure if I’m watching Chicago Med or Basic Hospital.
I don’t need that to occur to FBI.
Scola and Nina undergo some issues typically, which is ok, however we don’t want it week in and week out.
In the event that they had been each on the identical present, I’m afraid they’d have conflicts each week—the writers won’t know what else to do with them now that they’re in the identical place.
Storywise, this couple appears to do higher with extra space.
Every time they’re collectively, they discover one thing to combat about, and a few of these points are fairly vital.
We have already got Jubal’s dysfunctional relationship together with his ex-wife and all this hypothesis about Maggie and OA, so we don’t want this.
The one different choice for storylines for Nina, outdoors of circumstances, can be her conflicts along with her dad and sister.
That is one other battle that works higher on a short-term or restricted foundation.
I HATED it on Regulation & Order: SVU when Rollins’ sister got here to city.
Each Kim Rollins episode was a waste of display time that might have been spent on an precise case as a substitute of constructing Rollins silly or determined as a way to construct a narrative round her sister.
I doubt it might be any higher if Nina’s household had been in FBI an excessive amount of.
If something, it might be worse as a result of FBI is much extra procedural-focused than Regulation & Order: SVU.
I’m Not Saying Nina Can’t Visitor Star As soon as In A Whereas
Her latest go to to the New York Area Workplace was enjoyable.
Shantel VanSanten shouldn’t return to FBI full-time, however I don’t thoughts her popping up sometimes.
She does have a relationship with Scola, in any case.
All I ask is that when she does go to, it’s extra worthwhile than Rollins’ latest visits to Regulation & Order: SVU.
Over to you, FBI franchise fanatics.
Do you assume Nina ought to return to FBI after FBI: Most Needed ends?
Or has this character run her course for you?
Vote in our ballot, then head to the feedback to share your ideas.
FBI: Most Needed’s collection finale will air on NBC on Might 20, 2025, at 10/9c and stream on Peacock starting on Might 21, 2025.
Watch FBI On-line
Watch FBI Most Needed On-line
TV Fanatic is looking for passionate writers to share their voices throughout varied article sorts. Suppose you have got what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click on right here for extra info and subsequent steps.