Timothée Chalamet Inhabits Bob Dylan’s Mysteries in A Full Unknown: Assessment

The Pitch: In 1961, a younger man rides a motorbike as much as the hospital the place Woody Guthrie is being cared for and introduces himself as Bob Dylan (Timothée Chalamet), and he performs a music on the guitar for his people hero. From there, the early years of Dylan’s profession unfold, as he chafes in opposition to the music business’s expectations, connects with different seismic figures like Joan Baez (Monica Barbaro) and Pete Seeger (Edward Norton), and ultimately evolves into one of many twentieth century’s most necessary musical artists.

The Occasions They Are A’Altering: Author/director James Mangold’s A Full Unknown shines in its specifics, bringing to life Greenwich Village within the early Nineteen Sixties on an actual and tangible stage. Not solely that, however the musical group into which Dylan slipped throughout that point feels absolutely realized, from venues which may appear unconventional immediately to the business occasions Bob will get reluctantly dragged to — all of it vital scene-setting for the movie’s climax, set on the notorious Newport People Competition the place Dylan defied the fest’s organizers and performed on stage with electrical devices.

The fully-realized portrait explores not solely how Dylan emerged on the music scene within the early Nineteen Sixties, however the methods by which he’s at all times held himself again from public scrutiny: He begins the movie within the course of of making his personal picture, and by the top we’ve seen his future spelled out within the actions of the current. That future is one in every of revolution, as we witness Dylan’s expertise come out as each a performer and a songwriter, discovering his personal distinctive sound regardless of makes an attempt to maintain him confined in sure bins.

Certain for Glory: Timothée Chalamet, Consequence’s Movie Performer of the 12 months, earns his accolade by a dedication to craft — not simply studying to play the guitar and harmonica, but additionally grasp Dylan’s vocal inflections each in music and in speech. What’s outstanding about his work is that it by no means appears like mimicry, his intonations absolutely embedded within the essence of Bob with out feeling pressured, and he by no means struggles to seize the form of quiet conceitedness that outlined Bob’s public persona at sure factors.

Moreover, Monica Barbaro proves greater than succesful at capturing the fervour and energy of Joan Baez, particularly within the moments the place Bob’s pissed her off, and deserves to be known as out for it. It’s one factor to ship musical efficiency; it’s a complete different factor to carry out a music completely and professionally whereas additionally speaking to the digicam how mad you might be on the man singing subsequent to you.

It’s the form of magic solely potential due to a gifted performer actively doing all of it dwell. Total, the movie’s use of those efficiency sequences, that includes the forged performing dwell, is remarkably efficient: Edward Norton’s portrayal of Pete Seeger options him at his most affable, and there’s one thing so charming about watching him lead a crowd by “The Lion Sleeps Tonight (Wimoweh).” And whether or not strumming his approach by another person’s people music or diving into the world of rock and roll, on stage Chalamet is electrical. (Sure, that pun was intentional.)

A Full Unknown (Searchlight Photos)

As soon as Was a True Love of Mine: A Full Unknown’s greatest concern will be summed up by the character of Sylvie Russo, primarily based on Dylan’s real-life paramour Suze Rotolo — famously the girl featured on the album cowl for The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan, however an artist, activist, and author in her personal proper.

Because the fictional Sylvie, Elle Fanning is absolutely engaged all through, however the scenes together with her character pull the film into the biopic tropes it in any other case largely avoids. It’s greater than honest to convey up {that a} musical artist might need points in terms of his relationships with girls, however regardless of the mentions of the very cool and fascinating life she’s already main, Fanning’s position within the film typically descends into the nag who doesn’t perceive.

This actually comes out when Bob invitations Sylvie to return with him to Newport ’65, solely including to the chaos of these occasions. It’s depicted because the true finish of their relationship after an earlier breakup, although she finally ends up feeling like a superfluous character, as her presence in these scenes does nothing greater than to remind the viewers of how poisonous their relationship was. It’s particularly pointless when you think about that there’s no clear proof the true Suze was ever at Newport.

The Verdict: The title of this film couldn’t be a greater encapsulation of not simply Dylan as a determine of thriller, however the impossibility of the music biopic as a style. A troublesome relationship with a Girl Who Simply Doesn’t Perceive isn’t the one trope that makes it into A Full Unknown (there’s a literal Exhausting Day’s Evening-style running-from-the-fans second, as one other instance).

These tropes don’t undercut any of the performances, however do hold the film from feeling as contemporary because it may. But such tropes are onerous to keep away from, as a result of the factor about telling tales about our best artists is that they typically have rather a lot in frequent. A Full Unknown manages to keep away from the worst of it not simply with its deal with a set time interval, however extra importantly with its acceptance of the truth that for a determine like this, we’re by no means actually meant to grasp the complete scope of the person he’s. As a result of it doesn’t matter if we perceive Bob Dylan or not. We simply want to understand what he did.

The place to Watch: A Full Unknown arrives in theaters on December twenty fifth.

Trailer: