When The Means Residence launched Thomas, he wasn’t simply one other love curiosity.
He was a breath of contemporary air — emotionally clever, grounded, and one way or the other much more compelling for current totally previously.
His reference to Kat felt sudden however deeply earned, unfolding over time with out the load of nostalgia or expectations.
After which he was gone.
Nicely, not gone precisely. Thomas continues to be within the 1800s — proper the place we left him — however the present has made it clear that Kat’s story is transferring on with out him.
His arc was closed with a heartfelt goodbye in 1816, a wistful look exchanged between him and Elliot, and the sort of narrative finality that feels extra like a sigh than a interval.
It was refined, elegant, and, if we’re being sincere, just a little devastating.
Thomas Was By no means Meant to Be a Distraction
Thomas was Jacob’s good friend — somebody Kat met throughout some of the emotionally intense chapters of her journey by time.
He wasn’t there to tug focus from Elliot. He wasn’t a rebound. He was somebody who supplied Kat a love story rooted within the model of herself that had grown and developed throughout timelines.
It wasn’t the sort of love that screamed to be observed. It whispered and steadied. It confirmed up.
And in the midst of all of the chaos, Thomas offered one thing nobody else may: the possibility for Kat to decide on one thing new, one thing exterior the patterns she’d been reliving for many years.
However ultimately, the pond didn’t let him comply with her, and the present didn’t let him keep.
Goodbye Felt a Lot Like Closure — However Was It?
On The Means Residence Season 3 Episode 7, Thomas tries to comply with Kat by the pond however fails.
She says goodbye to him in 1816 throughout The Means Residence Season Episode 9.
And when Elliot exhibits as much as assist Elijah rebuild his cabin, he and Thomas alternate a look that felt lots like a symbolic baton move.
It was tastefully completed, certain. However that’s additionally what stings.
As a result of whereas Elliot’s arc continues to be unfolding — filled with longing, ambiguity, and open-ended emotional threads — Thomas was folded up and shelved like a completed guide.
And but, his story doesn’t really feel completed. Not likely.
Jasper’s point out of an ancestor who made his solution to New York and finally returned to Port Haven hints at a broader legacy.
Might that be Thomas? In that case, when did he depart? When did he come again?
Why introduce that breadcrumb if the writers don’t plan to comply with it?
Thomas Deserved Extra Than to Be a Narrative Detour
Even when Kat’s path was all the time going to steer her again to Elliot (and I’m nonetheless not satisfied it ought to), Thomas didn’t should be forgotten within the course of.
He may’ve remained a part of the present’s emotional tapestry — a logo of what may’ve been, of how love throughout time adjustments you, even when it ends.
As an alternative, we acquired a clear lower, a curtain drop, a bittersweet smile, and a closed door.
And for those who had been Staff Thomas like I used to be — like lots of us had been — it’s arduous to not really feel like we misplaced one thing particular.
We’re Nonetheless Speaking About Thomas for a Purpose
If Thomas actually is gone, then I’ll take the story for what it was — a time-crossed romance that burned quietly and left its mark.
However I can’t assist feeling like there was extra to inform.
Possibly he made it to New York, perhaps he constructed a life, and perhaps the pond has plans we don’t perceive but. Or perhaps The Means Residence merely selected to depart him previously so Kat may cease residing there.
Both approach, Thomas mattered. And we’re nonetheless speaking about him as a result of the present made us care.
If in case you have any lingering ideas about Thomas’s arc, please share them within the feedback under. Love Dwell Thomas Coyle!
Watch 1923 On-line
