Paul Simon would doubtless describe Arsin (Yesl Jahseleh), the younger Kazakh boy on the middle of Jing Yi’s function debut “The Botanist,” as the one dwelling boy in Xinjiang. Lonely and introspective, Arsin spends most of his time wandering round his distant village amongst its flora. When he’s not accumulating plant samples for his private assortment, he takes care of his grandmother and helps his disgraced older brother (Jalen Nurdaolet) herd sheep within the hills. More often than not, nonetheless, Arsin lives in a wealthy inside world the place his deep connection to nature and recollections of departed household, particularly his beloved lacking uncle, are inextricably certain.
“The Botanist” embraces nomadic Kazakh beliefs about useless souls persevering with to reside inside the pure world, one of many movie’s many liminalities. Arsin’s frequent bouts of sleepwalking maintain him in a perpetual dreamlike state. He and his household reside in a border village inside an autonomous area of China; individuals often journey backwards and forwards to neighboring nations, like Kazakhstan, in addition to different Chinese language provinces. The village itself is caught in a tenuous house between its rural roots and the fashionable world. Arsin’s older brother’s mobile phone appears like a minor technological disruption when juxtaposed in opposition to the placid environment, however ominous radio transmissions that trace in the direction of pure gasoline extraction coming to the area prophesies irreparable change.
Jing situates “The Botanist” in a woozy allegorical context the place individuals and crops are indistinguishable from each other. Arsin not solely feels related to his household in nature, however he additionally likens Meiyu (Ren Zihan), a neighborhood Chinese language woman whom he befriends, to a uncommon plant as properly. Visually talking, Jing takes an everything-but-the-kitchen-sink strategy to collapsing the movie’s human characters and its huge panorama right into a single fluid entity. Typically he not-so-subtly suggests it with pictures of Arsin tenderly working his fingers by a flowing river. Different instances, he deploys surreal folkloric imagery, like when Arsin speaks to his misplaced uncle within the type of a speaking horse, which may’t assist however recall tv’s famed Mister Ed.
An impassioned sincerity programs by “The Botanist” that’s as a lot a function as it’s a legal responsibility. Jing and cinematographer Vanon Li may depend on the occasional spinoff shot, however they nonetheless have an apparent capability for crafting robust photos. They principally handle to imbue Xinjiang’s vibrant flora with the required visible awe, however in addition they carry that very same beneficiant eye to the remainder of village, particularly its serene, sparse tracts of land. (A large shot of two sheep herds colliding in a desert basin casually stuns with its docu-style simplicity.) Recurring sluggish pans throughout a forest could danger repetition, however Jing and Vanon break up the rhythm with welcome intrusions, like intimate handheld depictions of youngsters at play and an ethereal close-up shot of a finger swiping by pictures on a cellphone.
Jing’s facility with younger, non-professional actors additionally helps attracts out an understated efficiency from Yesl, who rises to the problem of commanding the body by restricted actions like strolling and staring pensively. However whereas Yesl and Ren exhibit plausible chemistry, and each are able to projecting melancholy at key moments, Arsin and Meiyu’s romantically-charged friendship feels too skinny to make up the movie’s (admittedly free) narrative spine. Indirect glances shared between two individuals can solely talk a lot, or so little, earlier than they develop into a artistic crutch.
Furthermore, Jing evades the very fact of Arsin and Meiyu’s totally different ethnicities — Kazakh vs. Han Chinese language — by filtering their relationship by a vaguely outlined botanical metaphor. (Completely different floral species can coexist in concord, or one thing.) It’s acceptable for “The Botanist” to handle political realities by suggestion, but it surely generally looks like the characters’ totally different cultural backgrounds are hardly a priority in any respect, which barely negates the supposed unlikelihood of their connection.
An insistently weighty voiceover recurs all through “The Botanist,” delivering each exposition and expressions of craving from Arsin’s perspective. Not solely does the clumsy narration function the movie’s weakest writing, but it surely additionally lays naked some shallow thematic ideas. “The Botanist” wouldn’t be the primary movie to contend that love and religious connection can stand up to transformation or transcend time, but it surely takes greater than an earnest presentation to make sure these concepts don’t appear trite, even after they’re delivered from the voice of a kid.
As a lot as “The Botanist” chronicles Arsin’s inside coming of age, it’s his older brother that often feels just like the richer topic. Having fled the large metropolis within the aftermath of a violent incident, he now spends his free time calling an outdated girlfriend and getting drunk whereas typically neglecting his shepherding duties. A quintessential Chinese language younger grownup, the brother feels disconnected from the stillness of rural life and the pace of the town, but he nonetheless retains a foot in each worlds simply to have choices. Arsin initially sympathizes together with his brother’s existential wrestle from afar, however when he abruptly decides to return to the town, the younger boy appears to out of the blue understands his aimlessness.
It’s a testomony to Jing’s confidence as a younger filmmaker that he basically sidelines an emotionally potent narrative strand in favor of private exploration. Jing was born and raised in Xinjiang and he clearly imbues “The Botanist” together with his personal previous. (Each Yesl and Ren are additionally from Xinjiang, which contributes to the movie’s common lived-in feeling.) His connection to the area actually informs the trancelike ecological imagery that underpins Arsin’s psycho-spiritual journey. Humanity’s tender, fraught relationship with the pure world has a storied historical past on movie, however in “The Botanist,” it might probably generally really feel like an unearned shortcut to grazing the elegant.
Grade: B-
“The Botanist” premiered on the 2025 Berlin Worldwide Movie Pageant. It’s at present in search of U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Overview by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the most effective new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.