Logic means that rogue CIA murderer Jason Bourne may be a lot much less of a menace if — as a substitute of a shredded authorities super-soldier with a sniper’s accuracy and no private attachments — he had been a vaguely autistic spouse man who couldn’t hit somebody with a bazooka in the event that they had been standing proper in entrance of him. James Hawes’ “The Newbie” begs to vary.
An aggressively competent spy thriller that has much less use for logic than its lead actor does for his smile, this globe-trotting Robert Littell adaptation would have us imagine that nobody is extra harmful than a math nerd who refuses to think about himself as a killer, and the movie makes a compelling sufficient case to maintain itself throughout your complete tv season’s value of plot that it packs into two hours. Rami Malek has made that argument earlier than, in fact, and the “Mr. Robotic” star’s resolution to play one other socially maladapted hacker kind means that he would slightly weaponize his established strengths than appropriate for his weaknesses — an oddly becoming alternative for the savant-like cryptographer he performs right here.
An unblinking human sweater vest who’s married to a beatific Rachel Brosnahan, Langley-based cryptographer Charlie Heller loves precisely three issues on this world: His spouse, his spouse, and sifting by confidential information units to be able to decide that unknown members of the CIA have been assassinating targets within the Center East and blaming the kills on suicide bombers. However principally he loves his spouse. When Sarah asks Charlie to make him a cup of espresso within the morning, he replies “in fact!” with the keenness of a canine who’s simply been requested if it needs to go for a stroll; in a spy film so humorless it makes “The Good Shepherd” appear like “Goldmember” by comparability, Malek’s sincerity in that second is the closest factor we get to fun.
Sadly for Charlie, Sarah so clearly exists to get fridged that she would possibly as effectively be a bit of Tupperware. And so, when our mild-mannered hero’s spouse is taken hostage — and killed execution fashion — whereas on a enterprise journey to London, Charlie is the one particular person on Earth who appears to be stunned. CIA Deputy Director Alex Moore (Holt McCallany, born for this) definitely is aware of greater than he lets on, even when his boss (Julianne Nicholson in full “Paradise” mode) appears to be at nighttime.
When Charlie resolves to search out the lads who killed Sarah, Director Moore solely agrees to let the twerpy pc genius get some much-needed area coaching as a result of a firing vary is a extremely handy place to place somebody who you would possibly wish to shoot “accidentally.” That grotesque job would fall to Robert Henderson (Laurence Fishburne), a slightly Morpheus-like mentor who looks like he’s losing his time on a superb man who doesn’t have what it takes to tug the set off. And Robert is true on each counts: Charlie is sensible sufficient to slide off to Europe earlier than the CIA has the prospect to wipe him off the board, and likewise gutless sufficient that he tries to commit his first kill with… pollen.
And so it goes for a cloak and dagger yarn that makes use of its outward seriousness as a canopy for the silliness at its core — a canopy that it maintains with the assistance of Volker Bertelmann’s sawing, “Conclave”-loud violin rating. Nonetheless, “The Newbie” by no means forgets its true identification, and whereas Hawes’ earlier characteristic, the Holocaust-tinged biographical drama “One Life,” presents a surprisingly correct preview of the tone at work right here, the movie seldom takes itself as significantly as its po-faced spycraft would possibly counsel. Think about a film shot to resemble a much less shaky model of “The Bourne Identification,” besides — within the first correct battle scene — our hero isn’t throwing down with a beefed out henchman a lot as he’s clawing at a middle-aged girl who’s in the midst of asphyxiating from an allergy assault. And he solely wins the bout on a technicality.
“The Newbie” doesn’t play any of this for comedy, however there’s one thing inherently humorous about Malek’s shock at his character’s personal capability for violence. At the same time as Charlie evolves right into a grasp hitman, he’s nonetheless caught off guard by the sounds of his personal explosions, and — because it criss-crosses Europe from one goal to the following — the film is sustained by the way in which that Malek permits the character’s discomfort to develop alongside his confidence (the previous expressed by the actor’s eyes, the latter solely with the purpose of his chin).
By that, and by the all too uncommon resolution to (clearly) shoot on location. As far as “Bourne” wannabes go, this one is terrible mild on motion, however Hawes makes use of the cash he saved on huge stunts to shoot Malek scurrying by the nightclubs of Marseille, the hilly streets of Istanbul, and a handful of different very actual locations that every one mix to lend the motion — or lack thereof — a level of motion that’s credible sufficient to disguise how Ken Nolan and Gary Spinelli’s screenplay prefers to spin in circles.
Operating a well-paced two hours, “The Newbie” doesn’t have time to stuff in the entire stuff that its story requires to be able to make (sufficient) sense by the tip, which forces an important thread just like the departmental pissing match between Charlie’s CIA bosses to really feel like a supplemental B-plot slightly than one thing that’s inextricable from Charlie’s mission. The identical may very well be stated of Fishburne’s character, whose allegiance is extra enjoyable to trace than his whereabouts, and of Jon Bernthal’s two-scene efficiency as a badass area agent referred to as The Bear (lol), who exists to personify the form of spy film we’re used to seeing.
Even main points of Charlie’s emotionality are likely to fall by the wayside, as “The Newbie” — extra confident than its essential character, however equally unwilling to get its palms soiled — solely glancingly connects the dots between its protagonist’s extra-judicial killings and those the CIA is attempting to maintain coated up. The implication is that fashionable know-how has turned homicide right into a coward’s sport, because the rising distance between weapons and their targets invitations the form of ethical disconnect that enables individuals to deceive themselves (and their nation), however the disconnect between Charlie and his handlers is simply too huge for both of them to render dramatically fascinating judgment on the opposite.
If the film wags its finger at Charlie as he closes in on the person who executed his spouse (Michael Stuhlbarg as a bearded German baddie), that’s solely as a result of the seriousness of its tone requires “The Newbie” to gesture towards depth, simply because the absurdity of its plot sometimes requires “The Newbie” to remind us that it’s not that critical — which it accomplishes with the assistance of some ridiculously angelic visions of Sarah, dead-wifing so arduous that it looks like she’s hoping to be reincarnated right into a Christopher Nolan movie. That balancing act leads to a spy journey that’s neither enjoyable nor boring, and in virtually precisely equal measure. However there’s little doubt that Charlie is harmful, and I wouldn’t be against a sequel the place he’s compelled to determine what to do with that info; a sequel wherein neither he nor the potential franchise round him can write off its errors as rookie errors.
Grade: C+
twentieth Century Studios will launch “The Newbie” in theaters on Friday, April 11.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Overview by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the most effective new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.