Co-directed by Charlie Kaufman and Duke Johnson, 2015’s “Anomalisa” instructed a strolling nightmare of a narrative a few motivational speaker who perceives (virtually) everybody he meets to be the identical similar stranger. All of them share the identical face, all of them converse with the identical voice, they usually all mirror the inescapable self-absorption of the primary character, whose hell is that he can solely see the world by way of the prism of his personal two eyes.
“The Actor” — Johnson’s solo characteristic debut — is a equally dream-like movie a few man affected by the precise reverse drawback. His title is Paul Cole (a fantastically dispossessed André Holland, mining wealthy layers of terror from the concern of forgetting one’s position in life), he’s a rising star of the New York stage, and we’re first launched to him on a darkish and fateful evening within the fictional city of Jeffords, Ohio, the place his theater troupe has simply carried out their newest present. Paul takes a neighborhood gal to his lodge room for a nightcap, which evokes the gal’s husband to take a chair to Paul’s head.
When our hero wakes up in a hospital mattress the subsequent morning, he finds himself bothered with each retrograde and anterograde amnesias; he doesn’t know who he’s, nor does he have the power to create a brand new character for himself to play. Paul can see the remainder of the world simply nice (and in some respects, perhaps much more clearly than earlier than), however his hell is that he can solely see himself by way of the eyes of different individuals.
So begins a spectral and somnambulant little temper piece that lacks the power wanted to impress its haziness into one thing you may have the ability to maintain onto, however nonetheless feels vivid sufficient to carry viewers in its spell. Like all dream price sharing, it’s acquainted sufficient to acknowledge the place it got here from and unusual sufficient to not know the place it’s going.
Whereas Kafkaesque amnesia noir is virtually a micro-genre unto itself, Johnson’s movie — tailored from the Donald Westlake novel “Reminiscence,” which the writer wrote in 1963 however stored like a secret till after his dying — stands aside due to its abject disinterest in its central thriller. This isn’t a film a few man attempting to piece collectively the lacking fragments of who he’s, it’s a film a few man whose profound lack of ability to take action forces him to confront the concept that id isn’t one thing that may ever be discovered within the first place. Quite the opposite, it’s one thing that may solely be carried out, which proves fairly troublesome for an actor who out of the blue can’t bear in mind any of his strains.
Like that of the protagonist in “Anomalisa,” Paul’s situation is inexorably surreal in nature, and but on the identical time it’s additionally one thing that every one of us expertise to 1 extent or one other throughout each second of our waking lives. Johnson is fascinated by how each of these issues could be true without delay — by the shaky building of human id, and the way simply it may well all collapse upon itself like a home of playing cards.
The place the Lynchian psycho-comedy of “Anomalisa” mirrored that tenuousness by way of its use of stop-motion animation, “The Actor” does by way of the shifting fluidity of stagecraft. Cities are made out of painterly miniatures, inside areas are designed to resemble units, and the transitions between them are sometimes executed with the theatrical brio of a lighting change; the one areas that really feel even glancingly “actual” are the inside of the small-town movie show the place Paul first meets a fantastic stranger named Edna (an arrestingly lovestruck Gemma Chan), and the tv set the place he experiences for his first bit half because the incident. The entire movie is saturated with an amber glow that forbids you from taking any of it at face worth, and — in one other echo of “Anomalisa” — virtually your complete supporting forged is performed by the members of Paul’s theater troupe, who rotate by way of any variety of completely different roles over the course of this story.
Toby Jones first seems because the Ohio police officer who railroads Paul out of city with an unstated fringe of racial prejudice, after which once more just a few minutes later as a mortgage shark on the tannery the place the actor will get a job to assist pay his manner residence (the film is unstuck in time to some extent, but additionally clearly set within the mid-century America during which “Reminiscence” was written, earlier than id was refracted by way of the digital panorama). “Nosferatu” bird-eater Simon McBurney seems as a number of completely different docs, “Peaky Blinders” star Joe Cole is launched as Paul’s wannabe jazz musician BFF earlier than body-swapping right into a producer of the “Twilight Zone”-esque TV present that encases this film like a snow globe, and “Intercourse Training” breakout Tanya Reynolds transforms from a droll manufacturing unit time-keeper to a venomous New York scenester. The strangers in Paul’s world are so onerous to maintain straight that it seems like a cheeky joke when the ever-chameleonic Tracey Ullman reveals up as a supply of consolation (to start with, anyway).
The one one that stays mounted in Paul’s thoughts is Edna, whose affection for him raises the chance that his amnesia could be a possibility in its personal proper; that his lack of ability to recollect who he’s could be the perfect likelihood he’ll ever must change into another person. It’s implied — generally greater than implied — that Paul wasn’t the nicest man on the planet earlier than his mind damage knocked that man proper out of his head, and shedding his sense of self comes with the good thing about shedding his preconceptions of different individuals together with it. All of the sudden, Paul is as curious in regards to the world as actor ought to be, and free to improvise the place as soon as he may solely stick with his personal terrible script. Was he born to be an actor, or is that simply the one half he’s ever bothered to rehearse? Is New York his residence, or simply the place he’s been condemned to suppose he belongs? What’s falling in love if not an unsolicited invitation to rethink every thing you realize about who you actually are?
Cuttingly humorous at occasions, “The Actor” isn’t a lot desirous about answering any of these questions, however this semi-inert dying journey of a movie teases a sure pull from its cosmic uncertainty. Slight as a nagging thought and infrequently carried alongside by nothing however the fidelity of Richard Reed Parry’s quavering noir rating, Johnson’s solo debut grows darker and extra distressing till Paul’s sense of self is made so inextricable from his reminiscences (or lack thereof) that he has no selection however to start out over from scratch.
The lingering magic of Johnson’s adaptation is positioned in how the director — together with co-writer Stephen Cooney — insist upon seeing the constructive in the opportunity of re-casting oneself, which marks a pointy break from the unalloyed cynicism of Westlake’s novel. “Twenty-five years from now you’ll reside in a neighborhood and also you’ll go to a job and your children’ll be rising up, and that’s simply the best way of it,” Westlake wrote. “The place you reside could be right here or New York Metropolis or San Francisco, however who you’re and what you’re and what you’ve bought to look again on might be all the identical factor.” To which Johnson’s movie merely provides: Act accordingly.
Grade: B-
NEON will launch “The Actor” in choose theaters on Friday, March 14.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.