Directing music movies is straightforward. All you need to do is sit there, act assured, and by no means let on that you haven’t any thought what you’re doing. The shopper is almost definitely an fool; inform them the top consequence shall be “cinematic” they usually often shut up. And if somebody actually begins to press, say that you just’ll “should verify along with your producer.” That may purchase you a while.
That is the recommendation that Pasqual (Pasqual Gutierrez) provides to the doppelgänger (sorta — he’s shorter, however no matter) he hires to take his place on the set of a giant artist’s “return to kind” in Gutierrez and Ben Mullinkosson’s playful docu-fiction hybrid “Critical Folks.” Doubles, and the concept of being changed by one, are sometimes the stuff of horror within the motion pictures. Right here, being replaceable is a aid, as Pasqual struggles to stability his profession as half of a profitable directing duo with the calls for of impending parenthood.
A way of winking absurdity permeates “Critical Folks,” which fortunately doesn’t take Pasqual’s world of clout chasers and self-proclaimed “hypebeasts” very severely in any respect. Pasqual acknowledges that it’s ridiculous to overlook the delivery of your first youngster since you’re filming a scene the place a rapper throws pretend cash at girls dancing on stripper poles. Nevertheless, infants are costly, and these jobs pay. Lots.
Sufficient to purchase the BMW convertible with the vainness plate that reads “CLIQUA,” the title Gutierrez makes use of for his tasks with RJ Sanchez. Sanchez additionally performs himself within the movie, and in actual life the duo have directed movies for Unhealthy Bunny, The Weeknd, Travis Scott, and Rosalia. In “Critical Folks,” it’s Drake — represented right here by his supervisor over Zoom, with a PA holding a laptop computer as his on-set surrogate — who’s making their lives troublesome. Pasqual and RJ’s partnership provides “Critical Folks” some actual stakes: If Pasqual’s plan goes incorrect, because it nearly definitely will, it’s not simply his profession that’s in danger. It’s RJ’s, too.
However essentially the most fascinating relationship within the movie isn’t between Pasqual and RJ, and even between Pasqual and his spouse Christine (Christine Yuan, additionally as herself), for whom he’s ostensibly staging this complete farce. The dynamic between Pasqual and his double Miguel (Miguel Huerta) is fascinating, for a few causes: First, Miguel is hilarious. Lots of the film’s quite a few laugh-out-loud moments come from Huerta and his efficiency, whether or not he’s utilizing tacky pickup strains on certainly one of Christine’s buddies or yelling about Marvel motion pictures and IMAX.
However Miguel — who comes from East L.A., similar to Pasqual — additionally represents Pasqual’s combined emotions about making it out of his previous neighborhood and into the inventive class. He’s cruder, extra confrontational, much less accustomed to the methods of attorneys and financiers than Pasqual and RJ. And as soon as he’s offered with the perimeter advantages of Pasqual’s place, he turns into his raging id and evil twin nearly instantly. However Pasqual defends him, saying that Miguel reminds him of himself. “It’s like a glorified mentorship,” he explains to an irritated RJ.
There’s an arch layer of racial commentary to Pasqual’s plan: The movie opens with a scene of Pasqual holding auditions for the position of himself (once more, shades of a horror movie, particularly Takashi Miike’s “Audition”). These cycle via a collection of Mexican-American “varieties,” the clean-shaven ones accented by a foolish paste-on costume mustache. And a giant inspiration for this nutty thought was the truth that folks typically confuse RJ and Pasqual. So, Pasqual cynically concludes, if the folks he works with can’t inform the distinction anyway, then any Mexican man who seems to be sufficient like him will do. Proper?
This all builds to a climax not not like an episode of “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” a comparability that’s supported by the circumstances underneath which “Critical Folks” was made. Scenes set at Pasqual and Christine’s rental have been shot at their precise dwelling; a baby-shower scene is full of their precise buddies, together with co-director Mullinkosson. The inception of the undertaking was not not like the inception of Pasqual’s scheme within the film, and the top credit present Gutierrez and Yuan with their real-life daughter, who was born shortly after the movie wrapped.
Yuan is definitely pregnant within the movie, and one draw back of “Critical Folks” specializing in Pasqual’s interior battle is that she’s too typically relegated to the nagging spouse position. She’s as humorous as the lads round her — “I want I used to be your cellphone, so you’ll be touching me on a regular basis,” she complains — and there’s a parallel film unfolding from her viewpoint the place her husband is step by step changed with a cockier fuckboy model of himself. The movie does save a while for tender moments, and a scene at an OB-GYN’s workplace makes a dry mockery of the American healthcare system that feels very a lot rooted in expertise. However the stability is a bit off, one other meta aspect in a film that’s constructed on them.
A lot of “Critical Folks” was improvised, with the leads taking part in fictionalized variations of themselves. Fortunately, they’re all charismatic people who find themselves used to the presence of cameras, so that they really feel pure on display screen. Extra importantly, nevertheless, this dynamic channels actual offscreen tensions into onscreen confrontations, which lends an emotional actuality to the state of affairs as Pasqual’s life spirals uncontrolled. The movie stumbles a bit on a number of climaxes, however recovers properly for a bitterly humorous stinger.
Even the visible type, which alternates between expressive closeups and passive vast pictures, displays the mix of artifice and actuality. No matter “actuality” means while you stay within the flashy world of superstar smoke and mirrors, anyway. When confronted with real-life challenges, a filmmaker’s first impulse is usually to make a film about it. Witty and self-deprecating, “Critical Folks” is the very best final result in that situation.
Grade: B+
“Critical Folks” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition. It’s presently looking for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.