It’s been mentioned that a number of filmmakers at Venice are displaying up with their “state of the world” motion pictures. Whether or not that’s Luca Guadagnino along with his tackle cancel tradition, Yorgos Lanthimos satirizing alt-right-style radicalization, or Kathryn Bigelow depicting our mutually-assured insanity in nightmarish vogue, lots of our most famed administrators appear to be taking a look at a world in flux and asking: “How did we get right here?”
Hosoda, a former Studio Ghibli animator who went freelance and has since change into one in all Japan’s most profitable auteurs, isn’t any totally different. His final movie, 2021’s “Belle”, was a sci-fi adaptation of “Magnificence and the Beast.” For his newest act, Hosoda hasn’t traveled too removed from that baroque fantasy setting, which was already extra idealized than the relative normality of his mainstream breakthrough hit (and Oscar nominee) “Mirai.” “Scarlet” is a unfastened however clearly meant rendering of Hamlet, with all of its castles and knights, ghosts and traitorous uncles — and much that isn’t in Shakespeare’s play, too.
One of many first strains of dialogue is Claudius (Kôji Yakusho) plotting the homicide of his brother; “I’ve lengthy dreamed of pouring poison into his ears”, he says, however the King is simply too well-liked and Claudius should as a substitute body him for plotting with a neighboring nation, thus enabling his execution. Scarlet (Mana Ashida), a younger princess, watches on distraught as her father’s ruthless executioners appear to relish of their job. After Claudius poisons her, Scarlet begins her exile into the “Otherlands,” a kind of purgatory, the place she plots her revenge alongside a horde of people that really feel equally wronged by their too-short lives.
However this can be a Hosoda film, so issues will change into significantly extra difficult from there. Very similar to Mirai’s acceptance that he’s not the person of the home, Scarlet’s most vital journey is one in all self-discovery — a quest removed from the violent quest for justice undertaken by the unique Prince of Denmark. However there may be a few of that, too. The Otherlands is a group of struggling individuals from all locations and time intervals, who can however perceive one another regardless of their variations. Scarlet’s journey by means of them will lead her to cross paths with quite a lot of characters, beginning with Hijiri (Masaki Okada), a nurse from modern-day Japan who refuses to persuade that he ought to have died. Quickly thereafter, Scarlet encounters a bit lady who says that if she had been a princess, she would spend her life ensuring the world was livable for little women like her. It’s sufficient for Scarlet to understand that vengeance is perhaps a bit self-centered; there are larger fish to fry.
The politics of the misplaced lots with out meals or a house shouldn’t be removed from James Gunn’s “Superman”, one other well-intended however pretty obscure expression of struggling peoples and the evil rulers depriving them of life and dignity. Scarlet’s enterprise is much more consciously knowledgeable by “Dune”, whose inheritor to the throne is radicalized to embrace the reason for his former antagonists. Hosoda’s movie poses an analogous query to Scarlet as Frank Herbert’s saga did to Paul Atreides: How a lot is that this story all about her? Hijiri is a paragon of selflessness who teaches Scarlet that dwelling for others is the one fulfilling means. Hijiri even questions her ruthless method to warriors despatched by her uncle to complete her off, telling Scarlet: “The final word warrior fires invisible arrows from an invisible bow.” That isn’t actually Scarlet’s fashion, and it’s most likely an excessive amount of to ask to place the weapons down whereas she’s actively being hunted. However Scarlet does notice she has the facility to enhance the lives of all of the individuals within the Otherlands — and even perhaps cease a few of them ending up there.
Sadly, Hosoda’s concepts in “Scarlet” by no means get extra incisive or attention-grabbing than that. There’s an over-sweet centre on the center of it. Its ending is a feast of sincerity that, not simply tedious in its personal proper, feels unrepresentative of the irreverent character with whom we’ve simply spent two lengthy hours. Regardless of bloody violence all through, “Scarlet” lacks the sting that might make this tradition conflict of seminal western story and Japanese artwork type as memorable or vital because it must be. The primary couple of minutes of the movie are a breathless, virtually wordless introduction to the Otherlands, with Scarlet trapped underneath rotting fingers clamoring to maintain her there. However Hosoda’s expressionism just about disappears thereafter, and a dry sense of order exerts itself as soon as the story is spirited again in the direction of Elsinore.
To that finish, “Scarlet” quantities to a irritating waste of animating and directorial ability for the value of an excessively bizarre story. The sheer scale of Hosoda’s success might have softened his storytelling instincts, even when the aesthetics are sometimes outstanding. Having written his previous 4 motion pictures alone, it might be time for Hosoda to think about collaborating as soon as once more. And possibly not with Shakespeare.
Grade: C+
“Scarlet” premiered on the 2025 Venice Movie Pageant. Sony will launch the movie in U.S. theaters on Friday, December 12.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the very best new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.