What have you learnt about Sally Trip? For Americans of a sure age, science wonks, area geeks, and feminist historians, the simplest reply is the obvious one: she was the primary American lady astronaut to go to outer area. However whereas Trip’s life — not less than, the skilled facets of it — pushed her into the highlight and turned her right into a public determine whose affect was beforehand unmatched, Trip went to nice pains to hide her most non-public secrets and techniques, wishes, and even id. Take into account this: most individuals had no concept Trip was a lesbian, not to mention one who had been in a dedicated relationship along with her companion for many years, till her demise in 2012, when it was talked about in her official obituary.
This, it appears, was not somebody desirous to be identified, and that’s the pickle documentarian Cristina Costantini finds herself in in relation to her documentary “Sally.” How do you deliver to the display the life of somebody who probably would have run from such a challenge? Costantini, a self-professed science nerd and lifelong Trip fan, makes an attempt to make {that a} characteristic of her movie, not a bug. Sure, Trip’s life was rife with tensions, each private {and professional}. So how will we construct a movie round that? Rigorously. Maybe too rigorously.
The doc combines each archival footage of Trip — essentially the most spectacular of which is culled from her time at NASA, a trove of crisp, thrilling insider seems at her coaching — and newly shot 16mm items that use actors to deliver Trip and long-time companion Tam O’Shaughnessy to life within the moments they wouldn’t, and even couldn’t, file as they had been taking place. O’Shaughnessy herself supplies among the movie’s voiceover narration, as does Trip, by the use of previous interviews re-contextualized in service to the comparatively commonplace method to telling a full life story.
The push-pull of Trip’s life was seemingly omnipresent, notably after she joined the primary class of potential NASA astronauts to welcome girls and minorities (NASA Astronaut Group 8), by the use of a handwritten software that touted her credentials and confirmed off her aptitude for self-promotion. One speaking head shares that Trip positively “favored being a golden lady” and her clearly aggressive spirit is apparent from the beginning, however quite a few interviews see her begging off her eventual title as the primary American lady in area (or, even earlier than she was picked for her mission, attempting to wave off the chance of it taking place).
However Trip had been used to saying one factor and doing one other for a very long time earlier than that. Trip and O’Shaughnessy truly met at pre-teens at tennis camp — O’Shaughnessy went on to play tennis professionally, and Billie Jean King, a mentor for each girls, seems as a part of a stellar and attention-grabbing assortment of speaking heads — however even O’Shaughnessy didn’t notice Trip was a lesbian till years later, even if Trip’s faculty girlfriend, Molly Tyson (who additionally seems), was one other one in every of their tennis friends.
When Trip and O’Shaughnessy renew their acquaintance after Trip’s NASA acceptance, O’Shaughnessy’s confusion over Trip’s wishes is comprehensible: in any case, she had married a fellow astronaut (Steven Hawley, additionally showing in interviews), maybe as a method to deflect among the cruel press consideration utilized to her private life. The press are simply terrible to Trip, solely ever proven asking her prying questions on her womanhood and femininity, a mirrored image of the time that also stings. The baked-in sexism of NASA can also be a prevalent theme, and one of many movie’s most shifting moments arrives within the ultimate act, through which one in every of Trip’s self-professed “male sexist pig” cohorts lastly acknowledges the err of his methods in an open-hearted letter to O’Shaughnessy.
Maybe, the scene tells us, some folks may change. However may Trip?
“Sally” presents loads of doable explanations for why Trip was the way in which she was, a lot of them rooted in her household life. To say her dad and mom had been emotionally closed-off is an understatement, and Trip’s mom even briefly seems to sit down for an interview with Costantini, throughout which the very idea of sharing her emotions (once more, about her useless well-known daughter) offends her so deeply, the chance she may stroll out feels all too actual. However even Trip’s sister Bear, who additionally got here out as a lesbian, struggles to know why Trip couldn’t put into phrases what was so clear to everybody else.
“Let Sally be Sally” finally grew to become one thing of a mantra for O’Shaughnessy, who was deeply pained by a few of Trip’s reticence all through their in any other case fairly loving life collectively. However who was Sally? Who did she assume she was? Who did she need us to see? “Sally” doesn’t fairly reply these questions, but it surely actually reaches for the celebs in an earnest try to seek out them.
Grade: B
“Sally” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition. It’s at the moment searching for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the very best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.