When “To Catch a Predator” aired as a part of “Dateline NBC” from 2004 to 2007, it drew the sort of reward that hardly ever met early actuality TV. It wasn’t simply actuality TV, it was a social good, a method of exposing males who would sexually prey on underage youngsters, a method of getting proof to convict males who confirmed plain intent to commit statutory rape. That is the sort of present of which even Jon Stewart, famously crucial of exploitative TV, stated, “I approve” when welcoming the collection’ host, Chris Hansen, on “The Every day Present.”
The present ended partly due to authorized entanglements associated to the demise of one of many alleged predators it had caught in considered one of its stings. Nearly 20 years later, it has spawned a whole universe of unauthorized spinoffs, some nonetheless involving Chris Hansen himself.
Now there’s a documentary about “To Catch a Predator” and its aftermath: “Predators,” directed by David Osit, who stopped by the IndieWire Studio at Sundance, introduced by Dropbox.
He by no means got down to make a documentary about “To Catch a Predator,” which he turned a fan of whereas in faculty.
“I didn’t assume it might be a lot of an attention-grabbing documentary,” Osit stated. “I noticed the present earlier than I used to be excited by filmmaking. After which I heard about how the present ended and a few loopy tales round it, however at first I didn’t assume a movie concerning the collection might be attention-grabbing different than simply as salacious true crime. After which at some point I encountered on-line some uncooked footage collected by way of the Freedom of Data Act, uncooked interrogation scenes that weren’t edited for TV that confirmed the fellows who had been caught being talked to in full. And watching that uncooked footage I felt actually dangerous for these guys since you are given the house to consider them as human beings. However then I’d take a look at a chat log after which really feel disgusted with them once more. After which I’d hear a telephone name between them and a decoy and be grossed out once more. So I stored having this emotional ping pong in my head and in my coronary heart.”
Watching clips from “To Catch a Predator” once more, it’s laborious to not assume this was twenty first century America’s type of public executions. You’re watching a life finish as leisure — not actually ending, however very a lot figuratively. Who would make use of these males once more? How would their households survive? Many could be prosecuted and serve jail time, in what was a singular collaboration between TV information and legislation enforcement.
“It’s the gallows definitely,” Osit stated. “It’s the stockades. We enjoyment of our society, and never simply right here in America, within the ache of different individuals, like Susan Sontag wrote a tremendous e-book about that. What’s attention-grabbing to me, and I internalized in making the movie, is that each one of us carry a twin reservoir of empathy and cruelty. We’re able to each of these issues, all of us are. And a present like this tapped into each of these and used it as fodder.”
By having 18-year-old actors, who look youthful than 18, gown and act provocatively, wasn’t there additionally a side to “To Catch a Predator” of the present exploiting victims and victims’ ache as properly?
“For me ‘exploitative’ was all the time one of many purple flag phrases that I wished to keep away from,” Osit stated. “I wished to do the other of what I felt this present did, which was flatten the world into good and evil, proper and flawed, dangerous and good. And I wished to present everyone at the least the prospect to say, ‘Why are you right here? Why do you do that work?’ And the solutions stunned me. Folks come to this work [taking up the mantle from Hansen himself] from totally different locations. I’ve by no means met anyone who thinks they’re evil or what they’re doing as flawed. Even individuals we disagree with or we elect to workplace, even when we disagree with them, they imagine in what they’re doing. What if I dug deeper and made it in order that audiences don’t have already got their minds made up for them? As a result of that’s what this sort of present really did do, and a lot true crime leisure: They flatten the world and say that you simply’re the nice guys for watching this program, the dangerous guys are in this system, after which it ends and you may pat your self on the again for being one of many good guys.”
Watch IndieWire’s full video interview with Osit above.
Dropbox is proud to associate with IndieWire and the Sundance Movie Competition. In 2025, 68% of function movies premiering on the Sundance Movie Competition used Dropbox of their movie manufacturing. Dropbox helps filmmakers and artistic groups discover, manage, and safe all of the information which can be vital to any mission.