From Jean Seberg’s sideswept pixie reduce to Jean-Paul Belmondo’s aviators, Jean-Luc Godard’s “Breathless” has turn into extra modern in immediately’s cultural creativeness for its iconic appears to be like and pictures than for a way the jump-cut-pioneering renegade characteristic collapsed cinematic hierarchies as we knew them in 1960. That makes one of many biggest movies of all time, and the usual bearer of the French New Wave, ripe for discovery for a youthful technology — and more energizing nonetheless for the older ones properly accustomed to it.
If one of the simplest ways to criticize a film, as Cahiers du Cinéma critic Godard as soon as stated, is to make one, then director Richard Linklater’s reply to creating a tribute to “Breathless” may as an alternative be to not fairly criticize however actually to subvert the tropes of flicks about moviemaking. His black-and-white “Nouvelle Obscure,” itself a meticulous recreation of a film made in 1959 with all of the celluloid, Academy-ratio crackle and pop, is extra New Wave hangout film than cinema historical past, with the parade of faces and names inspiring figuring out chuckles within the cinephile viewers.
Past Godard, appearances from Claude Chabrol, François Truffaut, Jacques Rivette, Robert Bresson, Agnès Varda, and extra figureheads — all performed by lesser-known actors with various likeness to their real-life counterparts — make for a veritable who’s-who soufflé extra akin to Woody Allen’s “Midnight in Paris” fin-de-siècle cosplay, the place run-and-gun appearances by literary and creative idols like Salvador Dalí, Gertrude Stein, Alice Toklas, Man Ray, Luis Buñuel, and Djuna Barnes offered little greater than window-dressing to a Belle Époque time journey train.
“Nouvelle Obscure” is deeper than that, although plenty of these namedrops exist with out context past “look, right here they’re.” It’s significantly amusing to play a type of “I Spy” recreation in “Nouvelle Obscure” as to who’s who within the ensemble — although the filmmakers take the guessing out with title playing cards that introduce every character as if in a Wes Anderson or, maybe, a Godard film that impressed somebody like Anderson. However “Nouvelle Obscure,” maybe by design, fails to make the case that “Breathless” was a groundbreaking endeavor in any respect. That’s maybe as a result of the on-the-ground, glue-and-paper-clips late-Nineteen Fifties crew on the time (in addition to perhaps besides Godard himself) didn’t know what that they had their palms on or what form it will take. Godard’s revolutionary crime drama a couple of man, a lady, and a gun comes off extra like a pet venture or perhaps a scholar movie right here, a part of each the charms and frustrations of “Nouvelle Obscure.”
Perpetually in darkish sun shades, newcomer Guillaume Marbeck performs Godard as little greater than a caricature of the person who lagged behind his Cahiers du Cinéma friends (Rivette and Éric Rohmer amongst them) by way of taking his cinephilia past the storied journal and in entrance of a film digital camera. However Marbeck cuts a rueful silhouette, a cigarette ever burnt to its nub in his palms, that might simply encourage some Instagram-friendly appears to be like if “Nouvelle Obscure” finds the proper viewers (and I feel a younger one is in the end what Linklater is after, right here).
Effectively-cast is Zoey Deutch as “Breathless” breakout Jean Seberg in her nascent prime, who made the movie 20 years earlier than she succumbed to psychological sickness and sure killed herself after turning into an FBI goal for her political beliefs (although her dying stays the topic of thriller and hypothesis, in locations just like the podcast “You Should Keep in mind This,” which presents an addictive season paralleling the careers of Seberg and Jane Fonda as Hollywood political outcasts). There’s little foreshadowing of the Seberg that might be, although when she’s not twirling in fountains in an A-line costume right here, Deutch wryly performs Seberg as a type of mischievous backstage drama queen, complaining concerning the beginner manufacturing and its lack of sync sound to her disaffected husband, the filmmaker François Moreuil (Paolo Luka-Noé) — her first of some poisonous husbands.
Seberg was largely fluent in French, although Deutch (who perhaps isn’t) warmly captures the actress’ charmingly horrible American accent — and even nails the intonation of “New York Herald Tribune!” There’s additionally reference to her fraught collaboration with Otto Preminger — he burned her on the stake fairly actually for “Saint Joan” (1957) and challenged her on the set of her coming-of-age breakout “Bonjour Tristesse” (1958), the film that impressed Godard to forged her.
These experiences should have made coping with somebody like Godard, who wrote that day’s script pages for “Breathless” over breakfast throughout the two-week shoot, and recurrently threw out stated pages or balked at his collaborators who accused him of shirking eyeline and continuity conventions. One in all this movie’s huge laughs comes from Belmondo (Aubry Dullin) bloodied and operating by the road for the “Breathless” finale, reassuring Parisian passers-by that it’s solely a film. Among the callbacks to parts of “Breathless” outdoors the recreated manufacturing put on skinny, just like the repeated use of “dégolas,” in reference to one of many 1960 film’s nice quotable strains, outdoors of context. There’s a little bit of tee-hee you-get-it-right? to its inclusion in an early scene between Godard and his producer, Georges de Beauregard (Bruno Dreyfürst).
There’s a buddy comedy aspect to Godard’s at instances tempestuous relationship together with his producer that makes for a few of this movie’s most trenchant inquiries into the filmmaking mindset. “Paying audiences get pleasure from a proper narrative,” he cautions Godard as disasters on “Breathless” pile up — a wink to how resistant audiences have been towards experimentation in favor of simpler, blandly reassuring tales that let you know really feel, and when, and why. That hasn’t modified, as everyone knows, because the indie movie hemisphere continues to dangerously contract. Linklater has lengthy been an impartial filmmaker who’s solely courted the studio system (his current Netflix premiere “Hit Man” is definitely his most industrial movie thus far, although there have been others) with out ever being requested to adapt (“Waking Life” or “A Scanner Darkly,” anybody?). There’s no query Linklater identifies with Godard and is, like every filmmaker of his caliber and up to date, one frequently impressed by the French director’s iconoclasm and stylistic derring-do.
That stated, “Nouvelle Obscure” isn’t attempting to be a film that matches Godard’s type or temperament, however is nearer to the extra conventionally formed narratives pushed by a few of Godard’s much less canonical friends and plenty of imitators. Godard will get sage recommendation from Roberto Rossellini (Laurent Mothe) within the run-up to creating “Breathless”; I can’t corroborate whether or not this encounter ever occurred, however Linklater drops in comparable run-ins (like with Bresson capturing “Pickpocket” in a Paris subway tunnel) that serve extra to inform the story of the French New Wave, to seize its zeitgeist and power, than a coherent by-the-books retelling. Which might be a drag, anyway, whilst fastidious recreations of “Breathless” film moments may inform a distinct story. These French New Wave filmmakers, in any case, have been simply operating round Paris with cameras. Nonetheless, none have been fairly so making-it-up-as-they-went-along as Godard.
David Chambille’s celluloid cinematography and a interval jazz soundtrack immerse us on this world greater than the options of “Midnight in Paris” managed to, whereas Catherine Schwartz’s modifying strikes us by the “Breathless” manufacturing at a fast clip. However these parts might not, for a naive viewers, efficiently make the case for the brilliance of “Breathless” and the way its pulp and punch inform just about all the pieces such a youthful viewers watches today. Hopefully, “Nouvelle Obscure” encourages you to look again and watch “Breathless” once more — or for the primary time — however Linklater’s film might inadvertently counsel, “You possibly can simply watch this one as an alternative.”
Grade: B-
“Nouvelle Obscure” premiered on the 2025 Cannes Movie Competition. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the very best new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.