Initially, Homicide in a Small City started as a two-hour film thirty years in the past. Over time, it grew right into a mixed collection between Canada and FOX TV.
Homicide in a Small City Season 1 had its ups and downs because it tried to search out its footing and set up itself as a homicide thriller procedural.
Whereas we expect the collection would have benefited from extra episodes, it solely had eight, so it’s time to rank and evaluate its most memorable and least satisfying collection moments.
Greatest Episode: Homicide in a Small City Season 1 Episode 1
Possibly deciding on Homicide in a Small City Season 1 Episode 1 was a cop-out. Nonetheless, having an additional thirty minutes helped flesh out the tales and introduce viewers to the guts of the collection: Karl and Cassandra’s romance.
Inside minutes, there was a homicide, nevertheless it interspersed with the police chief and the native librarian assembly on a blind date. Not many police procedurals preserve a romance close to the forefront.
The premiere additionally labored as a result of James Cromwell gave a layered efficiency as George Wilcox. You suspected he killed his neighbor virtually instantly, however the motive was unclear.
As EP Jeff Wachtel shared, Cromwell gave an eerie efficiency as he hid the proof. You virtually felt sorry for Wilcox as a result of he watched his stepfather abuse his mother and sister, so he wished to save lots of his sister from her abusive husband, and he failed once more.
It additionally demonstrated that these instances weren’t black and white. Most of those suspects weren’t evil serial killers however the product of their childhood, which made them react.
Worst Episode: Homicide in a Small City Season 1 Episode 6
Homicide in a Small City Season 1 Episode 6 was probably the most disappointing episode, and it wasn’t solely as a result of it wasn’t based mostly on L. R. Wright’s materials. I consider Ian Weir and his staff knew the principle characters.
It bothered me that the collection made the psychiatrist, Dr. Lewis, evil. They wasted an actual alternative to go old-school and have her and Det. Alberg staff as much as analyze Shane and notice why he killed the politician.
As an alternative, it was all about energy, management, and having him do her soiled work.
Watching her play thoughts video games with Karl was painful, even when she was partly proper about Cassandra.
That made it damage worse. Although Karl was a very good man, Cassandra genuinely wanted a break to heal after her abduction.
Greatest Karl & Cassandra Second: They Notice They Need Every Different
There have been many moments when Karl and Cassandra had been collectively since they acquired collectively rapidly, and the collection pulled them aside.
Nonetheless, the perfect was once they realized they each wished their relationship to work out. Cassandra was proper. They tended to overthink issues, and that usually acquired in the way in which. Karl would all the time be a cop, and he or she would all the time communicate her thoughts.
They both wanted to simply accept these quirks or not. I liked that they gave in to their scorching chemistry.
Kristin Kreuk and Rossif Sutherland naturally play off one another’s banter, and he or she makes him loosen up extra.
Whereas we’re relieved they ended the season collectively, we want a second season to see the place this relationship evolves.
Greatest Supporting Character: Sergeant Sid Sokolowski
It was a toss-up between Sergeant Sid and Corporal Yen as a result of they each go the additional mile, however Sid has grow to be extra of a fan favourite.
His presence has helped the opposite characters, from guiding Karl as a father to bettering Corporal Yen’s vanity on the job.
However nothing was nearly as good as watching Sid soar right into a burning in Homicide in a Small City Season 1 Episode 3. He would have risked all the pieces to save lots of Karl’s life.
The instances generally affected Sid deeply as we discovered about his late sister’s drug downside. His compassion made him a greater cop.
Worst Supporting Character: Andy Kendrick
It usually felt like Fritzy Klevans-Destine was wasted as Andy Kendrick. He tried onerous, however he usually appeared to mess up, whether or not lacking some proof or flirting with a witness.
As Sid talked about, Kendrick survived on his appeal. That grew tiresome after some time.
One of the best half about him was his blossoming friendship with Corporal Yen, however she was extra fascinating to look at.
He redeemed himself by saving Karl’s life, however I’m uncertain how way more they will do with him.
Greatest Visitor Star: Erica Durance as Emma O’Brea
Homicide in a Small City featured many visitor stars, however reuniting Smallville’s Erica Durance and Kristin Kreuk was a particular deal with.
The women had wished to do a challenge collectively, and this one allowed them to showcase their real-life friendship as childhood pals within the collection.
They seemingly had extra layered scenes as Durance performed an agitated spouse anxious about her lacking husband.
Homicide in a Small City took benefit of Durance’s abilities, giving the episode a Gone Lady vibe. It was top-of-the-line episodes, partly due to Durance and Kreuk’s connection.
General Grade: B
It’s difficult to adapt mysteries and thrillers, and condensing one novel into an episode didn’t all the time work for this collection.
The case-of-the-week format labored for probably the most half. Nonetheless, some instances would have labored higher if they’d longer to breathe. This is the reason the collection premiere and two-part season finale performed the perfect.
Nonetheless, Homicide in a Small City included a number of positives. Along with Karl and Cassandra’s relationship, the collection boasted a robust supporting forged and excelling visitor stars.
Aaron Douglas and Mya Lowe might carry scenes when Sergeant Sid or Corporal Yen featured their character arcs. We will’t wait to be taught extra about them.
The collection pulled from well-known actors for visitor arcs, beginning with James Cromwell, however Stana Katic, Erica Durance, and Noah Reid had been in style selections, too.
If the collection will get renewed and some tweaks are made, it might have a greater second season.
Over to you, TV Fanatics. How would you charge Homicide in a Small City Season 1?
Tell us within the feedback.
Watch Homicide in a Small City 2024 On-line
