Are you able to blame a critic for wincing when a personality pulls out a notepad in the midst of a live performance? Cinematic depictions of criticism are often withering at greatest, and pointedly private at worst. Properly, critics can exhale whereas watching “Mile Finish Kicks,” the sophomore function from Canadian author/director Chandler Levack. Levack, herself a former critic, is cynical about a number of issues, however the act of criticism isn’t one in every of them.
Like her debut “I Like Films,” Levack’s new movie is predicated on her personal life experiences, particularly a summer time she spent in Montreal as a younger, aspiring author looking for herself. Her protagonist, Grace Pine (Barbie Ferreira), goes by way of an analogous arc, convincing herself — as so many younger individuals do — that transferring someplace cooler will repair her life. She’s additionally telling everybody that she’s writing a e-book about Alanis Morissette’s “Jagged Little Capsule,” by no means thoughts that she has neither a e-book contract nor a primary draft. Grace lately interned at an alt-weekly whose editor informed her she had promise as a author (extra on that in a bit). However actually, all she discovered there’s how snide and dismissive male rock critics could be towards youthful girls.
I don’t work there anymore, so it appears secure to disclose that my private nickname for the circle of white male gatekeepers on the publication the place I received my begin was “the plaid dads.” And, as with the intricacies of stocking at a suburban video retailer in “I Like Films,” “Mile Finish Kicks” will get the nuances of life as a younger feminine music critic proper. The situations are relatable — who amongst us has not anxiously ignored emails from an editor? — as are the conversations: The argument Grace interrupts, incomes derisive laughter from her coworkers, is over the deserves of various Hüsker Dü albums.
“Mile Finish Kicks” is ready in 2011, nevertheless it feels extra just like the late aughts — once more, correct — and the care put into the main points of Grace’s world is obvious from the opening credit, rendered within the modified Helvetica font of an American Attire advert. The reference reoccurs within the film’s most artfully shot scene, which follows Grace round a celebration with a highlight on her face, transferring alongside along with her. The flat, vivid mild creates a vignette impact paying homage to a Terry Richardson {photograph}, successfully evoking each the period and the sexual hazard that got here with it.
“Mile Finish Kicks” can also be particular to Montreal (look out for the Grimes lookalike, sniffing one thing off the rim of a bathroom at a loft social gathering), in addition to Canada as an entire. One monologue particularly in regards to the life cycle of a hip Canadian ought to slay with native audiences, though it rang true for somebody from the American Midwest as properly.
“Crimson Rooms” star Juliette Gariépy brings a French-Canadian aptitude as Grace’s DJ roommate Madeline, who begins off pondering that this dorky Ontario transplant who doesn’t converse French is form of lovely earlier than dropping her persistence with Grace’s unpaid lease and brazen fridge-raiding.
She’s not a very well-developed character; her position is to function a tour information/sounding board/eventual lesson discovered for our protagonist, which speaks to one of many weaker elements of Levack’s movie.
Grace could be a irritating protagonist, making silly, self-sabotaging choices in pursuit of fleeting pleasure and conditional approval from guys who, frankly, aren’t price her time. However that’s simply a part of what makes her actual. By comparability, a few of the supporting characters, notably (why mince phrases?) fool fuckboy Chevy (Stanley Simmons), are barely too exaggerated for the movie’s real looking milieu.
That is the place Levack’s cynicism is available in: It is a film that may’t imagine how dumb sensible girls act when there’s a person placing within the absolute naked minimal concerned. This sentiment comes throughout most clearly in a intercourse scene that’s each humorous and important to the plot, because the terminally detached Chevy actually simply lies there whereas a confused Grace does all of the work.
By comparability, his romantic rival Archie (Devon Bostick) is a weirdo, however a extra plausible one, and Bostick’s banter with Ferreira has a selected form of romantic chemistry frequent to hyperintelligent, socially awkward nerds. However once more, whereas it might be a byproduct of the self-absorbed protagonist’s viewpoint, the lives and motivations of every of those characters exterior of being two guys in the identical band vying for a similar girl’s consideration stay unconsidered. Then once more, it’s form of refreshing to have males taking part in the one-dimensional love pursuits in a film for as soon as.
At occasions, “Mile Finish Kicks” appears to be reaching for a broader, extra heightened fashion of comedy à la an ‘80s teen intercourse romp. A few of these jokes are humorous, however the shifts in tone are sudden, and it takes a number of beats for the movie to get better each time. Nevertheless, the truth that she will be able to pull them off in any respect speaks properly for the film Levack is presently making with Adam Sandler — utilized persistently over the course of a complete movie, she might fairly efficiently direct one thing fairly foolish.
The poignant bits, in the meantime, are persistently on level. A #MeToo-inspired workplace storyline (that’s the difficulty along with her outdated editor, performed contemptibly by Jay Baruchel) suits in higher right here than an analogous subplot in “I Like Films,” maybe as a result of it’s being skilled by the protagonist herself. It additionally offers us the movie’s most heartrending second, as Grace, who’s the final one within the workplace as normal, waves her arms to maintain the motion-sensor lights on, crying the entire time.
Ferreira is a plausible and sympathetic protagonist, bringing a vulnerability to Grace that makes the viewer root for her at the same time as she blows up her life for causes even she doesn’t appear to know. She needs to be a critic, however she additionally desperately needs to be favored. The stress between these modes is gendered, as Grace acknowledges when she lastly writes one thing that she believes in late within the movie. (It additionally helps that Grace, by way of Levack, is definitely a superb author.) Navigating that rigidity is one thing you be taught with expertise — the subject of Chandler Levack’s subsequent film, maybe?
Grade: B
“Mile Finish Kicks” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Movie Competition. It’s presently looking for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the very best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.