“Pee-wee as Himself” affords a refreshing distinction to superstar documentaries formed by estate-approved picture management. Director Matt Wolf approached the movie as a homosexual man profoundly influenced by “Pee-wee’s Playhouse” and its message of non-conformity — and as somebody desirous to unpack the complexity of Paul Reubens, a superb artist who re-entered the closet and disappeared behind his iconic persona to thrive in Hollywood.
Nevertheless, Wolf didn’t anticipate the mission to just about break him. It modified him personally and professionally — but it surely additionally earned 5 Emmy nominations, together with Finest Director. On this week’s Filmmaker Toolkit Podcast, he mirrored on the toll of constructing a movie about his idol.
Wolf’s introduction to Reubens got here by means of Josh and Benny Safdie, who would later come aboard as producers.
“Paul had met with different administrators whom he both didn’t join with artistically or who weren’t open to his degree of involvement,” Wolf stated. “And I believe I had a cocky perspective, ‘I’m good with difficult individuals.’ And I’m, however this was on a unique degree. The quantity of management that Paul needed to have, perhaps I didn’t totally perceive, or take critically. I figured as soon as we acquired up and working, he would belief me to do what I do.”
Reubens and Wolf had lengthy, private conversations. Each have been homosexual Jewish creatives with supportive households and uncompromising visions, and Wolf hoped their connection would construct belief. He additionally believed Reubens appreciated that he wasn’t targeted on the 1991 arrest or the later, discredited baby pornography cost — which Wolf noticed as a homophobic witch hunt.
To uncover the artist behind his Pee-wee alter-ego, Reubens’ 1,000-hour private archive was key — however whereas Reubens indicted he was prepared, he struggled to let go.
“I used to be coping with any person who had monumental points with management,” stated Wolf. “I believe he would say that about himself on the time. However so do a variety of artists. The distinction with Paul was that he had misplaced management of his private narrative within the media.”
The general public first noticed the person behind Pee-wee in what Reubens referred to as his “Charlie Manson” mug shot — goatee, lengthy hair, vacant stare – when he was arrested at a Sarasota, Florida porn theater in 1991. It was a picture that may change his life eternally. Privately, he let Wolf in, however getting him on digital camera took time. When he lastly agreed, his want for management was apparent.
“There was an actual energy battle that had been brewing and that was enjoying out on digital camera,” stated Wolf. “I fairly rapidly realized that that is a part of who this individual is, and he’s placing it on full show in entrance of the digital camera.”
Reubens was particularly complicated: an overtly homosexual CalArts artist who re-entered the closet, gave up love, and located fame and inventive independence as a personality preaching non-conformity. It was a narrative of somebody who exerted the last word management over his picture, after which skilled its full loss by the hands of the tabloids.
Attempting to unravel that on-camera led to actual breakthroughs, however the digital camera additionally captured how rapidly Reubens may very well be triggered to distrust the documentary course of with out being the one directing it. Wolf had no real interest in being a personality in his personal movie, however the subject-director dichotomy that was enjoying out on digital camera would turn into key to understanding Reubens’ complexities.
Wolf would make concessions, together with letting the Pee-wee creator, who as soon as obsessed about his “Playhouse” units, information the documentary’s manufacturing design for interviews.
“I used to be additionally clear that there isn’t any script,” he stated. “I might be developing that story in post-production. That was informative and alarming to Paul as a result of he needed to be within the edit room each day, and there’s no manner I may do what I do in that method.”
On the podcast, Wolf described a significant struggle over the director sustaining ultimate reduce. “I keep in mind strolling with him after we had this struggle, and he [said], ‘We’re terrified of the identical factor. You need to management the movie you’re making and I need management over my life.‘”
Wolf had all the time deliberate to divide his interviews with Reubens into three chronological blocks, separated by enhancing breaks. The second block lined Reubens’ life up by means of the top of “Pee-wee’s Playhouse.” It was instantly after wrapping his youngsters’s present in 1991 that Reubens visited his dad and mom in Florida, throughout which his notorious arrest befell. Each director and topic have been effectively conscious that the influence of that occasion could be inescapable within the third and ultimate block of interviews, which by no means befell. After the second block of interviews was accomplished, Wolf and editor Damian Rodriguez reduce the primary 45 minutes of the documentary and screened it for Reubens, hoping to finalize the deal.
“We had a fundamental settlement, however negotiating an concerned and long-form contract with the topic earlier than you start could be a poisonous course of. It might probably actually freak individuals out,” Wolf stated. “It’s a dance of constructing individuals really feel comfy, but in addition defending your self whereas making a movie. And we rode that line exhausting. So we have been nonetheless within the strategy of closing a take care of Paul as we have been filming. And it had been established that I might have ultimate reduce and he would have significant session, however the nitty gritty of that was not but resolved.”
Reubens left the screening a number of occasions, struggling to collect his ideas. Then, he disappeared. He stopped responding to Wolf, refused to signal the settlement, and wouldn’t ebook the ultimate interviews. HBO and the manufacturing assumed the movie was useless. The put up group was laid off, and all work ceased.
“It was horrible. It was horrible for him too, I’m certain,” stated Wolf. “It was simply so devastating, principally as a result of everyone knew how good the fabric was and what a superb movie we had on our arms… I saved telling him this movie would reintroduce him to a contemporary viewers, would let him set the report straight after years of malicious and unfair portrayals… It simply felt so devastating that folks may not see it. And so dumb. Like, ’Why can’t we discover a path and make this work? Don’t self-sabotage. This movie goes to reappraise your legacy.’”
On the time, Wolf had simply turned 40. Having his greatest and most costly mission collapse this late within the course of was a menace to his profession. His private life suffered; fights together with his accomplice of 20 years turned frequent.
“It modified me as a human,” he stated. “I’ll by no means make a movie the identical manner once more. And I fear in some ways in which in some way I’ll imagine that nice battle results in one of the best artwork as a result of I don’t assume that must be true.”
Then, after virtually a 12 months of no communication with Wolf, Reubens shocked everybody by signing the deal. His attorneys requested how rapidly the third interview block may start.
“I had a dialog with [Reubens] and his voice sounded bizarre,” stated Wolf, describing their first — and final — dialog in a 12 months. “He stated some intense issues that to me indicated that he could also be considering his mortality, that perhaps [he] had a well being analysis… he wasn’t particular, however he did say, ‘I’m not going be capable to be as concerned as I had hoped, and I’m sorry that I’ve been so emotional the previous few years.’ And I stated, ‘I’m sorry if I did issues that upset you.’ And he stated, ‘You didn’t do something incorrect,’ after which, ’I belief you.’”
Simply as he ready to fly to LA and resume filming, the subsequent shock got here.
“I had no data that he had ever had health-related points, and I get a textual content from my government at HBO with a screenshot from Instagram saying that Paul’s useless,” stated Wolf. “After which I acquired a name from Paul’s publicist and longtime buddy Kelly Bush Novak. She inspired Paul to report a ultimate message for the documentary. She realized that he had not had a chance to handle his arrests, and it was necessary for him to handle that — and he did, the day earlier than he died. Kelly recorded it.”
After listening to the ultimate audio, Wolf started placing the items collectively. “I knew instantly what occurred right here was a part of the story of this movie,” he stated. “And I went to work the subsequent day.”
Seven months after the Emmy-nominated “Pee-wee as Himself” premiered at Sundance, Wolf stated he would by no means make one other documentary the identical manner once more. He additionally couldn’t think about having made this one another manner.
“I’m attempting to completely soak up the depth to which persons are reacting to this movie emotionally. I knew I felt that manner [making it],” stated Wolf. “However I additionally really feel that there’s nothing to be performed in a different way. He was an intense individual. We had an intense relationship. What occurred to him throughout his lifetime was intense. The way in which he died was intense. It’s depth after depth, and brilliance and genius on full show — and so my job was to make that come throughout in order that you may expertise it.”
“Pee-wee as Himself” is nominated for Excellent Documentary or Nonfiction Particular, and Excellent Directing, Image Enhancing, Sound Enhancing, and Sound Mixing for a Documentary/Nonfiction Program.
To listen to Matt Wolf‘s full interview, subscribe to the Filmmaker Toolkit podcast on Apple, Spotify, or your favourite podcast platform. To observe the complete interview, subscribe to IndieWire’s YouTube web page.