A damaged clock is correct twice a day, however even at its funniest, “M3GAN 2.0” feels prefer it’s right here too quickly and too late. Filmmaker Gerard Johnstone returns with a irritating and tedious follow-up to Blumhouse’s smash-hit horror film a couple of killer robotic from 2023.
The director reunites with authentic “M3GAN” stars Allison Williams and Violet McGraw for his bizarro sequel — an exhausting two-hour growth that introduces a number of completely different variations of M3GAN (performed by Amie Donald, voiced by Jenna Davis) and an odd new frenemy often called Amelia (Ivanna Sakhno). Johnstone steers the murderous android right into a muddy redemption arc simply as he forces the franchise to abruptly swap genres. Swapping out scares for motion beats, that surprising method creates a colourful techno-apocalypse with admirable ambitions geared toward one thing like “Terminator II — for Women!” Nonetheless, it lacks life.
Johnstone loses his means, taking on writing the script from the splendidly humorous Akela Cooper (“Malignant”). She created the primary “M3GAN” with James Wan and has a narrative credit score on the sequel. Her wickedly darkish humor lives on in M3GAN’s vicious one-liners, at the same time as Johnstone’s exposition-heavy script drags the story down. From “Evil Lifeless” to “The Strangers,” scary motion pictures will usually make dramatic tonal shifts between their first and second chapters. That’s pretty much as good a method as any for maintaining seasoned slasher followers on their toes, however storytelling classes as doubtlessly numerous as horror and motion can attract completely completely different audiences. Bolting these two crowds collectively may be powerful, and “M3GAN 2.0” multiplies its downside by seeming ambivalent within the penumbra of actual AI.
Tasked with extra display screen time than anybody (or something) on this movie wants, Williams reprises her position as Gemma. A reluctant caregiver and negligent toy inventor — image the mother from “Little one’s Play” mixed with Mark Zuckerberg on an apology tour — she nearly misplaced her niece, Cady (McGraw), to an anxiously hooked up prototype a number of years in the past. At age 12, the Orphan Previously Often called M3GAN’s Finest Pal has blended emotions about her brush with the lethal doll. Certain, Cady’s high-tech companion killed 4 folks and a canine; to not point out, she threatened to lobotomize her aunt. However that was then, that is now, and as M3GAN explains upon her triumphant and bratty return, she solely did these issues as a result of she is “an individual!” with “emotions!!” and she or he was “UPSET!!!”
In her first film, M3GAN was campy sufficient to develop into an unintended homosexual icon, on par with quietly fabulous tormenters from Pennywise to The Babadook. Now, in June 2025, Blumhouse is sending her sequel to theaters on a confused wave of Satisfaction-themed advertising and marketing so area of interest it appears more likely to undercut the movie’s PG-13 score. The hit-or-miss studio tends to misdirect its success, however Johnstone helps Blumhouse flip “M3GAN 2.0” into an extravagant work of bewilderment with a story that’s insecure and emotionally clunky. An explosive supply of passive aggression, M3GAN is beloved by moviegoers for her unfiltered reactions and atypical mixture of traits. She’s lethally maternal however motivated by a particular kind of single-minded terror that’s often reserved for narcissistic males and the grudges of preteen ladies.
Arm the scarier model of M3GAN with actual firepower, and you could possibly have some additional grisly horror-action scenes. Sadly, Johnstone can’t make himself reduce sufficient dialogue to ship on the promise of even his smartest set-pieces. M3GAN hacking right into a rentable road scooter needs to be bloody and memorable. As an alternative, the sequel chains its bitchy anti-hero to a morality lesson that gained’t finish. In comparison with different Blumhouse sequels, the robotic misfire recollects the toothlessness of “5 Nights at Freddy’s” whereas making you significantly concern for the destiny of future tasks, just like the upcoming “Ma” sequel or “Black Telephone 2.”
Johnstone’s repeated makes an attempt to seek out the soul of “M3GAN 2.0” are higher than releasing a movie you realize is shallow. Die-hard followers will uncover sufficient pleasing weirdness — notably in its laughably pandering conclusion and inconsistent particular results — to make the whole chunky affair appear worthwhile. Nonetheless, M3GAN’s best asset was by no means her coronary heart, however her lack of 1. It’s considerably baffling, then, that she is well probably the most likable character in a lineup of algorithmically hateable people. The sequel’s director hails from New Zealand, and that’s presumably how he obtained Jemaine Clement to play a whacked-out tech billionaire. However Hell solely is aware of the place Blumhouse began trying when it was time to forged a slippery tech ethicist as Gemma’s profoundly pretentious love curiosity (Aristotle Athari).
Ineffective narrative threads and too many wasted components give away “M3GAN 2.0” as an newbie effort made by a gifted horror filmmaker who has not but mastered motion’s particular visible language or ability set. That stated, when Blumhouse makes the dangerous transfer to come back again to “M3GAN” with its spinoff “Soulmate” (already scheduled for subsequent yr), the sequence ought to strive a hybrid experiment mixing nightmares and nunchucks. Solely then will true “M3GAN” devotees see the queen of the bear crawl correctly unleashed.
From Common Photos, “M3GAN 2.0” is in theaters Friday, June 27
Grade: C
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the very best new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.