A phrase of recommendation to filmmakers who resolve to place a author of their film: If mentioned author is a journalist or essayist or critic — any sort of author that works in what we name media — we’re going to have questions.
As an illustration, within the Sundance premiere “Love, Brooklyn,” André Holland performs one such author named Roger. Roger is seemingly assigned to jot down an article in regards to the evolving nature of Brooklyn. This piece is mentioned so much all through the movie, and but I nonetheless need solutions. What sort of publication was it for? (Journal? Newspaper? Literary journal? I don’t know!) Why is his deadline ever-flexible? Why does his editor have him over to debate it with glowing wine as an alternative of calling him on the telephone? Or, extra realistically, sending him a strongly worded electronic mail? Is he engaged on the rest? The place does his earnings come from? Why isn’t he extra harassed about getting paid?
These all seem to be minor quibbles, however they reveal the bigger situation on the coronary heart of director Rachael Abigail Holder’s romance written by Paul Zimmerman. The title —”Love, Brooklyn” — is stunningly imprecise, sure? Nicely, so is many of the remainder of the film, which charts the relationships between three lovely Brooklynites performed by Holland, Nicole Beharie, and DeWanda Sensible. The rom-com is produced by Steven Soderbergh, whose presence is felt when Holland’s character pulls out a bottle of the director’s Singani liquor to sip.
Every of those actors labors arduous to deliver dimension to their characters that Zimmerman’s screenplay in any other case doesn’t afford them. If this movie is meant to be a tribute to the borough of its title, it’s a strikingly anodyne one, which saps its places in Fort Greene and its surrounding neighborhoods of character. It is a shockingly empty depiction of Brooklyn, shot as if the characters stay in a postcard the place road visitors is minimal and daily is completely heat. (Contemplating the perfect climate circumstances, it’s then stunning to see the grounds in Prospect Park across the Picnic Home — normally teeming with individuals — principally deserted.)
We first meet Roger as he’s having dinner with Casey (Beharie), a gallerist who we’ll quickly perceive is his ex. He’s complaining about his project — how he needed to jot down about Brooklyn evolving however he thinks it’s devolving — and gestures to order one other bottle of wine. She declines, citing an early morning. So as an alternative he finally ends up on the brownstone of Nicole (Sensible), a single mother finding out to be a therapeutic massage therapist. They’ve intercourse, however she emphatically tells him she’s not his girlfriend. Nicole has a younger daughter Ally (Cadence Reese), who enters the room at inopportune moments, and a husband who died in “an accident.” We don’t be taught anymore in regards to the circumstances of this dying.
The remainder of the movie tries to discover the contours of this triangle. Regardless of declining that preliminary bottle of wine, Casey and Roger have a simple chemistry evident after they get drunk and excessive at an artwork museum, and play act with one another like children within the park. Whereas Casey and Roger appear to be rekindling their romance, he’s additionally going over to Nicole’s for late night time trysts the place she’s opening as much as him. She and her daughter accompany him to a good friend’s social gathering; later, she encourages him to select Ally up from faculty and take her to the playground. Though Nicole doesn’t need to decide to labels, she’s awfully snug letting Roger get near her child with little concern of how which may influence the kid’s fragile psyche. This, nonetheless, will not be actually a priority of the film.
As a substitute, Holder is extra fascinated with romantic photographs of Holland biking round tree-lined streets, and the query of which of those ladies he’s going to finish up with. Holder does little to indicate us why, in actual fact, Roger and Casey really broke up within the first place. Beharie is especially vibrant within the skinny half, and her model of Casey is a weirdo vulnerable to doing humorous voices. Sidelined, nonetheless, is her frustrations with work. She runs a gallery that builders on her block need to take over (what occurs to that area is among the most irritating reveals within the movie).
Sensible, alternatively, is sensuous and loving, however she too is hamstrung by the fabric. At one level, she’s requested to specific sorrow that comes out of nowhere. A tear falls down her cheek, however there’s no construct up to date. It’s Holland, nonetheless, who has the trickiest function. Roger is supposed to be alluring, however one thing of a private mess, and but he largely simply smokes weed and acts charming. Holland does the latter significantly effectively, which fits a great distance.
And but all the actors should plow via dialogue that’s bracingly unnatural. As an illustration, Roger’s married good friend, performed by Roy Wooden Jr., out of nowhere declares, “Is there something higher than breasts?” It’s a line that appears like a parody of a attractive man.
However maybe most aggravating is the best way “Love, Brooklyn” treats Brooklyn. For a film that’s ostensibly indebted to a spot, it’s a vacationer’s view. Each character’s house is completely designed. Each bar is empty. When Casey wants a cab to go residence, a yellow one miraculously pulls up with out her having to hail it though you’d be hard-pressed to search out something however a inexperienced taxi within the borough and even that’s uncommon.
Finally Holder argues that — regardless of gentrification — this place continues to be magical, besides we by no means see any of the magic of which she speaks. We see a fantasy land, however that’s not the identical factor because the true magic town can supply.
Grade: C
“Love, Brooklyn” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Pageant. It’s at the moment in search of U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.