It’s no secret to state that Hollywood is brutal — but it surely makes a distinction who’s saying it. Removed from the shiny and adorned “La La Land” or quick-witted “Hacks” there’s “Leads,” director Bryan Poyser’s ode to pounding the pavement when it could be crumbling beneath you — and one actress and her brother’s persistence all through.
The movie‘s title has a number of meanings; the treacherous showbiz terminology that divides performers into main and non-leading roles, and leads like ideas, indicators, alternatives for the long run. Each sorts of leads find yourself tormenting Mags (Helen Kafka) and Merritt Malloy (Justin Arnold) when the latter comes banging on his sister’s door to run from his issues.
“Leads” appears and appears like a real indie, with a small solid, few areas, and a clear-cut visible language — just about all of which hinges upon Kafka to hold it house. From the very first pictures of her face as Mags directs an performing class, Kafka is susceptible and meticulous together with her portrayal. The half requires a 49-year-old actress who as soon as led a movie at Sundance, who’s terrified that the height of her profession and existence is behind her — the type of position that anybody with extra fame or much less expertise couldn’t deal with. Kafka bolsters Mags together with her personal many years of trade expertise, from indie results in the abilities picked up as a supporting participant.
Then there’s Arnold, who bursts onto the display as a fully-formed chaotic uncle (Mags can be single mom to a seven-year-old), fleshed out and immediately acquainted. Not solely does he explode into his sister’s life sporting an injured wrist and rotting fish (unrelated), however he asks to remain some time and finally ends up becoming a member of the performing class as her pupil. He befriends each pupil, catches the performing bug himself, and continues to champion his sister’s profession, all whereas nurturing his personal inventive desires and sitting on the reality of what introduced him to her door within the first place.
The duo’s sibling dynamic drives the movie, because of Poyser’s credible script and character work. Once more, this can be a no-frills film — together with the perilous frill that’s expository dialogue. Together with cinematographer Ellie Ann Fenton, he finds putting and intimate methods to shoot the actors with out gratuitous flare. It’s arduous to make a movie that’s even remotely about actors or performing with out veering in direction of self significance, however “Leads” isn’t in such hazard. Whether or not its Mags, Merritt, star pupil Alisha (Aaliyah Tardio) or any of her friends, the movie treats its central craft with the identical surprise as these younger pupils on display discovering each device and impulse afresh.
And in an more and more tense trade, Poyser additionally demonstrates the ability of impartial cinema and the resourcefulness and keenness that measure a undertaking’s success lengthy earlier than field workplace receipts. He used footage from his personal shelved tasks, unique songs by Arnold, photographs from Kafka’s profession, and his real-life performing college students. It’s a brutal enterprise, however in case you love the work, quitting isn’t an possibility — irrespective of how huge or small the half.
Grade: B
“Leads” premiered on the 2025 Tribeca Movie Competition. It’s at present in search of U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the very best evaluations, streaming picks, and presents some new musings, all solely obtainable to subscribers.