It’s a banner yr for lesbians grappling with most cancers diagnoses on the indie movie circuit, and that’s about as enjoyable because it sounds in “Julian” — a poetic but confused first effort from filmmaker Cato Kusters.
The drama follows two ladies on a romantic world journey that turns right into a tragedy when one among them immediately falls in poor health. Their story is as a lot about processing grief within the web age as it’s terminal sickness, and that’s a tremendous sufficient concept. However the set-up that takes it there depends on a warped sentimentality that will edge too near Obamacore for some queer of us (notably, Individuals) to understand proper now.
Primarily based on Fleur Pierets’ devastating memoir from 2023, “Julian” stars Nina Meurisse and Laurence Roothooft because the writer and her e book’s namesake, respectively. A basic lesbian vignette — two hotties locking eyes at a music venue — erupts right into a passionate affair that makes the brand new couple simple to fall in love with. When the pair get engaged, journalist Fleur comes up with a plan to show their pending nuptials into a worldwide occasion. She pulls up a spreadsheet to point out her future spouse, and Fleur explains how they could go around the globe getting married. They’ll decide to eternally with one another within the nations the place they will, and within the course of, make a press release concerning the locations the place they will’t.
Julian is in for the journey instantly, however Fleur’s editor and a few mates take a contact extra convincing. This can be a large venture and it could possibly be exhausting on them each. Nonetheless, the ladies are decided to create a life-affirming spectacle of their love, and watching Julian and Fleur wed for the primary time, the second is so emotional it practically makes the wildly over-the-top endeavor look like it must be a standard observe for all lesbians. Who wouldn’t need to say “I do” to their finest buddy time and again? Particularly when somebody else desires to maintain you aside?
As a matter of execution, the flip that steers “Julian” in direction of heartbreak is somber however intelligent. The belief that Julian is battling most cancers comes slowly, then seemingly suddenly, and it brings the newlyweds’ itinerary to a screeching halt. Unable to journey any additional, they finally lean on Julian’s dad and mom for assist and the scenes that present Fleur becoming a member of their household are a few of Kusters’ finest. The director has a knack for honing in on the subtlest facial features, and the performances she will get from her solid really feel splendidly collaborative. Common emotion radiates from tear-streaked faces as all 4 actors trade a type of kinetic concern that the loss they’re all too petrified of would possibly actually be coming.
That half works, however different easy tales about illness have been informed extra fantastically — and what ought to set “Julian” aside in a crowded area slowly undermines what it does properly. Residing in suspended denial, Fleur digs additional into the content material plan that they had earlier than all of this started. Memorializing your beloved’s life your writing is one factor, however utilizing your work as a distraction to keep away from actuality is one other. The portrayal is sympathetic and largely results in an inner battle for Fleur that’s captured properly. However that turmoil will get steadily bleaker and in the end leaves the ladies in a spot so darkish it’s exhausting to see what Kusters — and even the true writer, Fleur — needed to say about performative hardship.
This can be a multi-language movie with dialogue that’s in English, French, and Dutch, so perhaps one thing received misplaced in translation. Nonetheless, “Julian” appears to concentrate on private accountability for contemporary queer individuals at a significantly turbulent time for LGBT rights in a method that’s misguided and ineffectual. Marriage equality is just not the one concern dealing with lesbians fascinated about world journey, and God forbid your associate will get most cancers, there’s extra to say about moving into her hospital room than watching her stroll down the aisle.
However Fleur’s story is true and you’ll’t steer the real-life narrative the place it didn’t go. Paradoxically, that implies the expertise in all probability shouldn’t have been tailored for the massive display in any respect. Leaping forward in time, we see the attainable widow, her destiny not but clear, scrambling to recuperate information on a tough drive. It comprise footage of her spouse unable to get off the bed, and for a second, you nearly dislike Fleur. Poignant and value telling as soon as, “Julian” ought to’ve been laid to relaxation after the tragedy was retold the primary time.
Grade: C+
“Julian” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.