Leos Carax‘s means to create among the most placing and memorable pictures in trendy cinema is past query, however his causes for stringing these pictures collectively are sometimes murkier. The idiosyncratic auteur is nearer to an summary artist than a standard storyteller — a trade-off that has added way more to his profession than it has subtracted. That pressure fueled his magnum opus “Holy Motors,” which follows a person whose inexplicable have to create and carry out prompts him to spend his days biking by way of an countless roster of purchasers who ask him to don completely different disguises. It’s additionally what made him the perfect director-for-hire for the fantastically incoherent Sparks brothers musical “Annette.” And it’s why one might argue that his model is best suited to museums than conventional filmmaking.
The Centre Pompidou apparently thought so when it commissioned Carax to make a brief movie that used pictures to reply the query “Who Are You, Leos Carax?” The director’s try to interact with the immediate grew to become “It’s Not Me,” a video essay the title of which encapsulates its cussed refusal to reply the query that birthed it. The completed product is many issues — a retrospective that glides by way of Carax’s current filmography, an homage to late-career Godard tasks like “The Picture Ebook,” and an unpredictable visible experiment from an artist who has at all times excelled at experimenting visually. However most of all, it’s proof that Carax continues to be preoccupied by the query on the heart of “Holy Motors”: Why does he maintain obsessing over cinema and making the unusual pictures that fill his films? Seems, he hasn’t come any nearer to a solution.
The 40-minute video essay sees Carax stringing collectively pictures from his earlier movies alongside black-and-white clips from Outdated Hollywood, historic footage just like the 1939 Nazi rally at Madison Sq. Backyard, and some new pictures that see him catching up with previous characters just like the sewer leprechaun from “Holy Motors.” The montage skips between matters starting from the rise of hateful authoritarians all over the world and Carax’s shortcomings as a father to the Hitchcock movies that sparked his lifelong fascination with POV pictures. Carax makes use of his personal narration and textual overlays to regale his viewers with each thought that pops into his head, from existential fears to playful quips like “of all of the colics, spare me the melancholic.” All of it appears like one thing a nonagenarian Godard would have minimize collectively lengthy earlier than Carax makes the reference express by taking part in a voicemail that the “Breathless” director as soon as left him.
A venture as free and self-indulgent as “It’s Not Me” is barely worthwhile when it comes from an artist whose brilliance and significance are so firmly etched into historical past that something they really feel like producing turns into a relic worthy of examine. Godard’s membership in that membership was plain, however there’s extra room for disagreement about whether or not Carax breathes such rarified air. The extent to which “It’s Not Me” will resonate with a specific viewer doubtless will depend on how worthy of examination they deem Carax’s psyche, however there’s no denying that it’s fueled by the singular imaginative and prescient of an artist who refuses to let his viewers off simple.
“It’s Not Me” was initially supposed to display as a part of a museum set up that by no means materialized, a truth that ought to solely add to the movie’s mystique. Regardless of the easy query on the movie’s core, Carax is unsurprisingly extra fascinated about assembling compelling pictures and sounds than providing a honest look inside the person crafting them. He orbits vulnerability like a moth swirling round a streetlamp, getting ever nearer and infrequently touching it earlier than immediately recoiling. His deepest moments come when he searches for the origins of his personal obsession with cinema, probing his psyche for an evidence for why he continues to romanticize a medium that he’s spent a profession insisting is dying a sluggish demise. He muses about his fascination with large cameras being pushed round by grips, and regrettably factors out that small digital rigs won’t ever emit the identical distinguished aura. His rhetorical riffs level towards a visceral obsession with pictures that even he can’t fairly perceive. Identical to Denis Lavant’s Mr. Oscar in “Holy Motors,” he simply retains getting again in that limo as a result of he has no different selection.
Grade: B
“It’s Not Me” will debut with a dwell streaming premiere on the Criterion Channel on December 10 at 9pm ET alongside a restricted theatrical engagement in New York and Los Angeles. It will likely be out there to stream on Criterion Channel starting on January 1.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up one of the best critiques, streaming picks, and gives some new musings, all solely out there to subscribers.