Jeff Buckley’s life began with each an act of embrace and a decisive abandonment. His mom was solely 17 when she conceived him and, whereas it was recommended she may give the child up for adoption, she knew she needed to nurture the human rising inside her and let him nurture her in return. Jeff’s father, however, couldn’t let his goals of being a well-known singer/songwriter get replaced by the difficulties of elevating a baby and selected to not be part of his life.
Tim Buckley would finally achieve the notoriety he sought, producing 9 studio albums and serving as a well known determine within the people rock group for his distinctive voice and experimentation with a number of genres of music. Although Jeff did lastly meet his father following a live performance close to the place he grew up in Southern California, Tim would die of a heroin overdose shortly thereafter. For the remainder of his life, Jeff would eschew comparisons to Tim, however might by no means shake the sensation that their paths had by some means grow to be entwined, significantly the notion that he wouldn’t find yourself dwelling very lengthy.
In Amy Berg‘s somber and evocative tribute documentary “It’s By no means Over, Jeff Buckley,” the eponymous singer/songwriter’s private life is commonly given extra consideration than the music he left behind, a truth that will seemingly irritate Buckley to no finish had been he nonetheless alive. Sadly for his followers, a world bereft of extra of his work, and those that liked him most, he isn’t, and whereas his music has solely grown in recognition since his passing, Buckley’s reminiscence has light into the background.
Berg goals to alter that together with her piece, first by permitting these closest to him — from Buckley’s mom Mary Guibert to band member and pal Michael Tighe — a chance to share their recollections of what made him so particular after which utilizing Buckley’s beforehand unseen archives to take viewers again in time, dropping us into Nineteen Sixties SoCal, the artsy decrease Manhattan of the early ’90s, and varied live performance occasions world wide.
At first, Berg’s strategy to piecing collectively Buckley’s historical past feels quite conventional, with direct-to-camera reflections from Guibert about his childhood and the way she knew he could be a singer at a really younger age, in addition to footage and clips of Buckley as he grew and his voice started to develop. After Tim comes again into the image for a short second earlier than his loss of life, reinforcing all of the sensations of unworthiness in Jeff that had current since beginning, the vibe takes a noticeable shift. Focusing in on Buckley’s teenage years, the doc captures the event of not solely a real artist, however a gifted performer who noticed music as each a type of expression and a common language that may attain deep into the soul. Whereas his best reverence was held for the long-lasting rock band Led Zeppelin, his personal fashion gathered extra from untraditional influences like Nina Simone and Qawwali musician Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan.
Although anybody who’s listened to his lone studio album “Grace” even simply as soon as is aware of Buckley was a singular expertise who’s four-octave vary held each sensitivity and immense energy, the speaking heads all through — a lot of whom are musicians themselves or within the music enterprise — can’t assist however reinforce this many occasions over. Nonetheless, sticking to her total intention with the movie, Berg attracts a line between this technical ability and Buckley’s ethereal spirit, which, having been raised by a single mom, contained each masculine and female options and poured love onto others with reckless abandon. Different girls in his life, comparable to girlfriends Rebecca Moore and Joan Wasser, in addition to colleague Aimee Mann, are moved to tears as they recall how he made them really feel, however even they acknowledge that this ardour is also harmful.
From his shattering public debut singing at a tribute live performance for his father to his signing with Columbia Information after time spent growing his abilities at Sin-é in Decrease Manhattan, Buckley held an extremely excessive normal for himself, drawing on the careers and influence of figures like Bob Dylan and Bruce Springsteen as inspiration for his personal rise. Many music executives at Columbia had been pleased to implement that expectation, particularly after the discharge of “Grace,” which launched Buckley as one of many best singers of all time, in line with different artists like David Bowie and the movie’s producer, Brad Pitt. Although the album was solely a average success in America, it was a world hit abroad, and as Buckley and his band toured over the subsequent few years, the pressures of fame and the boxing in of his artistry brought about his psychological state to slowly deteriorate.
That is the place the need of Berg’s purpose begins to grow to be clear. Buckley could not have appreciated his life being put middle stage forward of his music, however a lot about it has been misconstrued in an effort to match him to different tragic artists like his father, Jim Morrison, Janis Joplin, and Jimi Hendrix, all of whom handed on account of drug use, that the necessity to set the file straight and present Buckley for all his one-of-a-kind magnificence and problems proves very important. And whereas the non-public particulars and recordings shared usually really feel extremely intimate, as if, maybe, we shouldn’t in reality be listening to this, the added context does make us take heed to his music in a brand new manner. Each clip of Buckley performing lifts the movie off the bottom, highlighting how his skills usually felt otherworldly. That is additional accentuated by the Lynchian animation produced by Icelandic director and artist Sara Gunnarsdóttir, recognized for her work in Marielle Heller’s “The Diary of the Teenage Lady” and her Oscar-nominated 2022 quick “My 12 months of Dicks.”
As soon as the tour wraps up, Buckley’s stress is additional exacerbated by the necessity to produce a second album and pay again the money owed he accrued in making “Grace.” As artists and musicians themselves, most of the members converse on to the issues inside the enterprise that set rising expertise as much as fail, although the executives featured additionally do their finest to defend their positions and categorical how they labored to assist Buckley with no matter he wanted. Nonetheless, those that solely cared about his well-being noticed he was going by means of a psychotic break and as he holed himself up in a small home in Memphis, Tennessee to work on new music, many had been involved what time would yield. Fortunately although, the time away from the fuss of fame cleared his thoughts, permitting him to supply concepts for his band to come back work on, however as a consequence of a devastating accident, this could by no means come to cross.
Towards the tip of “It’s By no means Over, Jeff Buckley,” Wasser makes a degree about Buckley that helps to tie the piece all collectively. She says that so most of the issues we take care of once we’re youthful finally fade away as we become older and that saddest a part of Buckley’s complete story is that he by no means obtained the possibility to succeed in that time. Sure, he had parts of mania and melancholy that seemingly wanted psychological intervention, however he additionally cared a lot about connecting with humanity that those that knew him finest actually do imagine he had extra to offer.
Berg has lined many tragic figures and conditions earlier than, significantly within the realm of sexual violence with movies like “Ship Us from Evil,” “An Open Secret,” and “Phoenix Rising,” and together with different music docs like “Janis: Little Lady Blue,” however together with her newest entry, she finds that regardless of what many might imagine, tragedy is the least attention-grabbing facet of her topic. By preserving her concentrate on solely a handful of people that might converse on to Buckley’s historical past, she finds what’s most compelling — outdoors of the music, in fact — was his capacity to maneuver ahead and upend preconceptions at each flip. From constructing a legacy past that of his father’s to being a relentless supply of sunshine to his mom and others, Buckley could have felt like he wasn’t lengthy for this earth, however by means of the music he left behind, proved even himself fallacious.
Grade: B+
“It’s By no means Over, Jeff Buckley” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution and gross sales are being dealt with by Submarine.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the most effective new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.