John Davidson is not any stranger to the flicks. In spite of everything, he’s starred in 5 of them over the course of the final 4 a long time.
If his title doesn’t ring any bells, that’s honest sufficient: the true John Davidson is a Scottish activist who first rose to prominence in 1989, when the then-16-year-old was the topic of a BBC documentary, “John’s Not Mad.” Different docs adopted in 2002 (“The Boy Can’t Assist It”), 2009 (“Tourettes: I Swear I Can’t Assist It”), 2014 (“Tourettes & Me”), and 2016 (“Tourette’s: Teenage Tics”). Davidson’s star energy is rooted in private ache. After the sudden onset of Tourette syndrome when he was only a younger teen, Davidson spent a few years in isolation and confusion earlier than ultimately turning his struggles and expertise into motion, changing into arguably the UK’s most recognizable Tourette’s activist.
That Davidson is a hero, each on a nationwide scale and to the broader Tourette’s neighborhood, is just not in query. What Kirk Jones’ “I Swear” asks is how Davidson’s story could be packaged into extra standard biopic trappings and shared with the biggest doable viewers. And whereas these trappings guarantee “I Swear” will adhere to the tropes and tips of the subgenre — inspiring tales about very actual individuals, with emotion to spare — a putting, star-making efficiency from star Robert Aramayo (“The Rings of Energy,” “The Empty Man”) as Davidson locations it a reduce above the fray.
Whereas the vagaries of life itself can account for a number of the weirder ripples in “I Swear,” the wants of becoming such a fraught story into simply two hours additionally complicate issues. The script, additionally from Jones, ignores a number of key elements (like all of Davidson’s documentary movie appearances) and ices over others (that the foundation reason behind Davidson’s dysfunction isn’t interrogated bothers, even because it might match neatly inside different points involving his household, who had been deeply unprepared to assist him). The emotional ballast of the movie — Davidson’s bond with Dottie Achenbach (an exquisite Maxine Peake), the mom of 1 his childhood associates, who can also be combating her personal well being battles — additionally suffers from moments of incoherence, however the immense energy of that bond goes a good distance.
We first meet John as a peppy younger teenager (Scott Ellis Watson), a daily ol’ kiddo who may be very invested in soccer (or soccer, relying in your homeland) and, it appears, fairly rattling good at it besides. He’s readying to maneuver as much as “large faculty” and check out for a starry new coach, and whereas his dad David (Steven Cree) appears principally all in favour of hitting up the native pub, he’s clearly pleased with his son’s athletic prowess. His brittle mum Heather (a heartbreaking and irritating Shirley Henderson) is barely holding issues collectively as is, after which John begins, nicely, appearing out? playing around? taking part in at one thing? Not less than, that’s how Heather takes it.
What’s actually occurring, in fact, is a sudden onset of Tourette’s, presumably exacerbated by mounting stress each at dwelling and at college. John’s terror and confusion, vividly portrayed by Watson, is heartbreaking. However what’s worse is the response of everybody else round him: his associates nearly immediately again away, the bullies pull in, the soccer goals disappear, and his family can solely discover disdain and anger for what’s occurring earlier than their very eyes. The one actual modifications that occur to “accommodate” him: his dad leaves and his mum sticks him in entrance of the fireside at meal occasions, in order that any meals he spits out will land someplace readily washer-friendly. That John’s struggle would ultimately turn out to be about instructing others how one can perceive the dysfunction is laid plain from the beginning, however it is going to take him a long time to get to that time.
His tics manifest in quite a lot of methods, beginning with a head bob right here and a shoulder nod there, an errant shout of “HEY!” to nobody specifically, and a few main stage fright on the subject of the classroom and the soccer pitch. As he ages up (Aramayo takes on the half after the movie’s first half hour), the verbal tics worsen, typically culminating in John yelling the worst doable issues at the worst doable occasions. John sees a woman he likes? He’s yelling at her to take off her knickers. Going for a job interview at a neighborhood heart that hosts occasions for teenagers? “I’m a pedo,” he shouts in the midst of an in any other case quiet room. Touring by practice? “I’ve acquired a bomb!,” he gasps.
Aramayo is superb within the position, simply transversing between John’s ache and confusion and a wincing humor about the entire scenario. When he reunites with a childhood pal and meets his heat and successful mom Dottie, issues begin to shift. The plucky Dottie, not too long ago recognized with terminal most cancers, is keen to help younger John — “Why not spend your last months serving to others?,” she wonders, a adequate message for any movie of this ilk — and he takes to the Achenbach dwelling with relative ease. (Heather, who has spent the previous decade bossing round her eldest son, is floored by the likelihood that anybody else would possibly see the nice in him, not to mention need it of their lives.)
However whereas Dottie and her household’s entrance in John’s life gives some much-needed positivity, it additionally heralds in a grating, grinding narrative cycle to “I Swear.” Each time one thing good occurs to John, he’s nearly instantly kicked again down once more. The cycle occurs with maddening, nearly humorous regularity, as John is lifted up up up by skilled prospects, excellent news for Dottie, a authorized win, and even a brand-new flat, solely to be pushed down down down by life’s tragedies, not all of them essentially entangled in his ailment, however none of them helped by it both.
It’s a sample that continues all through the vast majority of the movie, an emotionally shattering expertise that does one thing that probably feels acquainted to individuals like the true John Davidson: takes away the flexibility to hope for one thing higher. But, lastly, armed with each ache and pluck, John makes a selection to succeed in out to the individuals who want him most, children with Tourette’s and their households, all of whom are welcoming of the type of understanding and assist he by no means acquired.
Davidson’s activism inside his neighborhood will unquestionably be his legacy, and it’s disappointing that that portion of his life and work arrives so late into Jones’ movie. But, Aramayo’s delicate portrayal of the person and Jones’ unflinching dedication to exhibiting a few of Davidson’s most painful moments, those that pushed him into motion, add as much as an insightful biopic that chronicles a really worthy topic. Audiences will probably need to be taught extra about the true Davidson after seeing Jones’ movie and, fortuitously, a trove of different choices await.
Grade: B
“I Swear” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Pageant. It’s at the moment looking for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the most effective new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.