How Brett Richards Earned My Respect on Fire Country Season 4 Episode 4

When he arrived in the fourth season of Fire Country, Station 42 was a broken mess.

Brett Richards’ arrival wasn’t exactly a fun one. He was despised, with no one rooting for him. 

However, Richards was exactly the kind of discipline Fire Country needed. With a determined look, he set his eyes on restructuring 42.

His goal was simple: no one else dies on his watch. Bode, Jake, Eve, and the rest needed a fresh reminder of their 1s and 2s, no matter how much they loathed him.

But it seems his time on the show was pretty short and quite unpredictable.

Just when Richards appeared to have found his footing, he announced his departure on Fire Country Season 4 Episode 4, “Like a Wounded Wildebeest“. 

This came as quite a shock, as earlier he seemed dead set on changing the face of the station after Vince’s death.

Well, at least he did one thing right: by choosing the right successor for his role.

Manny Is the Best Choice to Lead Station 42

If there’s one thing Brett Richards got right in his blink-and-you’ll-miss-him stint at Station 42, it’s pegging Manny Perez as the glue that’s still holding the team together. 

The seasoned captain has spent years guiding lost souls at Three Rock Con Camp, earning both scars and respect along the way. 

Manny isn’t just the person with the most time at the station — he’s the one with the deepest battle wounds. He has the right kind of wisdom for a group that’s still reeling from Vince’s untimely exit.

From a leadership standpoint, Manny is the only one currently running on all cylinders. 

Jake may have the pedigree and ambition, but he’s torn between his rise and his connection to the Leones. His drive nearly consumed him and risked alienating his best friends, forcing a painful reevaluation of his priorities. 

Bode, true to form, remains the station’s live wire — brave, determined, but caught in the undertow of grief and addiction. He needs stability and clear boundaries, not more volatility. 

Eve’s heart is with Three Rock: she’s missing in action for most of Episode 4, helping those who need her most, rather than vying for command. 

It’s the bitter truth: Station 42 isn’t just looking for someone to fill Vince’s boots — they need someone who understands the terrain. 

Manny’s ability to get the best out of his people is exactly what Station 42 requires. When the grain silo rescue went sideways, it was Manny who kept heads cool and lives saved. 

Richards recognized it in real time, impressed enough to hand him the chief’s badge. This wasn’t a popularity contest, but a gut decision rooted in hard-earned respect.​

Vince himself could never have settled the debate—the man loved both Bode and Jake, his loyalties too closely entwined. 

Richards, unburdened by old allegiances, made the hard call and left Station 42 with the best chance possible: Manny at the helm, supporting Sharon, and keeping the group from splintering.​

Richards’ exit may have left questions up in the air, but his choice for chief? That’s the kind of legacy Station 42 will thank him for in seasons to come.

Brett Richards’ Exit Still Makes No Sense

You can’t help but squint at Brett Richards’ abrupt departure, wondering if you missed a whole arc in the blink of an eye. 

He was introduced this season with thunder and lightning — a disruptive outsider meant to “reinvent” Station 42’s culture. 

His approach landed like a sledgehammer in a shop full of fragile glass: discipline first, sentimentality last. 

So how did this hard-nosed chief suddenly buy into the show’s “family theme,” making a 180-degree turn that left viewers scratching their heads?​

Richards arrived swinging, ready to weed out weak points, especially in Bode, whose post-Vince behavior drew unfiltered scrutiny. 

Yet, barely an episode in, he’s passing out warm beers with Sharon and handing over the keys like he’s just another one of the gang. 

Even the scar he reveals feels like it was dropped in to hastily anchor his late change of heart.​

The problem? He hasn’t spent enough real time with the crew to earn that transformation. 

Richards’ emotional intelligence gets acknowledged — he notices Manny treating Bode’s addiction with empathy and care, and that prompts his handoff. 

But with so little buildup, the baton pass feels like a cameo rather than a substantial presence.​

There are no meaty speeches, tearful goodbyes, or game-changing decisions.

Just a man who seemed ready to clear out the rot, suddenly bending to the collective will and sneaking out the back door.

As fans, it’s natural to want a payoff: something to justify the hype and the rapid character turn. Instead, we’re left with a cameo and a few scars.

But Station 42 marches on, and the next test arrives soon. Tune in for Fire Country Season 4 Episode 5, premiering Friday, November 14th, on CBS. 

Do you believe Manny is the best choice as the new battalion chief? Tell us in the comments below!