There are some things Margarita (Lillian Provider) is aware of for certain: she doesn’t wish to get a job, she positively doesn’t wish to get a job which requires her to put on “onerous pants,” she loves horses, she loves her mother, and she or he’s not keen to interact in a lot of something that may open her as much as ridicule. And but, the younger autistic lady — and Provider herself is autistic — has already gone towards a few of these inside guidelines. She went to varsity and received a level. She spends plenty of her time driving round on an adult-sized tricycle with a stuffed horse head connected to it (he’s generally known as “Cheeseburger”). She loves doing karaoke along with her mother Sandy (a heartbreaking Gretchen Mol) at their favourite restaurant.
Like any individual, the push-pull of Margarita’s desires and desires are continuously butting up towards one another. Margarita’s incapacity might, after all, influence and have an effect on these desires and desires in barely alternative ways (versus these of a neurotypical individual), however the core of her expertise is widespread. It’s merely the human situation, however because the protagonist of Lauren Meyering’s inventive and emotionally complicated characteristic directorial debut, “Horsegirls,” Margarita’s life affords new methods of viewing seemingly previous tales. Basic tales.
And whereas interest horsing — the wholly surprising sport on the heart of Meyering’s movie and Margarita’s nice awakening — may itself not be previous or traditional, the movie capabilities a bit like every other nice sports activities movie. And, similar to its heroine, the seeming “distinction” or “uniqueness” of the game helps illuminate the widespread emotions on the heart of “Horsegirls.”
Primarily based loosely on co-writer and producer Mackenzie Breeden’s personal experiences (the multi-hyphenate additionally seems within the movie in a small supporting function), “Horsegirls” opens with Margarita’s life already at an excessive crossroads, even when she doesn’t but understand it. Her mom Sandy is her sole dad or mum after her father handed away from some kind of nebulous accident, and Sandy has already been by it within the intervening years. The loss of life of her husband — who she energetically remembers in humorous tales, together with Margarita’s favourite, concerning the genesis of her title — was onerous sufficient, however going by three rounds of most cancers since then has been significantly tougher to swallow.
Once we first meet Margarita, she’s dreaming her manner by a journey on Cheeseburger — Meyering blends in fantastical moments alongside the movie’s tougher dramatic moments, a inventive gamble that doesn’t at all times work, even because it impresses — on her strategy to go to her mom at her chemotherapy appointment. Nobody is extra assured of Margarita’s capabilities than Sandy, however there’s one thing deeply touching concerning the methods wherein the movie permits us to expertise Margarita’s revelations by her eyes (and Provider’s fantastic efficiency). Sure, Margarita is sufficiently old and mature sufficient to come back to Sandy’s appointments, but it surely’s additionally as much as her to synthesize their true that means. Ultimately, she’s going to.
However whereas Sandy may imagine in Margarita’s skills, she’s additionally continuously apprehensive how they could be exploited. It’s simple sufficient to agree that Margarita ought to get a job, however what occurs if her boss doesn’t totally perceive the best way she works? She ought to have buddies, however what if they’re making enjoyable of her behind her again? For each second Sandy is attempting to nudge Margarita into the actual world, she’s additionally responsible of pulling her manner again. And for Margarita, fierce and humorous and possessed of a Jenny Slate-styled honk, none of this can do. She’d moderately spend her time breaking into the native stables to hang around with the horses, who she adores and who her mom will not let her journey.
After which, one evening, a discovery: interest horsing. Inevitably, the second that Margarita spies a interest horsing class cavorting round a room within the native center faculty will doubtless have a profound impact on the movie’s viewers. What’s that? What are they doing? Are these women working round on stick horses, pretending to essentially be driving them? Sure, certainly, and it’s not only a wacky little interest, it’s a full-fledged aggressive sport, and there are severe contenders who’d prefer it to be an Olympic sport.
However whereas others may see one thing to ridicule, Margarita sees one thing fully completely different: a strategy to belong. It’s a intelligent manner into the movie and Margarita’s personal evolutions, a nifty strategy to remind us the entire energy of Margarita’s imaginative and prescient, a push towards conserving our personal eyes open to issues that may look, at first look, a bit foolish.
Sandy, who has begun to slowly orient herself towards educating Margarita all of the methods to be an grownup, doesn’t see it that manner. Enter: a significant schism within the relationship, simply in the mean time that each mom and daughter needs to be cherishing each second collectively. However whereas Meyering and Breeden’s script builds round acquainted moments and worries (the movie is a coming-of-age story, tinged with sports activities drama, whimsical comedy, and a powerful curiosity in displaying “incapacity” in a brand new gentle), Margarita’s method to every thing tilts issues into more energizing areas.
Provider herself helped form Margarita and her journey, and her perspective on the movie’s occasions provides an authenticity that feels new. It it, very similar to interest horsing itself, one which additionally feels surprising, sometimes misunderstood, and deserving of a more in-depth look.
Grade: B
“Horsegirls” premiered on the 2025 Tribeca Movie Competition. It’s at present looking for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the most effective new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.