The day after the 2024 election, I ended watching the information. Certain, I’ll nonetheless learn articles from numerous shops and comply with alongside on-line, however after years spent tuning into journalists who’d turn out to be personalities and pundits solely interested by getting their sound chew, I might now not escape the sensation that these folks hardly ever knew what they had been speaking about — or worse, had been straight up mendacity.
In an age the place info is weaponized and reality debatable to the purpose of meaninglessness, media has served as each an indispensable device and a rallying cry for whichever aspect you select to help, a reality that permits journalism to turn out to be extra about pushing a selected message than really searching for out the reality. This battle is on the crux of Sam Feder‘s authorized documentary “Heightened Scrutiny,” which captures ACLU legal professional and transgender rights activist Chase Strangio as he prepares to argue in entrance of the Supreme Court docket within the case of america v. Skrmetti.
The Skrmetti case originated as a problem to a Tennessee regulation prohibiting transgender minors from accessing sure types of gender-affirming care, together with puberty blockers and hormone remedy, however Strangio makes clear all through the movie: If this regulation is upheld by the Supreme Court docket, it would result in a full-out assault on trans id in America. Not only for youngsters, however adults too who must face a authorized system that successfully could be giving states the best to remove gender-affirming care based mostly on info that’s largely not grounded in reality. The place does this info come from? As “Heightened Scrutiny” takes care to put out, an excessive amount of anti-trans bias is circulated by way of mainstream media, and never simply from right-wing sources like Fox Information, however in The New York Occasions, The Wall Road Journal, The Atlantic, and lots of extra supposedly liberal publications.
Strangio’s preparations for the case are juxtaposed towards audio of his oral arguments earlier than the Supreme Court docket on December 4, 2024, and the questions posed by numerous justices at the moment, in addition to direct-to-camera asides from trans and cisgendered journalists and consultants. From Jelani Cobb, author and present dean of Columbia College of Journalism, to Gina Chua, government editor of Semafor and board member of the Trans Journalist Affiliation, “Heightened Scrutiny” calls on views who are usually not solely instantly affected by the form of propaganda mainstream media is spewing out, however who’ve spent their lives and careers gathering info to dispel these lies. Contemplating Skrmetti’s potential impression on trans youth, the documentary begins by confronting the query on the coronary heart of this case: What in regards to the youngsters?
For ages, this query has been used as a dog-whistle towards dad and mom frightened of shedding management over their youngsters, however furthermore, it’s been a device of authoritarian regimes in factionalizing populations. Within the lead as much as 1967’s Loving v. Virginia case, which deemed legal guidelines that ban interracial marriage to be unconstitutional, many tried to pose the identical query, as if to say youngsters could be worse off having dad and mom of differing races than they might be with dad and mom who had been the identical coloration. Simply as there was no factual foundation for this assertion in 1967, “Heightened Scrutiny” so too argues that this declare holds no water regarding the decisions made by the dad and mom of transgendered youth at the moment. Actually, taking away the best of oldsters to boost youngsters in a manner that honors their progress and well-being spits within the face of all of the American freedoms we declare to carry so expensive and speaks to authorities because the form of overly obstructive power so many conservative politicians might publicly work towards, however privately help.
In watching Strangio’s on a regular basis life, we get a way for what it should really feel prefer to be a transgender citizen in America at the moment, not simply by way of the strain he’s underneath to show his price, however within the fixed battle to be considered as a human being slightly than some mistake in want of safety from individuals who aren’t even keen to interact with them. In a single scene that entails the varsity board in Manhattan answerable for the training of Strangio’s little one, board members confronted with pleas from the neighborhood to help trans youth don’t even have a look at the audio system they’re alleged to be representing, as a substitute selecting to disregard them and concentrate on their telephones. It’s a blood-boiling picture that factors to society’s general apathy in the direction of minority teams, however one which fuels Strangio’s battle even additional.
Bringing it again to how media creates an setting for society to really feel threatened by the trans neighborhood, Strangio and different contributors additionally share their frustration over how the mainstream press usually tend to stoke a flame than defend these getting burned. Transgender lives are underneath risk on a regular basis, not simply within the sense of outright violence, but additionally as enemies of a authorized system seemingly intent on eradicating their very being. This isn’t hyperbole, as Feder cuts in clips from CPAC conventions that function politicians explicitly using any such language. In the meantime, precise dad and mom of trans youngsters like Alberto Cairo, Knight Chair in Infographics & Knowledge Visualization on the College of Miami, are proven breaking down in tears as he defends not solely his little one’s proper to stay and be seen as they need to be seen, but additionally his personal duty to help them as he sees match.
In Feder’s 2020 documentary “Disclosure” — a movie that must be required viewing for all these working in leisure — the filmmaker tracks the evolution of how trans life is represented on display, from dangerous portrayals in films like “The Crying Sport” to extra rounded depictions within the FX collection “Pose.” With “Heightened Scrutiny” — which additionally consists of trans actress and activist Laverne Cox as an government producer and on-screen contributor as she was with “Disclosure” — Feder varieties one other compelling argument towards trans bias, albeit one which’s immediacy proves much more dire. Having solely wrapped the movie lower than two months in the past, releasing it within the interim between when Strangio delivered his arguments to the Supreme Court docket and when the justices will in the end resolve on the matter (seemingly June 2025) looks as if a alternative that might have solely been made with the intent of fixing perceptions and constructing a coalition that sways public opinion.
Exterior of together with jump-scare clips that function the work of Armie Hammer and right-wing political commentator Matt Walsh and hard-to-swallow flashbacks to the all-too-recent 2024 election, “Heightened Scrutiny” succeeds in its mission of training a public whose minds have been corrupted by the weaving of fictions introduced as fact. Even Justice Sonia Sotomayor, one of many Democrat-appointed members of bench, references figures throughout Skrmetti from articles that don’t have any foundation in reality and that are simply disputed by Strangio, as soon as once more pointing to media as a permeating a part of our tradition that’s in determined want of readjustment. In the direction of the conclusion of the movie, nonetheless, all of that anger and disappointment constructed up from being consistently introduced as a hazard offers option to renewed willpower as Strangio is seen getting a tattoo of the poem “Prophecy” by civil rights activist and authorized scholar Pauli Murray. The poem reads…
“I sing of a brand new American
Separate from all others,
But enlarged and diminished by all others.
I’m the kid of kings and serfs, freemen and slaves,
Having neither superiors nor inferiors,
Progeny of all colours, all cultures, all programs, all beliefs.
I’ve been enslaved, but my spirit is unbound.
I’ve been solid apart, however I sparkle within the darkness.
I’ve been slain however stay on within the river of historical past.
I search no conquest, no wealth, no energy, no revenge:
I search solely discovery
Of the illimitable heights and depths of my very own being.”
For a very long time, I sought hope in watching the information, believing that someday, one thing good would lastly occur that might flip our trendy terrors round and lead us in the direction of a brighter future. What “Heightened Scrutiny” jogged my memory is that the hope is inside us, and that solely by way of coalition constructing and serving to others who want it probably the most will it actually be fulfilled.
Grade: A-
“Heightened Scrutiny” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up one of the best new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.