The function of Severus Snape within the Harry Potter movie collection is so carefully tied to Alan Rickman’s unforgettable portrayal that it’s onerous to think about anybody else within the half.
Nonetheless, earlier than Rickman donned the flowing black robes, the function was really provided to a different acclaimed British actor, Tim Roth.
Immediately we have fun the birthday of the late Alan Rickman, who performed Severus Snape within the Harry Potter movies.
He would have turned 79 years previous right now. pic.twitter.com/FgyMIdjLoN
— Harry Potter Universe (@HPotterUniverse) February 21, 2025
Tim Roth: The Snape That Might Have Been
Roth, on the time, was a longtime expertise with a string of critically acclaimed performances beneath his belt. However whereas he was approached for the half, he finally turned it down, paving the way in which for Rickman, who was not solely J.Ok. Rowling’s best choice but in addition somebody she had envisioned as Snape from the start.
Rickman’s deep, deliberate supply and commanding presence grew to become one of many defining components of the Harry Potter movies, making it tough for a lot of followers to image anybody else within the function.
Would Tim Roth Have Been a Higher Snape?
A put up on the r/TodayILearned subreddit reignited the dialog, with some arguing that Roth’s intense performances in previous roles might have made for a compelling, and maybe even extra book-accurate, Snape.
Immediately I discovered that Tim Roth was provided the function of Snape earlier than Alan Rickman. Do you suppose he might’ve pulled it off?
by inharrypotter
It learn, “Immediately I discovered that Tim Roth was provided the function of Snape earlier than Alan Rickman. Do you suppose he might’ve pulled it off?”
One fan responded, “Tim Roth is a implausible actor, and I’ve little doubt he would have crushed it as Snape.” One other added, “There isn’t a doubt that the late Alan Rickman did a wonderful job, critically I can’t think about another particular person portraying Snape, however Tim Roth was a number of years youthful than the late Alan Rickman, who would have been extra correct to the unique character.”
Others, nonetheless, insisted that Rickman’s efficiency was irreplaceable, with one fan noting that whereas Roth may need introduced a special take to the character, nothing might surpass Rickman’s “immaculate” portrayal.
“Sure, I feel Tim Roth would’ve been a terrific Snape. Not higher than Rickman’s, his portrayal of Snape was immaculate, however completely different and nonetheless nice,” they wrote. “Roth has performed different roles with Snape’s darkish and gloomy disposition, and he’s nearer to e book Snape in each age and look, so he’d have that going for him.”
Curiously, some followers instructed that Roth may need been a greater match for Remus Lupin somewhat than Snape, arguing that David Thewlis’s model of the beloved Protection Towards the Darkish Arts professor lacked the depth they’d hoped for.
“I really like Tim Roth, however I might have really solid him as Lupin over Snape,” one fan penned. “I didn’t just like the actor they used as Lupin in any respect. I can see that he would do a terrific job as Snape, however I might somewhat see him as Lupin simply because I don’t suppose that function was performed justice. Man, he’s too previous for any of that technology at this level, so can’t hope for the brand new present.”
Whereas we’ll by no means understand how Roth’s Snape or Lupin may need turned out, it’s clear that Harry Potter followers love to take a position on what might have been.
For extra such updates, try Hollywood Information
Should Learn: Batman Confirmed For ‘The Courageous & The Daring’: James Gunn Says It Received’t Be Robert Pattinson’s Darkish Knight!
Observe Us: Fb | Instagram | Twitter | Youtube | Google Information