Final 12 months, Jane Schoenbrun publicly contemplated the mediated self with their astounding style effort “I Noticed the TV Glow.” The buzzy Sundance entry imagined a monster-of-the-week TV present actually connecting two realities: a fantastical narrative bridge that allowed Schoenbrun to theorize at size concerning the fictional worlds we love once we’re younger and the true folks they can assist us flip into.
The financial curiosity in our tradition’s most aspirational id is ever-increasing. Consideration is a aggressive social market as hell-bent on fostering self-fabulation as it’s normalizing the microtransaction (and for what it’s value, each issues occur for a similar primary motive). In “Eat the Night time,” co-directors Caroline Poggi and Jonathan Vinel take a much less literal however decidedly extra cynical method than Schoenbrun’s earlier gender-centric movie — exploring as a substitute adjoining themes of up to date id and spotlighting defiance within the face of oppression by class. It’s a unique however however kindred coming-of-age effort with an equally tragic essence: a shaggy and flawed French crime thriller that’s delicate and queer, quick-mutating in its psychological guts, and melancholy with jolts of oddly electrical escapism.
Recognized for his or her 2018 sci-fi debut “Jessica Endlessly,” the reunited co-directors keep extra grounded than that introduction makes their movie sound on this primarily dramatic characteristic. Poggi and Vinel seize an ephemeral nook of contemporary human reference to visible uniqueness of their tonally complicated second story — set in opposition to a sprawling MMO’s final weeks on-line earlier than the worldwide recreation’s servers go darkish ceaselessly. This poetic three-hander follows the shy teenager Apolline (Lila Gueneau) on her quiet-yet-soulful quest to say a correct existential goodbye to her beloved “Darknoon” together with her older brother and longtime fellow gamer, Pablo (Théo Cholbi), throughout one final go to to her digital house.
Apolline’s elaborate avatar and tricked-out weaponry point out the a whole lot of hours she’s already spent within the liminal “there” — and Pablo’s equally spectacular warrior suggests a honest dedication to the fantasy he’s shared together with his sister for the previous decade. Nonetheless, simply as a lot love and keenness may very well be assigned to the twentysomething’s new romantic connection to Night time (Erwan Kepoa Falé), a good-looking stranger who is straight away Pablo’s accomplice in crime and finally turns into his boyfriend.
Extra nefarious authorized schemes have been investigated by child detectives for Disney films than what you truly see Pablo and Night time getting as much as right here. (Severely, Pablo falls in love with Night time whereas educating him to pack tiny skull-shaped tablets in a bafflingly cute {couples}’ montage that’s finest described as “Breaking Dangerous” meets the pottery seduction from “Ghost.”) However the motion is made principally compelling once more by the blistering pace throughout this movie’s again half. The abruptly hurried rhythm of “Eat the Night time” rams you thru the remainder of the drama like a professional gamer’s championship lap, delivering a cascading tonal chase that may really feel extra dizzying than bodily spinning out.
Co-written by the administrators and Guillaume Bréaudand, “Eat the Night time” juxtaposes Pablo and Night time’s principally unremarkable prison enterprise whereas Apolline silently counting down the times till the demise of “Darknoon,” a self-made strain cooker that helps the script go by even quicker, for good or unhealthy. The plain lack of innocence baked into the everlasting finale of “Darknoon” is personally cataclysmic and tauntingly anticlimactic for the 2 siblings, however the narrative manages to stability the stakes of Pablo’s warring priorities nicely. It neither condescends over Apolline’s emotional craving nor diminishes the true hazard dealing with Pablo and Night time in a gang battle that snaps into focus simply because it begins inflicting issues.
The near-equal weight placed on these two wildly disparate emotional arcs appears weirdly becoming of a story that’s clearly been influenced by a utilitarian understanding of recreation design. What bought made right here doesn’t all the time really feel human to look at, and you will get misplaced analyzing the parts of this oddly alien movies that generally function like a type of weird half-puzzle. (On some degree, can’t you swear you’ve seen “Eat the Night time” entrance to finish… earlier than?) However because the star-crossed couple’s affection deepens — and Pablo insists once more that he’ll make time to play “Darknoon” with Apolline later — an all-too-predictable coincidence pulls him away from each Night time and his sister.
Excluding a random scene with a pet snake and a number of other needle drops this film didn’t want, “Eat the Night time” shows spectacular instinct and restraint round its different extra formidable concepts. Forcing Night time and Apolline collectively would possibly seem to be apparent tragedy bait from far-off, however the usually sharp script isn’t so cliched as to place them on a collision course for an “Odd Couple” battle or a saccharine and ill-fitting reunion episode. As a substitute, the pair’s mutual hardship surrounding a shared liked one (the specifics of that are higher skilled with out spoilers) define a rocky panorama for a not often traveled emotional street — one which’s shut sufficient to Earth to earnestly encourage acceptance but in addition stunning sufficient to spur extra of the unhealthy conduct you solely ever see rewarded in video video games.
Created by Lucien Krampf and Sara Dibiza, the so-called “actual” “Darknoon” made for the film resembles one thing like “Fortnite” however lends itself to a extra prompt sense of affection than the precise battle royale sensation. Though the in-film/in-game universe shares a sure shiny resemblance to some precise console staples, the cinematic ambiance achieved for “Eat the Night time” is considerably extra flattering to its younger heroine, her brother, and their identity-shaping obsessions and tastes than a very playable title can be. The wonder and authenticity baked into the “Darknoon” design additional pushes again in opposition to strategies that the movie itself is anti-game and anti-media — an interpretation that may not come to anybody who bothers to look at it at first however may be fairly justified.
Even because the metaphoric traces between the nerdy trio’s on-line and offline personas blur right into a tortured mess — like Apolline’s semi-photorealistic face rising over her avatar’s cartoonish grin proper as she tries on some very grownup cosplay in her room — the specter of a imprecise emotional catastrophe looms. When “Darknoon” ends, what ends with it? Presenting the sport sequences with simply sufficient self-assurance and assured model to avert consideration from any technical limitations, the co-directors promote the digital setting as a compelling backdrop and its personal theatrical presence.
The “Darknoon” experiment isn’t essentially value repeating in one other movie, however the voice-acting in scenes the place Apolline, Pablo, and Night time are having honest conversations by means of their digital avatars whereas the characters are simply “hanging out” makes for a stronger sense of intimacy than you’d assume. With out the supernatural pathways afforded to “I Noticed the TV Glow,” Poggi and Vinel lean closely on these softer moments as a substitute — permitting the serenity of “Darknoon” and the comparative chaos of “Eat the Night time” and its tormented important characters to resonate in a loud and cacophonous discord.
The result’s directly accosting and surprisingly affirming, narrowly saved by a robust solid of performers and moody cinematography that navigate the film’s thinner elements and extra ambiguous moments with relative ease. A temptation to let the modifying get somewhat too intelligent at occasions confuses some lesser subplots, and the general muddy construction nearly undercuts the ending on which “Eat the Night time” in the end hinges. Besides, the divisive movie debuted as a part of the Cannes Administrators’ Fortnight part in 2024 — and whereas it’s not all the time exacting in its media principle, Poggi and Vinel’s newest is an uncommon profitable ode to the endlessly sloppy carousel of roles and video games we every play in our lifetime(s).
Grade: B-
From Altered Innocence, “Eat the Night time” is in restricted theaters in January 2025. In New York Metropolis, from January 10 to 16 on the IFC Middle — with administrators Caroline Poggi and Jonathan Vinel on opening weekend. In Kansas Metropolis, Missouri, from January 10 to 16 at Screenland Armour. In Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on January 10 at PhilaMOCA. In Cleveland, Ohio, on January 30 at Cleveland Institute of Artwork Cinematheque.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect opinions, streaming picks, and provides some new musings, all solely accessible to subscribers.