“Calle Malaga” opens with title playing cards explaining to the viewers the historical past of Tangier’s Spanish inhabitants: How, as Spain fell to fascism below Francisco Franco’s rule within the Thirties individuals fled to the Northwest Moroccan metropolis, and a neighborhood of Spanish audio system blossomed and grew over the many years. It’s a very didactic contact that conveys little past what Carmen Maura’s efficiency as Maria, an aged girl dwelling alone in Tangier, already tells the viewers.
Making her approach by way of the streets of her neighborhood, looking for groceries and warmly greeting her neighbors, Maura makes it apparent that Maria adores her quiet, content material life on this metropolis the place she grew up. And, when Maria’s daughter Clara (Marta Etura) arrives to drop a bombshell — that she must promote the household house, and Maria should both come together with her to Madrid or stay the rest of her life in a nursing neighborhood — the way in which Maura’s face flashes from devastation and horror to anger and metal makes all of it too clear how arduous she’ll combat to keep up this life.
The third characteristic of director Maryam Touzani, “Calle Malaga” strikes chords just like her acclaimed sophomore characteristic “The Blue Caftan” in its exploration of the romantic, home life of somebody effectively previous middle-age. Touzani primarily based the character of Maria partially on her personal Spanish grandmother, and she or he offers Maura — an amazing actress finest identified to American audiences for her work in Pedro Almodóvar motion pictures like “Girls on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown” and “Volver” — an exquisite half to embody. Maria is a splendidly textured character, at turns flinty and chilly and vivacious and humorous, and Maura is adept at embodying all sides to this girl. Nonetheless, the film round her proves so much much less fascinating than it’s foremost character. Often protected and solely skimming the floor of the difficult feelings its premise raises, “Calle Malaga” is likable however by no means fairly fascinating.
Warmly shot with sun-draped lenses by Virginie Surdej and soundtracked by an overbearingly sentimental rating by Freya Arde, “Calle Malaga” introduces the menace on Maria’s home as a tragedy earlier than shortly pivoting to a extra cheery, sentimental story, one during which the girl finds neighborhood and even love by way of the hardship. Artful and resistant, Maria agrees to go to the retirement heart and let Clara put the home available on the market and return to her household in Madrid. Together with her daughter off her again, she fakes a visit to see her to depart the middle and heads again to squat in her unoccupied former house, ultimately teaming up with a younger neighbor to host football-viewing events within the area as a option to scrounge up cash. It additionally helps her purchase again her outdated furnishings from good-looking antiques seller Abslam (Ahmed Boulane), with whom she sparks a tentative romance.
The romantic subplot proves probably the most charming thread “Calle Malaga” has to supply, because of Maura and Boulane’s performances. There’s a wistful sense of longing between them even earlier than issues flip explicitly romantic, and for a comparatively tame and breezy movie it does get genuinely scorching in its depiction of their relationship. In different areas, nevertheless, the script from Touzani and her husband and producer Nabil Ayouch falters in the way in which it fills out the individuals surrounding Maria. Her finest buddy Josefena (María Alfonsa Rosso), a nun who has taken a vow of silence, is extra a tool by way of which Maria can spew her emotions and internal ideas than a fully-formed individual. Sometimes their interactions work to humorous impact, like when she extolls Abslam’s efficiency in mattress to her silent buddy, however the movie stumbles when it tries to construct actual emotional stakes round their bond.
Faring even worse is Clara, thinly rendered as an ungrateful little one and an impediment for her mom. Though she’s launched with very legitimate causes for promoting the residence — she simply went by way of a divorce, she’s struggling financially, she wants the cash to purchase a brand new house for her children — “Calle Malaga” has little curiosity in giving her actual interiority or taking her considerations severely. Her strained relationship together with her mom has little nuance, and the unsatisfying, abrupt ending that leaves the 2 nonetheless at odds proves curiously bitter for an in any other case mild film.
Lack of nuance plagues “Calle Malaga” normally, and it’s significantly obvious in how skinny the neighborhood Maria loves so dearly really is on display. The cobblestone step streets are pleasing on the attention, however the individuals who inhabit this neighborhood and rally to assist Maria don’t have a lot character to talk of. There’s little sense of what her life on this metropolis, as a Spanish girl round principally Moroccans, seems to be like. Regardless of the movie’s introductory textual content, most of “Calle Malaga” may occur in any metropolis on this planet. With out Maura’s efficiency, there’d be no specificity to talk of.
Grade: C+
“Calle Malaga” premiered on the Venice Movie Competition. It’s at the moment searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.