Loads of the essential stuff was actual: the songs, the rhymes, the circulate, the friendship. It was the window-dressing that was, effectively, dressing. Within the early aughts, a pair of Scottish BFFs, Gavin Bain and Billy Boyd, had been determined to flee their provincial lives in coastal Scotland. The boys beloved rapping and revered acts like D12 and Eminem, they usually weren’t half-bad at it, both. The issue? Nobody wished to listen to or see or assist Scottish dudes rapping, with one now-iconic audition ending when a scout sniffed at them and referred to as them “rapping Proclaimers.”
What are two plucky boys to do? In actual life, simply as in James McAvoy’s peppy function directorial debut “California Schemin’” that tracks the story twenty years later, it turned a query of giving the viewers what they wished. And what they wished, Gavin and Billy determined, was a pair of rappers from California. So from California they shall be.
For his function directorial debut, proud Scotsman James McAvoy has loads of materials to tug from: The actual story of Gavin and Billy, after all, plus Bain’s 2010 memoir of the identical identify and a 2013 documentary entitled “The Nice Hip Hop Hoax,” Archie Thomson and Elaine Gracie’s screenplay, and McAvoy’s personal apparently sophisticated emotions about his homeland. Scotland was sophisticated to Gavin and Billy too, and whereas their scheme initially concerned a deliberate massive reveal of their precise provenance, all the higher to stay it to a classist and elitist trade that didn’t need their brogues of their rap music, that slowly falls away.
It’s enjoyable sufficient at first, because of McAvoy’s energetic route and robust turns from its younger stars, together with Seamus McLean Ross (as Gavin, later to be often called Brains), Samuel Bottomley (as Billy, later to be often called Silibil), and the very charming Lucy Halliday (as Billy’s girlfriend Mary). The trio work collectively in a name heart in suburban Dundee, however quiet Gavin can’t assist however dream massive. When he hears about an open audition in London (McAvoy himself performs a splendidly scuzzy music government who places out the decision), he and Billy alight for the massive metropolis.
It doesn’t go effectively, and when the boys are laughed out of the workplace, town, the nation, Gavin gained’t surrender. Free-wheeling, high-spirited Billy doesn’t appear so very bothered, however it’s Billy’s personal work ethos that provides Gavin his sensible thought: on the name heart, they offer the shoppers what they need. Why not try this with their rapping? Bolstered by a pleasant montage that sees the boys boning up on their American tradition and accents — watching “Die Onerous” and screaming “present me the cash!” and “we had been on a break!” — the power is flying by the point they set out for London once more.
This time, they’re from “San de Angeles.” They communicate with a surfer boy have an effect on. They’re carrying a metric ton of skater child attire. They’re Silibil N Brainz. The duo basically bluff their manner by way of town, finally catching the attention of scout Tessa (Rebekah Murrell), who helps them land a contract nearly instantly, their goals coming true with startling pace. However as they zip by way of early aughts London (a visit to the MTV studios to look on “The Hook” will give Millennial movie-goers some severe flashbacks), their quest to “expose the wankers” takes a tough flip. Seems, the razzle-dazzle of the trade can blind nearly anybody.
Most of the story beats listed here are fairly conventional to the music biopic style — Billy begins sleeping round and skipping calls from Mary, Gavin will get actually into medicine and alcohol, each of the boys go all-in on being “from California” — and all of it begins careening towards the inevitable. However that’s form of the purpose: these tales, each actual and pretend, observe this trope-laden arc as a result of that’s what tends to occur most frequently. The trade chews individuals up and spits them (and their goals) proper again out.
It’s the oldest story within the e book, however it’s made all of the extra crushing in “California Schemin’” as a result of Gavin and Billy are so very satisfied they’re those pulling one over on the brass. That stress is rarely fairly resolved, nevertheless, and because the movie strikes nearer to its anticipated revelations, we will already guess how and the place this all may finish. Usual track, simply with a barely completely different tempo.
Grade: B-
“California Schemin’” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Pageant. It’s at present searching for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up one of the best new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.