“Who appreciates Camille as a lot as they do a chair? She’s by no means been capable of simply sit there silently and nonetheless be beloved?”
These phrases, spoken by an invisible narrator (Melanie Lynskey) initially of “By Design” synthesize the premise of Amanda Kramer‘s newest work, a gore-free piece of physique horror that seeks to discover feminine objectification in probably the most literal potential phrases. Utilizing summary dance and painful silences as an instance the contrasting experiences of a girl and an inanimate chair who change our bodies, the movie unfolds like a considerate nightmare advised via the distinct gaze that made Kramer’s movies like “Please Child Please” and “Ladyworld” unforgettable. The movie typically feels as unimaginable to definitively grasp because the coveted furnishings that it follows — however whether or not that’s a function or a bug lies within the eye of the beholder.
After we meet Camille (Juliette Lewis), she’s trapped in a lifetime of soul-crushing monotony that seems benign from the skin. Whereas she yearns for some form of mental stimulation, she spends her days going to boring lunches together with her “mates” Lisa (Samantha Lewis) and Irene (Robin Tunney), who solely communicate in pleasantries that drip with passive aggression. Kramer scripts and shoots their conversations with a deliberate stiffness, stylizing the sequences of feminine intrasexual competitors to the purpose the place you couldn’t presumably be deluded into believing the type phrases that depart their mouths. Every humblebrag-filled lunch is adopted by a day procuring journey, the place the three ladies admire furnishings that they’re fast to level out the others may by no means afford.
One such journey turns into a life-altering occasion when Camille sees a chair that modifications her complete worldview. Whether or not she’s genuinely moved by the great thing about its design or just on the lookout for an excuse to explode her personal routine is irrelevant. She decides that she merely will need to have it. She spends the night getting her meager funds so as and speaking herself into making a purchase order she will be able to’t actually afford, and reveals up the second the store opens the subsequent day to purchase it — solely to search out {that a} mysterious different buyer has already crushed her to it. In a second of desperation, she needs that she may turn into the chair, pondering that one thing so stunning will need to have a extra snug life she does.
She will get her want, and shortly finds herself being shipped off to an eccentric musician named Olivier (Mamoudou Athie). A pianist who sustains himself by taking part in at personal events for teams of six folks or much less in unusual rooms that really feel ripped from a Lynchian nightmare, he has by no means been one for possessions. His bachelor pad feels ripped straight from /r/malelivingspace, with little greater than a keyboard, a mattress, and a few dumbbells adorning the bottom. Ultimately, this chair appears like one thing stunning he can actually personal. With a world of collectors making an attempt to accumulate it from him, his minimalism evaporates as defending his worldly attachment to it turns into his sole focus.
The remainder of the movie unfolds in more and more nonverbal phrases, because the chair containing Camille’s soul has no mouth with which to precise its ideas and her physique with the thoughts of a chair has no such ideas to precise. Kramer depends closely on interpretive dance and classical music cues to convey feelings, crafting an immersive world that’s stunning on the floor however devoid of any genuine heat. “By Design” turns into an exploration of ways in which Camille and the chair’s lives change and the methods they continue to be the identical.
Regardless of Camille being diminished to an inanimate object that may do little greater than sit with a clean look in her eyes, her conversations together with her overbearing mom don’t change that a lot. She may hardly get a phrase in between her mother’s tales and grievances earlier than she had the thoughts of a chair — and if something, the matriarch is simply grateful to have even fewer interruptions to endure. Her conversations with Lisa and Irene are equally banal. Whereas the 2 mates not less than discover that she’s modified, they flip the event into a chance to compete to see who can seem to do extra to assist her with out really doing something in any respect.
Kramer intentionally chooses the broadest potential metaphors, leading to a movie that’s extra fascinated by utilizing a hammer to bluntly form the define of the feminine expertise than portray its best particulars with a delicate brush. However its largest concepts — like the best way that society seemingly doesn’t care when a girl fully loses her skill to talk; or the contradiction between a girl who craves mental stimulation but casts a want to be desired and possessed for her appears alone — are definitely worthy of exploration in her succesful palms. Visually unmistakable and fearlessly summary, “By Design” stands out as a key entry in an more and more important filmography. It gained’t be for everybody, however that’s by design.
Grade: B
“By Design” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Pageant. It’s at present looking for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the perfect new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.