Even within the comparatively regulated world of the modern web, you by no means know what the particular person subsequent to you is taking a look at on their cellphone: Fascist propaganda? Hardcore pornography? Photographs from a church picnic? So it goes that the grey, featureless workplace constructing that offers “American Sweatshop” its title seems to be prefer it might be something. The one signal that one thing is off right here is the on-site counselor — and the staff vomiting and crying and having rage-filled tantrums at their desks.
Content material moderation is a well-documented phenomenon, first dropped at widespread public consideration by Adrian Chen’s 2014 “Wired” article “The Laborers Who Maintain Dick Pics and Beheadings Out of Your Fb Feed.” The headline there says all of it: All over the world, a silent military of low-wage employees manually overview flagged content material on social-media websites to find out whether or not or not it violates the location’s phrases of service. In apply, this implies being uncovered to a continuing stream of CSAM, homicide, and sexual content material for hours day-after-day, with all of the dangerous psychological results one suspects may observe.
A number of documentaries have adopted content material moderators at work, and the 2022 Filipino film “Deleter” turned the career right into a horror movie. Nonetheless, it’s comparatively recent as an idea for a characteristic, with one drawback: “Pink Rooms” got here out final 12 months. Pascal Plante’s chilly Quebecois techno-thriller isn’t about content material moderation per se, however its descent-into-hell construction is — deliberately or not — mimicked right here. By comparability, “American Sweatshop” can’t determine if it’s an earnest ensemble drama or an edgy vigilante thriller, which speaks to the weaknesses of each the screenplay and director Uta Briesewitz’s comparatively artless strategy to the fabric.
On the plus aspect, “American Sweatshop” is considerate and detailed, constructing its characters and their world with small, however revealing beats like a closeup of Korean immigrant Paul’s (Jeremy Ang Jones) boxed lunch and the casualness with which aspiring nurse Daisy (Lili Reinhart) steps out to smoke a joint whereas on break on the trauma manufacturing facility. A gap scene lays out the grotesque absurdity of the state of affairs, as workplace supervisor Pleasure (Christiane Paul) delineates between culinary content material and animal abuse in a gathering. If an individual kills an animal on digicam, that’s abuse. In the event that they kill an animal and eat it, that’s cooking.
“Nuance is essential,” she says, a tip that screenwriter Matthew Nemeth might have taken for himself on the subject of Pleasure’s expository dialogue later within the movie. The movie has an earnest concern for its characters, together with Daisy, her jaded work bestie Ava (Daniela Melchor), Paul, and Bob (Joel Fry), the workplace wild card who everybody suspects may snap and shoot up the place sometime. Daisy is the one one whose life outdoors of labor is explored in any element, and is the heroine of the vigilante storyline referenced above. Nonetheless, “American Sweatshop” spends sufficient time with the remainder of them, notably Paul, that it’s unclear which is the “A” plot and which is the “B” one.
This weakens each of them, bringing the movie to a halt in between Daisy’s — let’s say — imprecise expression of her rage over seeing an particularly graphic “fetish video” known as “Nail in Her” and the results of that incident in her on a regular basis life. The pause obliterates any rigidity that may have constructed up throughout earlier sequences, which additionally embrace Daisy auditioning as a “mannequin” on the similar firm that produced the video with a purpose to get nearer to the individuals who made it. That scene takes a moralistic, anticlimactic flip — as does the film itself, which fits to loads of hassle to diagnose an institutional drawback solely to suggest a person answer. Are you being floor into mud by a system designed to guard the rich on the expense of the poor? Strive volunteering at a soup kitchen, that ought to assist.
Briesewitz is equally conflicted on the subject of really displaying the content material that so impacts our characters. Given how judgmental the movie in the end is about pornography, equating it with snuff movies and beheading movies, she will be able to’t get too graphic or else danger being labeled a hypocrite. (“The nastiness leaks in,” as one character says.) However she must put the viewers into Daisy’s mindset, which she accomplishes by displaying every little thing wanting the deaths themselves. Titles flash on the display: “Man Run Over By Prepare.” “Fetus in Blender.” We see an individual leaping off of a constructing, however Briesewitz cuts away earlier than they hit the bottom.
If this appears like “American Sweatshop” is attempting to have it each methods, that’s as a result of it’s. It needs to titillate, and to guage. To indicate, and to inform. To enrage, and to pacify. Mixed with the by-the-numbers route and unremarkable cinematography, the general impact is of an after-school particular about how social media is unhealthy for you — which it in all probability is, to be honest.
Grade: C+
“American Sweatshop” premiered at SXSW 2025. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up one of the best new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.