Everyone desires rom-coms to have a renaissance, however no one appears to understand how they need to evolve to replicate the realities of the trendy world. Few of the current efforts to resurrect the shape have been meaningfully profitable, and most of these uncommon successes have used sizzling new stars to cover their reliance on dusty previous tropes; no shade to the breezy attraction of “Anybody however You,” however nobody would accuse that Shakespeare-inspired charmer of making an attempt to maneuver the style ahead.
The prevailing knowledge is that the unfettered want success of films like “Sleepless in Seattle” (or no matter) is a poor match for the messiness of the digital age, even when it actually had extra to do with the truth that social media has made it exhausting to write down an honest meet-cute, and the streaming increase gave Hollywood studios an excuse to cease making an attempt. However want success was all the time only a means to get audiences within the theater and ship them residence pleased. The reality is that messiness itself — inside sure, simply resolved parameters — was all the time the very factor that rom-coms did finest.
As far as Chad Hartigan’s “The Threesome” is worried, it’s additionally one of the best motive to deliver them again. A really twenty first century film that does what it could actually to faux that iPhones don’t exist, this winsome story of a hook-up gone horribly unsuitable — or fatefully proper!? — compensates for avoiding the web of all of it by doubling down on the chaos and confusion that it’s sown into the courting scene. Tripling down, even.
Extra agreeably comedic than laugh-out-loud humorous (it errs nearer towards dramedy than rom-com, and solely will get away with that as a result of its characters are so aggressively resistant of labels), “The Threesome” would look like a traditional story of a pal crush that blossoms into one thing extra critical after a drunken evening out. “The Little Mermaid” breakout Jonah Hauer-King performs Connor, a curly-haired pet canine of a manboy who understandably can’t assist however pine after the only coolest — and coolest single — 30-year-old lady in all of Little Rock. Her identify is Olivia (Zoey Deutch, fortifying her standing as Gen Z’s rom-com queen), she has a caustic humorousness, and she or he as soon as jerked off to Billy Joel. Extra relevantly, she additionally had informal intercourse with Connor in some unspecified time in the future within the not too distant previous, however you possibly can inform from the way in which his eyes observe her round a room that it wasn’t so informal for a hopeless romantic like him. Whereas it doesn’t appear to be these two have a ton of shared historical past collectively, Ethan Ogilby’s impressively dexterous authentic screenplay leans into conference sufficient to counsel that it’s solely a matter of time earlier than they may.
Lower to: A enjoyable evening on the clurrbbb, the place the photogenic pals dance the evening away with the lovable Mary Elizabeth Winstead look-alike they met by probability earlier that night. Her identify is Jenny (“Bottoms” actress Ruby Cruz, pleasant in a efficiency that’s improbable at taking part in harmless with out ever tipping over into naive), she’s a youthful grad scholar who doesn’t appear to have any pals over her personal, and she or he doesn’t say no when Olivia insists all of them return to her place. Nor does she blanche on the suggestion of Reality or Dare, a sport that has by no means as soon as in historical past been performed with out an ulterior motive. Evidently, everybody wins.
Nonetheless you would possibly anticipate a candy and buoyant film referred to as “The Threesome” to unfold from there, that’s not the way in which issues go this time round. Connor doesn’t fall in love with each ladies, they don’t fall in love with one another… the story that Hartigan and Ogilby are interested by spinning out of that premise — “that premise” being “what if three engaging individuals had intercourse collectively” — doesn’t actually match the size of a love triangle or a romantic entanglement of every other clearly definable form.
For one factor, there’s no ambiguity to the truth that Connor desires Olivia and Olivia solely. For one more, issues between all three of those individuals are about to get a lot messier than anybody would ever be capable to hint with a stencil. I don’t need to give an excessive amount of away (although it’s a credit score to the movie that I really do need to give an excessive amount of away), but it surely’s protected to imagine that the occasions of that one magical evening will reverberate for a very long time to come back. And that you simply’ll should droop your disbelief somewhat bit if you happen to hope to have a very good time browsing on the shockwaves.
After all, realism has all the time been a fungible idea on the subject of a romantic comedy, whether or not you’re speaking in regards to the story of a lifetime falling into Gregory Peck’s lap in “Roman Vacation,” or Josh Hartnett going 40 days — and 40 nights! — with out an orgasm in a film whose title is escaping me in the meanwhile. However “The Threesome” wears its style trappings much more evenly than most movies prefer it (you possibly can see it in Sing Howe Yam’s cinematography, which trades the same old gloss for a extra delicate indie sheen), and its varied twists of destiny can appear a bit extra contrived than they could in a extra fanciful rom-com-like factor.
Such issues would possibly threaten to upend a simpler film, however “The Threesome” — as precariously balanced alongside the border between genres as it’s alongside the high-quality line between one section of life and one other — makes use of them to replicate the unsure geometry of contemporary maturity. Early within the story, earlier than a sure friction develops between them, Olivia assures Jenny that she has “loads of time to search out her individuals,” however the occasions that transpire from there have a humorous means of suggesting that none of those characters have all that a lot time left to search out themselves. Not on their very own phrases, anyway. The world has by no means been as freeform and unsettled as it’s at present, and a movie like “The Threesome” is so refreshing due to how truthfully it leverages traditional style strictures to search out the non-public alternative in that.
Heavy as issues get, Hartigan and his forged always remember that all the characters in a film like this are all the time clinging to concern as they fumble in the direction of happiness, and “The Threesome” retains the rom-com of all of it cooking on the backburner even when the motion within the foreground appears extra consistent with a melodrama. Jaboukie Younger-White offers top-notch homosexual finest pal as Connor’s — look ahead to it — homosexual finest pal, Deutch is uncooked and prickly sufficient to ship scorching one-liners in the midst of even essentially the most intense confrontations, and Hauer-King fulfills the style necessities by taking part in a square-jawed white boy whose dimples are deeper than any a part of his character. The actor’s efficiency would have benefited from a lighter contact, as even the silliest jokes he makes are freighted with simpering anxiousness, however Connor is plausible sufficient as a guileless himbo with a concern of abandonment, and Deutch and Cruz every have sufficient charisma to energy a complete film on their very own.
Hartigan doesn’t power them to. He provides them loads of help simply by inviting them to observe conventional character arcs which were twisted into one thing extra like a maze. The nowness of all of it is extra natural than overbearing (it manifests itself in every part from a pointed Elon Musk reference to a plot element that hinges on current adjustments to sure legal guidelines, even when the premise is inextricably rooted in a bedrock of conservatism), and the love — or not less than the will for it — burning away on the movie’s middle is traditional sufficient that even the movie’s ostensibly unconventional ending looks like coming residence. “The Threesome” doesn’t all the time really feel like what you would possibly consider whenever you think about a “fashionable” rom-com, however that’s what makes this one of many uncommon films that really suits the invoice.
Grade: B
“The Threesome” premiered at SXSW 2025. It’s at present searching for U.S. distribution.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up one of the best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.