Two statements made within the opening act of Michael Shanks’ queasy, principally intelligent characteristic filmmaking debut “Collectively” will come to hang-out each its stars and viewers: 1. That “everybody is aware of” Tim (Dave Franco) wants his girlfriend Millie (Franco’s real-life spouse Alison Brie) greater than she wants him, and a couple of. In the event that they cut up later, it’s going to simply harm extra. And, oh boy, does Shanks — and his very sport stars and producers — take these seemingly trite relationship observations to wild ends over the course of this delightfully unhinged spin on the physique horror joint.
We first meet Millie and Tim as they’re about to maneuver from metropolitan Melbourne to the Aussie countryside. Schoolteacher Millie has been provided an excellent gig at a comfortable, small city college, marking seemingly the primary time the long-time (however pointedly not married) couple have made any huge modifications to accommodate Millie’s desires. Certain, Tim continues to be attempting to make it as a musician, however his comparatively superior age (rock excursions are for the children or the extremely wealthy, neither of which Tim is) doesn’t scream “subsequent huge factor!” anymore, and the emotional hangover from the horrific deaths of his dad and mom (actual nightmare fodder, for him and the viewers) aren’t serving to issues. Thus: transfer to the nation!
What Millie and Tim don’t know — and what, crucially, the viewers does, care of a jumpy, sticky opening that lets us in on some pre-move occasions within the couple’s soon-to-be dwelling — is that the bucolic space they’re decamping to is way extra, effectively, bubonic. Let’s put it this manner: nobody ought to ever drink stagnant water of any form, and also you certain as hell shouldn’t do it on the backside of a creepy cave full of half-smashed church pews and all method of squishy substances. Millie and Tim are going to be taught that the very onerous method.
There’s one thing amiss earlier than they make it to mentioned creepy cave, nevertheless, because the pair’s first day of their beautiful new home is marked by the invention of a fetid, not-entirely-dead rat king stuffed above a piping scorching mild fixture. Later, Tim will be capable of draw a line between that discovery — to make sure, a screamingly fucked-up soar scare that ought to depart audiences yelping and tittering in equal measure — and one other rodent-based discover from his youth. Franco brings a compelling darkness to Tim, first introduced as a little bit of a tragic boy, earlier than reworking into one thing solely completely different. And Millie? Brie portrays her as a delicate, form soul with a fast-approaching restrict. Millie desires solutions, and she or he’s gonna get ’em.
Nobody’s imagining {that a} easy hike by means of the paths that dot the countryside behind their home goes to completely repair Millie and Tim’s simmering relationship points, nevertheless it’s a begin, proper? Shanks’ script, imaginative as it’s, doesn’t get too caught up in obscuring what’s to come back (pay attention, it’s proper there within the title), as an alternative putting extra weight (and delight) on unraveling how we’re going to get there. No, nobody ought to drink stagnant water from a creepy cave, however “Collectively” doesn’t work except Millie and Tim do, after which we will get on with the remainder of it.
And what a remainder of it it’s! Ultimately free of the cave, a really not-good-feeling Tim is first to note one thing is improper. Largely, he can’t be away from Millie anymore, actually. He feels ailing, jittery, confused, out of physique when she will get too far, and for a dude who noticed his dad and mom shuffle off this mortal coil as a consequence of psychological sickness, that’s double scary. He tries all the things, a frantic Franco zipping between pharmaceutical aids and a few very ill-advised Fb stalking, whereas an alternately frightened and offended Brie each screens the state of affairs and tries to get away from it. Tim wants her greater than she wants him. And perhaps they need to have cut up earlier, as a result of it’s simply going to harm extra now.
Of some help: a sly Damon Herriman, forged right here as Millie’s fellow instructor Jamie. Is Jamie focused on Millie romantically? Is he only a good dude? What’s up together with his relationship standing? Why does he appear to be the one particular person taking note of the brand new couple? Why does he know a lot about that damned soiled cave? And what the hell is happening with these marriage ceremony photographs in his home? The solutions to all these questions (and extra!) will come, and the giddy, gross pleasures of “Collectively” will, too.
Shanks’ usually clear scene-setting principally serves as an additive to the enjoyable of the movie, from the primary look to a tiny electrical noticed (would possibly as effectively name it Chekhov’s Tiny Electrical Noticed) to these daring opening scenes that don’t cover what’s to come back, however that tends so as to add to the enjoyment of watching the movie, these edgy expectations, that need to guess what’s coming subsequent (and the delight once you’re proper).
And whereas it’s simple to poke holes in a few of the logic Shanks’ script appears to assume is baked proper in — with out spoiling an excessive amount of, we’ve bought loads of questions on how a lot the broader neighborhood is clued into what’s actually occurring, plus nonetheless extra queries in regards to the bodily (and, sure, sexual) implications of a lot of it — within the second, it’s onerous to not get pulled into the spectacle, caught to the story, actually related to this crowd-pleasing (and -screaming) little ditty of a midnight deal with.
Grade: B
“Collectively” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition. Neon bought it for U.S. distribution on the pageant.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the very best new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.