They weren’t the largest band on this planet, however for awhile there, they had been the largest band on this planet to Charles (Tim Key). Now that he’s alone and flush with money (due to not one, however two huge lottery wins), there’s nothing he’d like greater than to reunite stated band — referred to as Mortimer McGwyer, after members Nell Mortimer (Carey Mulligan) and Herb McGwyer (Tom Basden) — on his far-flung island residence for a very non-public gig. What may probably go fallacious?
Whereas James Griffiths’ “The Ballad of Wallis Island” is constructed on a smidge of deception — Nell and Herb way back parted methods, each personally and professionally, and it’s fairly clear Herb wouldn’t have agreed to such a gig if he’d identified Nell can be there — the movie is sort of warm-hearted. Charles is a dad-joke-spouting oddball, and whereas his relentless spew of horrible puns and gags may initially rankle, they ultimately converse to his intense loneliness and actual need for connection. Bringing Mortimer McGwyer to his beautiful island house is an act of actual love, each for himself and his personal long-lost love.
Herb doesn’t need to hear it. When the practically washed-up rock star fairly actually washes up on Wallis Island — “Isn’t there a harbor?,” he bellows earlier than plunging face-first into the surf from a tiny boat, the island’s solely mode of entrance — it’s apparent he’s not going to vibe with no matter Charles is throwing down. And that’s earlier than Nell and (gulp) her husband Michael (Akemnji Ndifornyen) present up. It’s not hijinks that ensue, extra low-key emotional revelations, set to music and within the register of a John Carney joint.
Lengthy-time collaborators Griffiths, Basden, and Key have been noodling with the idea of the movie for fairly a while, initially conceiving of it as brief movie “The One and Solely Herb McGwyer Performs Wallis Island,” which received greatest brief at The Edinburgh Movie Competition and was nominated for a BAFTA in 2007. That these characters — Basden and Key wrote each the brief and this function collectively, with Basden himself penning over two dozen songs for the movie — really feel so lived in and actual shouldn’t shock, and the addition of Mulligan solely provides nonetheless extra depth to the proceedings.
This trio may simply be decreased to tropes or archetypes: the sell-out rock star (Herb has moved into pop music within the intervening years, it’s demeaning as all hell), the crunchy has-been (nowadays, Nell sells chutney on the native farmers market), and the kooky fan (Charles’ nutty jokes and continuous yammer barely conceal a damaged coronary heart), however Basden and Key know their guys and gal, and the place they should go.
Think about the thriller of why Nell and Herb broke up all these years in the past, which one other movie would probably deal with as some type of skeleton key to all the factor, the sort of plot twist deployed at a second that requires a giant, blustery emotional revelation. As an alternative, Griffiths and his collaborators count on the viewers will develop to grasp why these two parted to start with, primarily based on the place they’re now and even the place they had been means again when. It’s a loving selection, each to the movie’s characters and its viewers.
Basden’s songs equally had a heat texture to the movie, and whereas they won’t be as catchy as different tracks in related movies, he and Mulligan make great music collectively, and their fractured bond is most plausible once they’re singing collectively. The result’s a comfortable crowdpleaser with actual coronary heart and a few beautiful songs, and one which doesn’t commerce honesty for predictable beats.
Grade: B
Focus Options will launch “The Ballad of Wallis Island” in restricted theaters on Friday, March 28.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the perfect new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.