“Why don’t you could have a seat over right here.”
It’s perverse {that a} TV information program about little one predators shortly developed its personal catchphrase, as if silver-throated host Chris Hansen had been simply one other incarnation of Steve Urkel, however such was the addictive mixture of harrowing docudrama and lizard mind leisure that outlined the “Dateline NBC” spinoff “To Catch a Predator.”
On the air from 2004 to 2007, the present adopted a easy components: Members of a volunteer group often known as “Perverted-Justice” would discover males on-line and lure them to a home with the specific promise of getting intercourse with a minor. When the marks arrived, they’d be greeted by a young-looking decoy — just for Hansen to step out of the shadows a second later, together with a digital camera crew able to broadcast their disgrace to the world. After sputtering apologies and pleading for mercy whereas Hansen learn aloud from the transcripts of their on-line chat logs, the predators had been instructed they had been “free to go.” By the later seasons of the present, a few of these unsuspecting visitor stars should have recognized {that a} mob of native cops was ready to deal with them the second they stepped outdoors.
Backstopped by the sheer horror of the crimes that its topics meant to commit in opposition to kids, “To Catch a Predator” successfully turned an unspeakable act into the stuff of a public spectacle. It didn’t appear to matter that the present made the overwhelming majority of those instances unimaginable to prosecute, or that filming it threatened to confuse the boundaries between leisure media and regulation enforcement much more than “Cops” already had; folks reveled within the sheer actuality and schadenfreude of watching a foul man’s life come to an finish earlier than their eyes, and few would argue that the predators ensnared by Hansen’s entice deserved a a lot completely different destiny. Partly, that’s as a result of these males meant to do such horrible issues. And partially, that’s as a result of “pedophile” is a phrase that has the facility to make even the suggestion of nuance appear unforgivably immoral (which helps to clarify its outstanding use as a political weapon).
A uncooked and riveting documentary that skeptically re-examines this system’s attraction, legacy, and ethicality, David Osit’s “Predators” definitely doesn’t make the case that Hansen’s marks had been harmless bystanders who had been entrapped in opposition to their will. Quite the opposite, the movie opens with the skin-crawling audio of a cellphone name between a 37-year-old predator and one of many “13-year-old” decoys from Perverted-Justice, and that alone is sufficient to set up the incontrovertible awfulness of what was at stake with these sting operations.
And but, as each a filmmaker whose work (“Mayor,” “Thank You for Taking part in”) has all the time been compelled by ethical inquiry, in addition to an individual for whom “To Catch a Predator” triggered a swirl of conflicting feelings, Osit is haunted by his enjoyment of a present that was finally much less fascinated by crime than punishment. Hansen’s theatrics helped paved the best way for a media panorama pushed by humiliation rituals, and “Predators” leverages the success of that NBC program — together with the tragedy of the way it ended, and the YouTube vigilantes who’ve iterated on its format with even much less oversight than Hansen ever had — right into a probing investigation of its personal.
The movie’s final conclusion is obvious from the beginning: “To Catch a Predator” was an invite to see the world in black-and-white, a prospect which has solely grow to be extra engaging in gentle of America’s subsequent chaos. It was an invite to tar and feather folks so plainly “evil” that everybody watching alongside at residence couldn’t assist however to really feel “good” by comparability. And although it bought itself as an invite to make sense of an inexplicable unsuitable, the present’s energy was rooted within the permission it gave us to disregard why such heinous violations proceed to occur.
To paraphrase the Scandinavian ethnographer who Osit interviews all through the movie: Chris Hansen may ask his targets to “assist me perceive” why they prey on kids, however the attraction of reveals like “To Catch a Predator” hinges on not understanding their topics. “For those who present these males as human beings,” the interviewee says, “the present sort of breaks down.” Nonetheless lively immediately, Hansen has now been staging these sting operations for greater than 20 years, and but he’s no nearer to realizing why some males can’t cease themselves from falling into his traps.
That telling admission doesn’t emerge till the movie’s third act, during which Hansen agrees to a sit-down interview that frames the previous “To Catch a Predator” host as if he had been one of many present’s unsuspecting marks. First, Osit catches up with a few of Hansen’s ex-collaborators, whose unresolved emotions concerning the expertise complicate the present’s repute as an ethical campaign. One of many decoys Osit interviews smiles on the digital camera as she fondly reminisces about her days as an actress, however her discomfort grows as she’s made to reply questions she’s by no means dared to ask herself. One other is extra clearly traumatized by his involvement within the present, significantly as a result of he was forged within the episode that ended with a person killing himself because the digital camera crew made its method into his home. One regulation enforcement officer refers to his participation as “a stain on my soul.”
“Predators” makes positive to listen to from a number of members who’re pleased with their work on this system (or different packages prefer it), most notably a Kentucky DA who appears like he got here straight from “The Dukes of Hazzard,” and insists that his job was solely to seize predators, to not rehabilitate them. Most of those folks serve to bolster the dehumanization at work, none extra so than the police officer who responded to the aforementioned suicide, and — in footage from the day — may be seen laughing concerning the useless earlier than his physique has even been faraway from the home.
Soliciting empathy for little one predators can be a high-wire act for any documentary filmmaker, however Osit is much less fascinated by placing Hansen’s targets on trial than he’s in interrogating our want to behave as decide, jury, and executioner. (I’m unsure if that explains why he doesn’t interview any members of Perverted-Justice, or if it makes their absence appear all of the extra obtrusive.) Break up into three elements that replicate an infinite sample of crime, punishment, and cultural recidivism, “Predators” fixates on our shared complicity in persevering with that cycle with each click on.
The center part of the movie introduces us to “Skeet Hansen,” among the many highest-profile of the numerous Chris Hansen imitators who’ve discovered success on YouTube, and it’s instantly clear that the man isn’t doing any favors to his namesake. Bumbling and unrehearsed the place the OG Hansen was smoother than a used automotive salesman, the shoddiness of Skeet’s operation solely serves to underscore how transparently “To Catch a Predator” exploited the worst crimes conceivable for affordable leisure.
And Skeet no less than has the decency to name the cops on his targets when he’s carried out with them — so lots of the newbie predators you could find on-line immediately desire to assault their targets in public and depart them for useless because the content material uploads to Twitter and TikTok. Damning as Skeet’s look is likely to be, Osit convincingly argues that anybody who watches his movies is simply as complicit in persevering with the cycle.
To that time, probably the most illuminating a part of the movie’s center chapter is the sunshine it shines on the victims of childhood sexual abuse, and the way a few of them — maybe greater than anybody else — may play an lively function in perpetuating the false binary between good and evil. Skeet’s most enthusiastic collaborator is revealed to be a survivor, and the nonchalant testimony she provides right here articulates why folks like her is likely to be significantly wanting to see little one predators get strung up in a digital city sq.: It’s not solely out of revenge, but in addition as a result of such the cause-and-effect of crime and punishment permits her to make sense of a trauma that should be all of the extra agonizing to endure with out an evidence.
That’s no less than the best way Osit sees it. The director has requested critics to debate the third act of his movie with discretion, nevertheless it’s secure to say that “Predators” stems from a private want for catharsis. Just like the present it places underneath the microscope, Osit’s documentary mines “content material” from abhorrent criminality, nevertheless it does so to radically completely different ends. Osit isn’t any extra certified to — or fascinated by — “resolve” the epidemic of kid predators than Chris Hansen has ever been, however he’s clearly troubled by the truth that Hansen and his imitators rely on impeding our capacity to meaningfully handle this disaster. If something, their work exists to advertise, and to inflate the general public’s impression of how widespread the disaster actually is.
Did “To Catch a Predator” save a small variety of kids from being abused? Probably. Most likely, even. And even one can be motive sufficient to rejoice it for that. However, like a lot of the media that has been made and consumed within the twenty first century, the present did so due to its personal self-insistent want to exist, and its success was dependent upon simplifying a world that continues to develop extra difficult by the day; upon eroding nuance, problematizing sensitivity, and mulching real concern into unrepentant bloodlust.
As “Predator” makes clear in a heartbreaking apart a few newly 18-year-old highschool pupil whose life was ruined after Hansen discovered that he was relationship a youthful classmate (the age hole between them authorized in a number of different states), there are very actual penalties to presenting dehumanization as a righteous act of public justice. “To Catch a Predator” may seem to be the unsuitable lens by which to make that case, as few folks invite much less sympathy than the boys who discovered their method into Hansen’s net. However that’s precisely what makes Osit’s movie such a strong indictment of the lens by which we’ve since been conditioned to see every thing else as effectively.
Grade: B+
“Predators” premiered on the 2025 Sundance Movie Competition. It’s at present looking for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the perfect new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.