“Mufasa: The Lion King” is strictly what you’d count on from a photorealistic Disney prequel/sequel directed by indie filmmaker Barry Jenkins. In different phrases, our man misplaced. As insecure as its title, the Home of Mouse’s newest spin-off of an animated traditional comes from the Oscar winner behind the moody, R-rated masterpiece “Moonlight.” Jenkins’ pivot to a big-budget, kid-friendly challenge for a significant studio was at all times intriguing. However in hindsight, it’s exhausting to think about he ever actually stood an opportunity at revolutionizing from inside Disney’s so-called “live-action” cash machine.
A busy-yet-bland franchise addition, “Mufasa” serves as the most recent chronicle of the identical lion-based occasions of Jon Favreau’s divisive “The Lion King” from 2019. Though critically disliked, that movie made $1.65 billion on the worldwide field workplace by staying largely devoted to the unique transfer in a ground-breaking visible type. It connected a roster of A-list expertise, together with Donald Glover and Beyoncé (who return briefly in “Mufasa”), and was heralded as a technical achievement on the Academy Awards. Your mileage on that “Polar Specific” could differ, after all.
Regardless of Jenkins’ monitor document and clear inventive contact, the sunshine of Favreau’s semi-success taints every little thing all it touches right here. The contrived script from Jeff Nathanson — introducing extra lions with political and sexual frustrations than it is aware of what to do with — is packed entrance to finish with raging rivers, steep cliffs, and poorly justified plot factors tying these causes for motion sequences collectively. Supporting practically as many new characters as there are genuflecting giraffes at Delight Rock, “Mufasa” is a story-within-a-story that reframes “The Lion King” inside a sprawling map that’s not a lot enjoyable to really discover.
The maximalist strategy isn’t prone to work when your warm-up act was a single-variable experiment… and also you’re solely retaining the variable individuals didn’t like… however even treating the 2019 movie as the usual, the “Mufasa” visuals buckle beneath the pressure of such an untamed narrative. A fantasy sequence skews a little bit too near a Lisa Frank folder, whereas an enemy contingent of snow-white lions generally known as The Outsiders mix collectively within the worst approach. Plus, Simba’s daughter Kiara (Blue Ivy Carter) pops up wanting much less like a collector’s Nationwide Geographic and extra like a flesh-and-blood Neopet in some way received offline.
Informed by Rafiki (John Kani) to the lovely lion cub as an inspiring story about her grandfather, the primary arc traces how Mufasa (Aaron Pierre) got here to be King — and the way he met not simply Rafiki, but additionally his future queen Sarabi (Tiffany Boone) and chicken advisor Zazu (Preston Nyman). What occurred to 1994’s Father of the 12 months earlier than he was flung off a cliff right into a pack of wildebeests? Unsurprisingly, it bears a hanging resemblance to his son’s story and serves as a sneaky “Maleficent”/“Cruella” type origin story for Scar.
After getting separated from his household by an amazing flood — a stunning quantity of this film takes place within the snow and underwater — a younger Mufasa (each Braelyn and Brielle Rankins voice the cub) finds himself an orphan of circumstance. The misplaced creature is reluctantly taken in by a half-friendly delight when his new buddy Taka (Theo Somulu, later Kelvin Harrison Jr.) rescues him from a would-be crocodile assault. Taka’s mom, Eshe (Thandiwe Newton), embraces Mufasa immediately, however Taka’s fearsome father and the delight’s chief, Obasi (Lennie James), refuses to simply accept him utterly.
Within the “current” day, Kiara listens to Rafiki intently with perpetual scene-stealers Timone (Billy Eichner) and Pumbaa (Seth Rogen) serving as each meta commentary — and a reminder that Simba had it approach higher, even consuming bugs.
“Can I make a suggestion?” Timone asks Rafiki, in one in every of two scenes seemingly designed to be quoted in a “Mufasa” evaluation. “Attempt much less childhood drama, extra meerkat.”
It’s an inexpensive suggestion. Unimaginative musical numbers match the unique bangers with copycat songs virtually one-for-one, and simply as Mufasa’s adoptive household begins to settle down, a fair greater menace emerges. Circled by a military of all-white lions (which, when you Google them, are uncommon, however do exist!), Taka and Mufasa are compelled to flee the wrath of the inconsistently caddy Kiros (Mads Mikkelsen) proper as he’s singing his foolish little villain track, “Bye Bye,” to the remainder of his stolen topics.
If even one courageous choice was made throughout this challenge, then it was casting a Danish dude in a universe well-known for its use of Swahili. Mikkelsen’s distinctive voice additional protects his character from a pitfall that most of the different lions fall into. Awash with photorealistic sameness, “Mufasa” captures Jenkins’ literal try and herd massive cats inside a body that may’t maintain the formidable design as much as tempo with a pursuit-heavy plot. Up mountains. Down mountains. By way of rivers. Round rivers. Look out for that stampede! And one other one in 20 minutes! Track, track, jazz paws, repeat.
What seems like a tonal treadmill is usually differentiated by environments that can little question be wildly complicated to many elementary schoolers’ understanding of African geography, and will even lead adults to combine up the characters. Taka and Mufasa look and sound an excessive amount of alike, significantly throughout their scenes within the snow, and the identical goes for his or her foes, The Outsiders. Go to the toilet throughout the improper journey track/disaster/monologue and you could want a minute to get reoriented.
In some methods, that inbuilt visible confusion helps conceal the film’s most predictable twist (which, for what it’s value, is already spelled out on the “Mufasa” Wikipedia web page). How Scar grew to become Scar is central to organising “The Lion King” and its crowning brotherly betrayal. Vaguely masking that character’s id is likely to be a enjoyable reveal for teenagers who in any other case might get forward of themselves. However Taka and Mufasa’s missing individuality explains why it’s even simpler for Timone and Pumbaa to run away with their film this time round. The comedic duo would handle it even quicker if Disney would adapt their cult traditional backstory “The Lion King 1½ ” from 2004 — however that may require getting Donald Glover and Beyoncé again for greater than ten minutes in a challenge they virtually definitely wouldn’t do.
The dearth of a “Can You Really feel the Love Tonight?” encore doesn’t undercut Jenkins’ bone-deep dedication to drawing out sexual rigidity on display, although. The sordid love story that emerges throughout Mufasa’s journey with Sarabi is likely to be earnestly jarring at instances (there’s a lot… nuzzling?), however one might theoretically argue it brandishes earnest flecks of “Moonlight.” It’s robust to suss out how a lot of that comes from Jenkins’ path or Nathanson’s script. Nevertheless it’s each a goofy reprieve from taking the more-is-more strategy to what was as soon as ostensibly an allegory based mostly on “Hamlet” — and a smirk-inspiring reminder that wild animals coming-of-age have at all times performed a powerful position in “The Lion King.”
Not a single ‘90s child might neglect Nala falling again into that mattress of grass with these fireflies exploding behind her: a scene so weirdly horny it has been canonized on extra BuzzFeed lists than you possibly can depend kings within the sky. For this prequel/sequel, that very same oddly electrical power fuels the one plot value caring about for this treasured IP’s higher storytelling circle of life.
The ending makes our title hero look so outlandishly silly you may by no means see him the identical approach, however when you beloved Favreau’s movie from 2019 (and are nonetheless largely untroubled by eyestrain), then this vastly flawed growth is value watching. See it in theaters if the pure historical past museum is closed — or await it to come back out on Disney+. “Mufasa” has hidden charms which can be arguably greatest described as Jenkins launched straight to VHS.
Grade: C+
Disney’s “Mufasa: The Lion King” might be in theaters Friday, December 20.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up one of the best evaluations, streaming picks, and affords some new musings, all solely out there to subscribers.