Hulu and Disney+’s All’s Fair is the legal drama people can’t stop talking about — and not always for the right reasons. Still, all that buzz, good or bad, has paid off: the boffo ratings have already paved the way for a Season 2 renewal.
Despite all the negative reviews, the legal drama starring Kim Kardashian will be back for more, as reported by the Hollywood Reporter.
All’s Fair is a highly stylized legal drama set in Los Angeles, centered on an all-female high-stakes divorce law firm. Executive-produced by Ryan Murphy, the show follows Allura Grant (Kardashian) and her colleagues as they navigate glamorous clients, complex personal lives, and power struggles in and out of the courtroom.
With Murphy’s name attached, along with astounding talent up front that includes Sarah Paulson, Glenn Close, Naomi Watts, and Kardashian, who also executive produces, the Disney show seemed like it was on the way to be a smash hit, at least until critics got their opinionated little hands on it. As it currently stands, the show has a staggering 4% Fresh on the aggregator site Rotten Tomatoes (though audiences were a bit nicer with a 64% Fresh rating).
Although critical reception was overwhelmingly negative, the show has generated significant attention and viewership, making a Season 2 renewal seem almost inevitable.
With that in mind, here is a look at what to possibly expect from a second season, including who will star, when it will premiere, and more.
Disney/Ser Baffo
When and where will All’s Fair Season 2 premiere?
As Season 1 just debuted, expect a long wait before setting eyes on Season 2. According to reports, creator Ryan Murphy has already begun writing the second outing of the drama.
All’s Fair had an impressive launch on Hulu with 3.2 million recorded views (calculated as total viewing minutes divided by running time) worldwide in just the three days following its premiere. According to Hulu, it is the best start on the platform for an original scripted series in three years.
The first season of All’s Fair debuted on November 4, 2025, on Hulu and Disney+. The first three episodes were released simultaneously, with new episodes scheduled to be released weekly on Tuesdays.
What is All’s Fair about?
All’s Fair is a legal drama series created by Ryan Murphy, Jon Robin Baitz, and Joe Baken, and follows an all-female divorce law firm that formed when three female attorneys leave a male-dominated firm to open their own practice.
Who stars in All’s Fair Season 2?
The current cast stars Kim Kardashian (Allura Grant), Naomi Watts (Liberty Ronson), and Niecy Nash (Emerald Greene) as the founders of the firm, while Glenn Close stars as Dina Standish, Sarah Paulson is rival attorney Carrington Lane, and Matthew Noszka stars as Chase Munroe, Allura’s husband.
It is unknown at this time if the cast is set to return.
Guest stars have included Jessica Simpson as Lee-Ann Hunt, a woman who suffers botched plastic surgery; Brooke Shields as Juliana Morse; Grace Gummer as Grace Henry, the trophy wife of a tech billionaire; and James Remar as Theodore Baskin, the husband of a wealthy cosmetics-industry magnate, among others.
All’s Fair, Tuesdays, Hulu and Disney+