I Can’t Wait For Peacemaker’s Season 2 Finale, And I Have A Checklist Of Things I Really Want To See

Spoilers for Pacemaker’s penultimate episode are below for anyone who hasn’t yet streamed it via HBO Max subscription.

I’ll admit it: I’m not yet ready for Peacemaker Season 2 to wrap up its run on the 2025 TV schedule. I’ve enjoyed this multi-dimensional storyline more than I did the first season’s Butterflies narrative, and even though fans’ Overman theories didn’t even up panning out, I still loved all the big ways James Gunn & Co. set up the finale for these characters, and I have more than a few hopes and wishes for that final episode.

While it’s not even clear yet whether or not Peacemaker Season 3 will happen, or if these characters’ stories will be followed in other projects, more loose ends than desired are still dangling freely. So while I know not ALL of my checklist items will pan out entirely, I’m throwing all of them at the wall in the hopes that some of them will stick.

Keith Formally Declaring Revenge On Peacemaker

Perhaps the easiest way to set up Season 3 would be with a key villain already set to rise up and come after our titular hero. A hero who is mainly responsible for the accidental death of Earth-X’s Christopher Smith, and is tangentially responsible for the death of that family’s patriarch Auggie, as well as the near-death of David Denman’s Keith. That episode very clearly kept him alive and seething by the end, but I’ll still need a far more direct declaration from Captain Triumph himself regarding his future intentions. (With the add-on assumption that Keith’s home portal device remains intact and usable when he’s back up and at ’em.)

A Resolution To Peacemaker And Harcourt’s The Will They? / Won’t They Thing

Considering every single one of this season’s threats not named Rick Flag stemmed from Peacemaker’s emotional yearning for Harcourt, the Season 2 finale 100% needs to follow through on this storyline, even though I presume obstacles will still factor in. In the form of Harcourt agreeing to a romantic relationship, only for Peacemaker to get sent on a years-long mission to Mars or some other far-flung location where he and Harcourt would be unable to see each other. Not that I want that, but I also don’t necessarily want a potential Season 3 to just be goo-goo-eyed Chris and Emilia.

Proof That Earth-X’s Vigilante Survived The Police Shootout

I wasn’t ready for “another Vigilante” to be among my favorite things about this season, but one version of me out there probably saw it coming. I don’t need anything major here to pay that off, just a quick look-see to make sure our boy made it through that hectic shoot-out inside the Smith household. Although let me say it now, I do NOT want to see him survive that altercation just to have him get jump-shock blasted in the face by one of Keith’s weapons. He’s got so many other animals to learn facts about then disperse facts about.

Tim Meadows’ Langston Fleury To Get The Spotlight One More TIme

Tim Meadows’ offbeat A.R.G.U.S. agent came out of the gate wielding such personality traits as the name “Langston Fluery,” a bird-blindness affliction, and very specific views about housewarming gifts. But it doesn’t seem like he’s been part of recent episodes nearly enough, and I hope he gets quite the noteworthy sign-off, especially if we don’t get to see him in the DCU anymore. (Get him in the comics, DC!)

Adebayo Patching Things Up With Keeya

Being chased by an entire neighborhood of racists is the kind of thing that can change a person’s perspective on just about anything. I dunno if that’ll have anything to do with where the Adebayo wives’ future, but I feel like Leota may want to take a step away from this kind of life for a while to rekindle things, especially if Peacemaker is either going to prison or going on squad-like missions for A.R.G.U.S. and Amanda Waller.

Okay, so part of me doesn’t actually want Peacemaker to pay off the pet-incinerating alien character that’s popped up a handful of times thus far, including in the opening dance. I do appreciate pure randomness for the sake of it. But another part of me pretty much needs for the Kyphoid entity’s existence to matter to the overall story. Because I can’t think of a bunch of obvious ways for it to happen, and those are the times when James Gunn tends to win me over the most. Maybe he’ll get his own spinoff, and we’ll find out this is the DCU’s Martian Manhunter, but it’s Kyphoid Manhunter. Not quite as catchy. Scratch that idea. Do it justice, James.

Rick Flag Reveals Wild New Plan For Portal Device

Certainly whatever Frank Grillo’s Rick Flag gets up to next will have implications for James Gunn’s Superman sequel Man of Tomorrow, and I can only hope that it’s not just a means for Lex Luthor to eventually imprison more of his enemies and jilters. But I hope that fans get to see the A.R.G.U.S. director specifically revealing some wacky secret plans for the portal device. And okay, maybe it wouldn’t be that wacky to learn that he just wants to use it to go and hang out with Earth-X’s still-living Rick Flag Jr., even knowing that version is quite possibly a Nazi. But if it’s an even weirder plan, I’m into that, too.

A Clayface Reference