Lou “Simple” Evans isn’t a very gifted singer, however he’s received swagger and pizzaz and panache, and an actual reward for selecting the songs he croons on varied little phases across the barely scuzzier aspect of Las Vegas. Tiny bars and iffy lounges and downbeat casinos are his area, and set lists filled with upbeat jams (Whitney Houston and Stevie Nicks, Mike and the Mechanics and Pat Benatar, oh my!) was actual heartbreakers are his forex.
Being the most important star on The Strip has by no means been his purpose, however he’d certain like the chance to not really feel like such a loser on a regular basis, to not need to scrape by for each penny. And in Vegas? That sort of optimism — “I’d wish to have a paid off bank card invoice!” — is a legal responsibility.
It’s “one other magical day right here in Las Vegas, Nevada” when Nic Pizzolatto’s surprisingly low-key characteristic directorial debut “Simple’s Waltz” opens, although you wouldn’t understand it from the Evans brothers. Simple (Vince Vaughn) is gearing up for an additional throwaway present along with his band, The Grifters, in a “budget-friendly” downtown Vegas joint. Sam (Simon Rex) has slinked off to a dim bar, somewhat than doing his precise job (managing Simple and different native acts), and his eyes gentle up when he spots a reasonably gal (Kate Mara as Lucy) throughout the way in which.
And whereas, as Sam tells it, “the primary rule is to know when to depart the fucking on line casino,” that doesn’t appear to be taking place for both of the Evans males. In a metropolis of individuals at all times hoping for the following large rating, they’re no totally different than anybody else, however time is working out, persistence is sporting skinny, and one thing has to alter. Their luck, it appears, has to show. Proper? Speak about of venture.
Regardless of the dire-sounding set-up of Pizzolatto’s movie (he additionally wrote the movie’s script), “Simple’s Waltz” isn’t almost as downbeat as most may anticipate from the man behind “True Detective,” however grinding it out in Vegas is rarely a stroll within the park. Not almost as darkish — or deep-feeling — as final 12 months’s “beloved star takes on a vibe shift in a Vegas-set drama,” what “Simple’s Waltz” has in widespread with that Pamela Anderson automobile is apparent sufficient: a stable flip from its star. Vaughn pours himself into the position, however he additionally appears to grasp that going large and broad for this one is a misstep. Simple isn’t a caricature, even when the folks and occasions round him more and more really feel that method.
When Simple catches the attention of native supervisor (and far, far more) Mickey Albano (a well-cast Al Pacino), his star is out of the blue on the rise. Mickey books him right into a residency on the swanky Wynn On line casino, passing the entire thing off as a part of his newfound curiosity in giving again to the little folks, not his bone-deep curiosity in searching for himself. Entanglements abound: Mickey can be pleasant with Lucy, whom Sam pretends to not know, if solely as a result of he’s received the great sense to not present Mickey all his playing cards. And when Sam cooks up a very silly scheme to make some fast money, there’s little doubt a heavy like Mickey isn’t going to love it.
What Simple lacks up for in apparent vocal means — although everybody round him, particularly Sam, is at all times fast to remind him he’s the perfect singer on the town — he greater than makes up for with flash. However that kind of flash shouldn’t be essentially the most pure match for Pizzolatto, whose personal sensibility appears to be at odds with the story at hand. Tonal disparities are sometimes on provide, with Pizzolatto going for darker stuff (somebody is gonna break your legs, sucka!) and Vaughn infusing the entire thing with continuous, hangdog attraction. Simple is the sort of dude who sings “The Little Drummer Boy” prefer it’s the saddest track on the planet, however that’s not ok for Pizzolatto, who opts to shoot that efficiency in black and white, as a result of why not.
Regardless of the assorted dramas that swirl round this group of Vegas locals and wannabes, “Simple’s Waltz” meanders towards the majority of its actual punch, with its plot solely kicking in long gone its midway mark. By then, Simple has develop into a viral hit, Sam has dug himself in method too deep, and Mickey is itching to point out his true colours. Audiences may nearly be keen to listen to a traditional limb-breaking menace by then, as a result of far an excessive amount of of this has been, effectively, a bit too simple happening.
Grade: B-
“Simple’s Waltz” premiered on the 2025 Toronto Worldwide Movie Competition. It’s at the moment searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the perfect new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely obtainable to subscribers.