Freud thought that, at the least for a few of us, the guilt comes earlier than the crime. Looking for punishment for a pre-existing (most likely Oedipal) feeling of disgrace and inadequacy, a number of the incarcerated search a actuality that matches their self-identity. For them, crime is just a device for the good things: punishment and pariah standing. Criminality as kink.
Together with his newest neo-noir, Cai Shangjun presents a full-throated endorsement of one in every of Freud’s extra contentious theories with a story of a poisonous romance necessitated by an irresistible vicious cycle. Set in gritty, smoke-filled Guangzhou — the world’s sweatshop and residential to the “Shein village” of cut-price clothes makers — Shangjun’s China is just not a cheerful or a wholesome place. Nor are his characters. However good folks not often make for good films.
Meiyun (Zhilei Xin) runs her personal clothes model in a slick shopping center, the place she broadcasts dwell walkthroughs of her newest merchandise to fussy prospects, who complain about points past her management. Nearly as curt are the docs on the native hospital: Meiyun is six weeks pregnant however, with no hearable heartbeat, it’s unclear whether or not the kid will carry. Her gynecologist reveals a hanging disinterest in Meiyun’s hope that it’ll come by way of; even in stoic China, the dispassion is breathtaking, the primary signal of a harsh, unfeeling surroundings to which Meiyun is well-acquainted. The daddy of the kid is Qifeng (Shaofeng Feng), a good-looking married man whose personal daughter appears to suspect one thing is off. Qifeng leaves a lot to be desired, apologizing to Meiyun for urgent her to get an abortion final time she fell pregnant. Meiyun confides, “The previous will meet up with me. I’ll get what I deserve.”
It quickly turns into clear what she means. Qifeng is Mr. Proper in comparison with Baoshu (Songwen Zhang, in one of the best efficiency of the film). Now a most cancers affected person in a room near the place Meiyun is being consulted, he’s an older man from Meiyun’s previous, lengthy earlier than the mall and the livestreams and the trimmings of an trustworthy life. Baoshu frolicked in jail for a automotive accident prosecuted as a hit-and-run. However Baoshu was asleep within the backseat and Meiyun was behind the wheel.
Baoshu’s determination to take the blame and spend 5 years behind bars — not even telling his late mother the reality — continues to hang-out each of them and causes an inescapable cycle of guilt. Meiyun briefly continues seeing Qifeng, establishing a love triangle that’s like a cursed Chinese language interpretation of “Materialists.” The 2 males’s tradition conflict is funnier than you may count on and credit score to a filmmaker who grasps the tone of what may in any other case have been a dour expertise.
But it surely isn’t enjoyable for lengthy. Baoshu exploits Meiyun’s admittedly well-placed guilt, transferring into her place and behaving like a pig (and worse). Meiyun is now pressured to confront the disgrace she was in a position to disregard whereas Baoshu was locked up and out of her life. It sends her right into a spiral that units up an arresting second half of the movie, which is a component cleaning soap opera, half thriller.
The one fixed is the sad couple’s bleak environment. Shangjun’s China is a grim setting. It’s humid and grey, petty crime and exploitation abound, and even the hospital might actually use a sweep. This isn’t the Twenty first-century China that the state is eager to venture in movies that play overseas — and these characters will not be mannequin Twenty first-century Chinese language, both. The choice to permit its manufacturing and launch (up to now anyway) is presumably the identical rationale that noticed Khrushchev enable Solzhenitsyn’s “One Day within the Lifetime of Ivan Denisovich,” one other story about unjust imprisonment and the burden of guilt, to be printed on the top of censorship in 1962. Although it paints a darkish image of Stalin’s Gulags, Solzhenitsyn’s landmark autobiographical story is admittedly in regards to the freedoms Ivan can discover inside his jail camp over one “virtually glad” day. The identical applies to Shangjun’s characters, whose unhappiness is primarily brought on by their ethical errors. True freedom, it suggests, is there to take it, should you can solely break the cycle.
Simpler mentioned than finished. “The Solar Rises On Us All” quickly turns into the disheartening however affecting story of a pair of damaged folks for whom salvation is just unaffordable in a morally costly world. Meiyun tells Baoshu he may as effectively keep at her place as a result of “Life is difficult in every single place”, a reasonably concise expression of the existential nihilism to which they’ve each fallen. The choice — the unknown — is extra scary nonetheless. So they need to stay boats towards the present, borne again ceaselessly into the previous. Westerners have lengthy indulged in the concept that it’s Catholics and Jews who are suffering probably the most guilt. Together with his newest, Cai Shangjun says: strive me.
Grade: B-
“The Solar Rises on Us All” premiered on the 2025 Venice Movie Competition. It’s at present looking for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie evaluations and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up one of the best new evaluations and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.