The Stolen Lady took viewers on an attractive thriller full of twists, turns, and darkish, tragic secrets and techniques. The present centered on Elisa (Denise Gough), a mom whose daughter Lucia (Beatrice Campbell) was stolen by one other lady, Rebecca (Holliday Grainger). It was rapidly revealed that Rebecca (aka Nina) wasn’t who she claimed to be—and neither, it turned out, was Elisa.
Whereas the central mysteries of The Stolen Lady had been all solved, a number of moments nonetheless left us scratching our heads. From a weird kidnapping plot to some questionable journalistic choices, we have rounded up 10 essential particulars that did not make sense in regards to the present.
10
The Kidnapping Plot Ought to Have Failed
On the floor, Nina’s plot to kidnap Lucia was well-orchestrated, requiring massive sums of cash and years to drag off. However in reality, a lot of the plan relied on sheer luck. For instance, if Elisa’s aircraft hadn’t landed late, leaving her frazzled, and if her son hadn’t constantly honked the horn, it appears seemingly she would have turned down Nina’s provide to look at Lucia. Moreover, if Fred (Jim Sturgess) hadn’t fallen asleep, he seemingly would have discovered Lucia was lacking a lot earlier, which means the police might have rescued her earlier than she ever left the city.
A Crime of Alternative
Admittedly, Nina’s daughter Josie (Robyn Betteridge) performed a not-insignificant function in serving to her mom persuade Elisa to let Lucia come over. Moreover, Elisa’s aircraft had been late earlier than, and it is potential Nina knew of this sample. Nevertheless, that also does not clarify why Nina would go away a lot as much as probability. On most different days, her plan would have failed, probably inflicting Elisa to turn into suspicious. Actually, this feels extra like a criminal offense of alternative than one thing rigorously coordinated and carried out.
9
There Was Zero Purpose to Rent Matkovic
In an effort to kidnap Lucia, Nina hires a person named Matkovic, who drives the woman to France. En route, they cease at a fuel station, and Lucia tries to run away. This tried escape is what in the end permits the police to find her. Nevertheless, if Lucia had merely stayed with Nina, she most likely would not have tried to run, which ends up in an essential query: why was Matkovic concerned within the plan in any respect?
A Extra Difficult, Much less Efficient Plan
Finally, Matkovic simply spelled bother for Nina. He was a legal responsibility as a result of he knew her location and what she had accomplished. Plus, after the police found his id, he got here to her home in search of cash; whereas this altercation in the end resulted in his loss of life, it might simply have resulted in Nina’s. It is potential that Matkovic performed some essential function in getting Lucia to France, resembling by smuggling her aboard a ferry, however even when this had been the case, we surprise why Nina (who additionally traveled to France) could not merely have accomplished it herself.
8
Regular Lives are Over
After kidnapping Lucia, Nina’s actions turn into a bit contradictory. She appears anxious after a neighbor stops by, implying that she needs to sequester the ladies away from others. But, she additionally tells them that they are going to have the ability to exit and make buddies, even taking them right down to the seaside as if attempting to persuade herself that is true. Whereas there, she sees Lucia’s picture in a newspaper and appears stunned—which is a shocking response for audiences, as a result of what precisely did she suppose was going to occur?
Lack of Widespread Sense
In fact, kidnapping a lady and pretending she’s yours already implies one thing may be up psychological health-wise. It is potential that Nina was so caught up in her fantasy that she was having bother seeing actuality for what it was. Nonetheless, given her aforementioned “meticulous” kidnapping plot, it appears honest to suppose she’d have some kind of long-term plan in place—or, on the very least, that she would have realized they’d have to remain hidden indefinitely.
Associated
‘The Stolen Lady’ Is One of many Finest Thriller Collection Since ‘Mare of Easttown’
‘Andor’ star Denise Gough stands out in a slick, taught story a couple of dad or mum’s youngster that mysteriously goes lacking.
7
Faking Identification is a Attain
Selma (Ambika Mod) was a journalist who believed that Elisa was concerned in Lucia’s disappearance. Early on, she advised her boss that she thought Elisa was faking her id as a result of she was consistently on social media, but had no presence a number of years again. To be honest, Selma was confirmed proper: Elisa had been a part of a cult and solely began social media after leaving. Nevertheless, it was a heck of a soar to suppose that no social media presence meant that Elisa was pretending to be another person.
Different Solutions
It is potential that Elisa’s lack of social media presence was just because she did not use social media up till that time. The timeline corresponded with early motherhood, so she may need chosen to go surfing then since she had extra to share. Moreover, there have been varied different, extra logical leads that Selma might have pursued, resembling assuming that the kidnapper was linked to one in every of Fred’s shoppers.
6
Placing Lucia at Danger
After publishing her article about Elisa, Selma appeared genuinely anxious that the protection might put Lucia in danger. She additionally appeared greatly surprised that a lot negativity had befallen Elisa for the reason that article. Like a number of of the opposite entries on this checklist, we’ve got to surprise why she did not understand this may occur. It appears apparent {that a} hit piece would lead to unfavorable consideration for Elisa and probably endanger her daughter concurrently.
Unhealthy Journalism
Clearly, it is potential that Selma is just newer to writing about tales like this, so she did not understand that an article associated to a kidnapping case might have implications {that a} story about an aggressive pig would not. It is also potential that Selma merely needed the inside track and did not take into account the potential ramifications. In both case, this means she has rather a lot to study as a journalist if she hopes to proceed working within the subject.
5
How Does the Cult Operate?
After discovering that Elisa was in a cult, Selma journeys to her hometown to listen to extra about how the cult capabilities and who Elisa was. Nevertheless, the viewers does not study a lot in regards to the cult besides that they put on purple, commerce items as an alternative of utilizing cash, and declare to keep away from trendy issues. But, a number of trendy objects are worn or utilized by the members, and out of doors of the horrible issues Elisa’s father did to her (and what her mom allowed), the cult itself appears pretty innocuous. Given the cult’s significance to the story, it is unusual we did not study extra about it.
Extra To Discover
To be honest, this is not an error of the present a lot as one thing we would wish to know extra about. It appeared like an apparent story for a journalist like Selma to comply with, however as soon as she was accomplished studying about Elisa, her curiosity within the cult apparently vanished—however as viewers, ours solely grew.
Associated
‘The Stolen Lady’: The place and How To Watch the Finest New Thriller Collection
In case you’re confused about when and how you can stream ‘The Stolen Lady,’ you are not alone. Fortunately, you will have a number of simple streaming choices.
4
Lucia’s Acceptance of Nina
Towards the tip of the present, Lucia discovers that Nina has been altering pictures to resemble her, and she or he decides to run. Nevertheless, we do not perceive why she believed Nina’s lie so simply from the start. Sure, she’s a baby and simply influenced, however she lived her whole life along with her mother and father. It is unusual that she did not not less than have extra questions (and even appear to overlook them).
Unusual Youngster Logic
Clearly, we do not blame Lucia for getting kidnapped, nor was she at fault for staying with Nina and Josie. She’s a bit woman, in spite of everything, in addition to the sufferer in the whole lot that transpired. Nevertheless, we do surprise why she did not put up extra of a struggle to flee, particularly given the truth that Nina was consistently away, which gave her the right probability to flee.
Certain, it is potential that the birthmark pictures may need satisfied her that Nina was telling the reality, or perhaps she developed a type of Stockholm Syndrome, however she’d had a number of probabilities to run early on and did not actually appear . It is also potential she did not run as a result of she was unsure the place she was, however that did not cease her from working on the fuel station, so why the hesitation now?
3
Elisa’s Connection to Marcus
Marcus (Xavier Samuel) and Elisa had been having an affair shortly earlier than she turned pregnant with George. He was there when she by accident pushed her father down the steps and likewise within the automotive when she collided with Nina’s husband and daughter. It is apparent that he beloved her, since he determined to take the autumn and go to jail as an alternative. Nevertheless, we’re stunned that the police did not discover and look into this connection—and much more stunned that Elisa did not point out it.
An Apparent Lead
Sure, Marcus was in jail, however he’d nonetheless seemingly be an individual of curiosity in Lucia’s case. Moreover, Elisa may need gotten into bother for exposing her connection (as later occurs), however she will need to have realized mentioned connection might be pertinent to the case, so it ought to have been prioritized. Actually, if the intel about Marcus had been found/revealed sooner, the police might have simply linked him to Nina, and in flip rescued Lucia extra rapidly. Because it occurred years in the past, Elisa may not have thought it was related, however given the severity of what occurred, she most likely ought to have thought-about it.
Associated
‘The Stolen Lady’ Is Primarily based on a Devastating True Story
‘The Stolen Lady’ is a harrowing collection in regards to the abduction of a small youngster. Much more surprising is the truth that it is based mostly on true occasions.
2
How Did Nina Observe Elisa to the Cult?
After Nina’s husband and daughter had been killed, she went to Elisa’s cult in search of solutions. Nevertheless, it is unusual that she’d do that, provided that Marcus took the autumn. Nina was circled when the crash occurred, so she did not see a girl within the automotive (and later, it was made apparent that she’d had no concept that Elisa was driving). So, why did she go to the cult attempting to study extra about her husband and daughter’s deaths when she had no motive to suppose it wasn’t an accident and that Marcus hadn’t been driving alone?
Unsatisfactory Solutions
Perhaps the police discovered proof that another person had been with Marcus, but when so, the viewer wasn’t advised this. Moreover, perhaps the cult members had been the one folks close by when the crash occurred, so Nina had hoped to ask them some questions. Nonetheless, it appears fairly handy that Nina discovered Elisa’s mom, of all folks, to talk to, and even stranger that Nina would soar to kidnapping as an alternative of getting the police concerned after studying of Elisa’s involvement.
1
Elisa’s Connection to Nina
Maybe the largest factor that does not make sense about The Stolen Youngster revolves round Elisa’s connection to Nina. Elisa ran over Nina’s husband and daughter, and but, she apparently by no means noticed pictures of Nina. Perhaps she needed to place the entire thing behind her and by no means bothered to search for the case. Nevertheless, that makes us query who Elisa was as a personality, since she principally deserted Marcus in jail, ignored her sufferer’s widow, and extra typically shirked all duty earlier than attempting to return to her regular life.
Undermining the Entire Collection
Actually, this looks like a plot gap that turns your complete collection on its head. Elisa ought to have acknowledged Nina, or on the very least, Nina ought to have anxious that Elisa may. In spite of everything, photographs of her outdoors the trial had been publicly obtainable and within the information. Identical to with the remainder of the kidnapping plot, Nina actually lucked out that Elisa did not know who she was from the start, or else the kidnapping (and present as a complete) would have ended proper there after which.