“Babygirl” star Harris Dickinson is a bit of too younger, a bit of too good-looking, and a bit of too scorching proper now for critics to fake as if his directorial debut exists in a vacuum, and but the uncooked and raggedy “Urchin” — which might command our consideration no matter who made it — is just a few seconds previous earlier than it’s locked into the thrall of a unique actor altogether.
Greatest identified for taking part in the younger Tom Riddle in “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” Frank Dillane awakens into this film with the ache and neediness of an open wound. His character’s title is Mike, he’s been dwelling on the streets of London for the final 5 years, and he doesn’t take kindly to the road preacher whose shouting (“Have you ever heard about Jesus!?”) stirs him out of his newest drug stupor. It’s unhealthy sufficient that she’s loud, but it surely’s even worse that she’s attempting to save lots of folks — in her personal approach, at the least.
Such generosity of spirit proves to be one thing of a set off for a tousle-haired misplaced boy like Mike, who resents anybody for daring to supply him the assistance he doesn’t know the right way to settle for. He’s nice sufficient to a few of the folks he acknowledges from numerous shelters and the like, however when a very good samaritan presents to purchase Mike some meals, our man returns the favor by violently mugging the person for his kindness.
And so it’s off to a different stint in jail, the following half in a cycle that Mike appears ambivalent to flee. The movie round him shows equally little curiosity in forcing the matter, even after Mike is launched from jail — now sober for seven months — and lands a job as a prepare dinner at a low-rent resort on the outskirts of city. He makes associates with two of his co-workers, sings Atomic Kitten’s “Entire Once more” at karaoke, and even attends a supervised reconciliation assembly with the person he beat up.
However Dickinson’s lithe and tetchy script solely feigns at a clear hero’s journey with the intention to undercut it with the chaos of human habits, and what may need been a pleasant three-act story a few moppet on the mend sours into one thing far much less digestible or instructive (comparisons to “Bare” virtually make themselves, and whereas “Urchin” lacks the sadism of Mike Leigh’s Thatcherite-era scream, it’s a credit score to Dillane’s outstanding efficiency that the 2 films appear able to holding a dialog with one another).
After all, “Urchin” is all of the extra rewarding for its messy strategy to Mike’s disarray, which rejects a transparent analysis in favor of honoring a personality who seems like he can’t even afford to know himself. Dickinson’s movie — formed by folks he knew rising up, and additional knowledgeable by his work with quite a lot of social outreach charities — displays a mature, and steadily harrowing, recognition of how folks could be held captive by the centrifugal power of their very own behavioral patterns.
On this case, these patterns would seem to stretch again to childhood, as Dillane performs Mike as an overgrown child — one entombed by the insouciant aloofness of somebody who’s by no means fairly understood the connection between actions and their penalties. Carrying the identical clean expression on his face when he will get out of jail as he does when he’s first arrested, Mike at all times exists within the second at hand, and in most conditions stays unblinkingly trustworthy about his circumstances (which might be extra reassuring if he didn’t fantasize about his delusional future with the identical nanchalance as he displays on his troubled previous).
If Mike is able to sweetness or bursts of violence, that’s solely as a result of he’s equally able to something always, and considers all of his choices to be roughly the identical. When a buyer on the restaurant complains about an undercooked burger, there’s no telling if Mike will implode or explode; solely motivated by emotional avoidance (as we see within the unforgettably transient scene the place he’s reconciled along with his assault sufferer), Mike makes no distinction between displaying as much as work or snorting ketamine on the seaside, and lashes out at anybody who dares to counsel one selection may be higher than the opposite.
That steadiness is central to Dillane’s magnetic efficiency, which at all times tacks nearer to neediness than sociopathy, and by no means steers in the direction of low cost sympathy or demonstrative rage. Mike is a troubled soul, however he’s not Anton Chigurh (regardless that he’s typically simply as demanding to look at); if he reliably makes probably the most self-destructive selection out there to him, it’s solely so scary to look at as a result of he’s so shut to creating a greater one.
Alas, the form of his life doesn’t bend towards salvation, simply as Dickinson’s movie doesn’t information him in the direction of any kind of narrative salvation. Quite the opposite, Josée Deshaies’ lengthy lens cinematography flattens Mike into his surroundings, successfully drilling the overt movieness out of the scenes the place he exists in public. That documentary-like sense of discovery is contrasted in opposition to a handful of hyper-stylized setpieces (together with a dance sequence and a number of other totally different journeys into the recesses of Mike’s consciousness), as Dickinson eschews the movie’s early faux-realism in favor of a extra complicated array of modes and emotions — a choice that makes “Urchin” as onerous to pin down as its protagonist, and likewise permits Dickinson to forged himself in a small however pivotal position with out disturbing some docudrama phantasm of fact.
The place “Bare” tethered itself to the mania of a mad thinker, Davdi Thewlis’ efficiency wavering someplace between Jesus and the Satan, “Urchin” is sure to an unbreakable innocence that persists lengthy after Mike has disabused us of our sympathy; he’s the sufferer of a merciless world, but in addition an unfeeling agent of its callousness. Dickinson clearly hopes this story will make it that a lot more durable for folks to dehumanize the homeless inhabitants, however the energy of his movie — and the promise of his intelligence as a filmmaker — is that it acknowledges how a portrait of mottled ambivalence may higher accomplish that objective than 1,000,000 low cost sops of empathy.
Mike is stricken by the sensation that nobody will let him in; that happiness is glowing from the opposite facet of a window labeled “this isn’t for you.” That will not be sufficient to justify his persecution complicated, however Dickinson’s terrific debut insists that the view from our facet of the display is simply as clear because the one from Mike’s.
Grade: B+
“Urchin” premiered on the 2025 Cannes movie pageant. It’s presently searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and significant ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Evaluation by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Opinions Editor rounds up the perfect new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.