The second season of 1923 will need to have set some document for essentially the most distress endured by characters in a TV present.
Whereas Season 1 had its ups and downs, Season 2 dials up the struggling as everybody faces conditions many wouldn’t endure – and a few characters don’t.
The unforgiving nature of the pure world, coupled with the human race’s unending greed, creates a few of the most horrible conditions.
It may be onerous to look at others endure unimaginable horrors. For a lot of, this could compound their normal hopelessness within the face of uncontrollable conditions.
The truth that we can’t repair most issues, regardless of how a lot we need to, is spiritually debilitating.
1923 Season 2 explores the struggles of those characters within the early twentieth century, when individuals had much less understanding of the world and society than they do in the present day.
Demise was the order of the day. If different individuals don’t get you, animals positive will. If animals fail, climate and local weather will get the job carried out.
It appeared like a real-world Russian roulette sport wherein all of the slots within the gun are loaded. Whereas the sport may not fail in some unspecified time in the future, it doesn’t matter since you can’t cease enjoying.
Nevertheless, the season featured one other drawback: it leaned into an excessive amount of.
The truth that Taylor Sheridan is aware of the best way to stability the narrative is likely one of the largest allures of his works.
When he writes a scene, he’ll depart no stone unturned, however he doesn’t spend an excessive amount of time on one thing that loses its impression.
This stability has stopped his exhibits from focusing an excessive amount of on one factor, and it’s been clear since time immemorial that intercourse sells.
Whereas a lot of his exhibits are sexual, it manages to mix in with the narrative and really feel like a pure a part of it.
1923 Season 2 is the primary time that it looks like intercourse is getting used sinisterly, which is method worse than gratuitously.
The season options quite a few intercourse scenes, starting early within the season premiere.
In a single, Spencer stops a rape and in one other Whitfield continues his assault on intercourse staff. In yet one more, Alex is assaulted on a practice.
The widespread thread right here is that intercourse is introduced as a method of management, which isn’t removed from the actual world.
Nevertheless, the intercourse scenes within the season have a selected nastiness to them, the place they deal with the detrimental points of sexuality.
To make issues worse, the present dwells an excessive amount of on these scenes, making an already uncomfortable present much more disturbing.
Seeing Whitfield abuse the ladies he retains hostage is as chilling as watching a racist marshal homicide a toddler with out a second thought or regret.
Each different scene on the Paramount+ hit to do with intercourse is specific rape or rape-adjacent, eradicating the stability that Sheridan’s exhibits attempt to set up.
1923 Season 2 Went Too Far
It was essential for the season to stability it out with loving or consensual depictions of intercourse and sexuality to counter all the things else that was occurring too continuously.
Aside from Teonna and Pete, all the things else was simply too terrible.
One other factor that sneaks into these scenes is the depiction of intercourse between genders.
Sheridan’s exhibits don’t even remotely characteristic first rate depictions of same-sex relationships. One can depend on one hand the variety of queer characters on all of his exhibits.
Queerness is talked about in passing, nearly at all times being a punchline to some joke or state of affairs.
And I’m not even mad about it as a result of Sheridan’s exhibits entice a selected viewers, and I knew what I used to be signing up for with them.
However to make the one depiction of same-sex sexuality nearly exclusvely tied to rape isn’t one thing with none detrimental penalties.
Viewers may be very biased towards sure demographics and queer individuals have seen their unfair share of this bias.
Writing scenes that present same-sex interactions the way in which 1923 portrays them in Season 2 is frankly disgusting.
It reinforces present notions that there’s something essentially flawed with same-sex relationships.
“I imply, take a look at them. All they do is abuse one another and harmless individuals,” is a thought somebody who’s homophobic would possibly inform themselves.
However above all, it’s simply disturbing to be subjected to fixed rape scenes when one scene and even alluding to it may be efficient.
Over to you, 1923 Fanatics.
What did you consider the fixed depictions of sexual violence within the season? Let’s discuss it within the feedback part beneath.
Watch 1923 On-line
TV Fanatic is looking for passionate contributors to share their voices throughout varied article varieties. Suppose you will have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click on right here for extra data and subsequent steps.