After the star graduate of an elite Belgian tennis academy commits suicide, her surprising dying triggers an investigation into the late teenager’s relationship with the (now suspended) older male coach who’d been so instrumental to her success. That investigation steadily however inevitably involves concentrate on the coach’s newest protégé, who’s spent the final a number of years beneath his wing, and is on the cusp of qualifying for the Belgian Tennis Federation. Folks can’t assist however suspect that she is aware of a factor or two about how coach Jeremy (Laurent Caron) treats his pupils when nobody else is round to see. Her associates, her dad and mom, the directors at her faculty… everybody is keen for her to fill within the blanks, however Julie retains quiet.
Evidently, Leonardo Van Dijl’s “Julie Retains Quiet” doesn’t regard that as a lot of a spoiler. This spectacular debut characteristic — chilly as a crypt and but enormously delicate abruptly — is rarely framed like a thriller, or at the very least not just like the thriller that you simply would possibly anticipate from its premise.
Because the title of the movie makes clear from the beginning, the query on the coronary heart of this story isn’t whether or not Julie (first-time actress and veteran tennis participant Tessa Van den Broeck) will communicate up, and even what she would possibly reveal if she did. The query on the coronary heart of this movie — which is government produced by Naomi Osaka and co-produced by the Dardenne brothers — is why Julie chooses to stay silent, and the overlapping array of doable solutions offered by Van Dijl and Ruth Becquart’s script permits this sober coming-of-age story to mature into an absorbingly implosive portrait of a woman studying to hearken to herself.
Or at the very least to hearken to herself clearly, as a result of it’s not as if a mess of outdoor voices have been discovering their means into Julie’s head — just one, Coach Jeremy’s, whose ideas have suffused into her personal. Cinematographer Nicolas Karakatsanis shoots the lady as if she had been an ideal echo chamber, his 35mm frames smothering Julie with a delicate focus that makes her really feel like she’s worlds away from her associates on the following court docket over.
Possibly that’s why the opening scene finds Julie practising her strokes by herself as she chases an invisible ball throughout the baseline for minutes on finish, the tennis equal of shadowboxing. This may hardly be the final time that Van Dijl drills his consideration into Julie’s monastic coaching routine, as if the star athlete had been making an attempt to sublimate herself into the game that has come to outline her, or as if she had by no means discovered some other means of expressing herself (at one level we see her flip by way of an previous photograph album that appears to cowl the final decade of her life, and he or she’s holding a racket in each image).
Julie is a warrior, however that perseverance belies the vulnerabilities in her sport. Within the chipper and smiling interview footage she watches of her useless predecessor, Aline, the older lady beams that Coach Jeremy taught her how you can be in command of her feelings (the crushingly darkish irony of that declare is the closest this film involves a humorousness), and we understand that Julie has been conditioned to play by way of any type of ache. To talk out would fly within the face of her coaching.
A extra prescriptive movie would possibly construct to a scene through which she breaks down and tells her dad and mom every thing that Jeremy did to her, however “Julie Retains Quiet” — once more, per its title — eschews any hint of melodrama in favor of highlighting subliminal moments of self-discovery. As soon as proud to be the academy’s brightest prospect, Julie blanches when her form new coach Backie (Pierre Gervais) stops follow in order that the remainder of the scholars can admire her footwork. The investigation has clearly made her cautious of the highlight, however each scene on this movie probes a bit deeper than that; on this occasion, it led me to marvel if Julie might need felt herself following in Aline’s footsteps, and if that had made her newly reluctant to function a mannequin for the opposite women.
We’re with the character for each millisecond of this film, and but Van den Broeck’s efficiency — steely however looking out — by no means betrays any of Julie’s secrets and techniques. The actress implicitly acknowledges that Julie’s silence is her biggest power. A number of the individuals in her life, and a number of the individuals in Van Dijl’s viewers, would possibly argue that she lacks the braveness to talk her fact, however “Julie Retains Quiet” is so trustworthy and humane exactly as a result of Julie has the braveness to make sense of that fact for herself earlier than she agrees to share it with the world (it’s the cinematic equal of watching Novak Djokovic bounce the ball 100 occasions earlier than he feels assured within the serve to come back).
With Jeremy sidelined from taking up new college students, Julie’s silence creates its personal type of security, particularly because it compels the individuals round her to point out their playing cards. It’s by way of her silence that Julie can admire Backie’s sincerity, and the way the college administrator’s concern for Julie’s well-being hides her even larger concern for a scandal.
The longer the movie goes on, the extra it looks like Julie’s silence is freighted with invaluable data, and the sterility of Van Dijl’s method — his aesthetic as redolent of Michael Haneke in its take away as it’s of the Dardenne brothers in its focus — quickly involves assume its personal depth of feeling. We’re capable of glean a number of key particulars from the one and solely scene through which Julie meets up with Coach Jeremy in individual (his profile at all times gripped in shadow, his compliments all dangerously backhanded), however we’re capable of parse a lot extra from the wordless reveal that Julie secretly recorded their dialog.
Van Dijl by no means budges from that mode of pressurized introspection, and “Julie Retains Quiet” can often really feel a bit anemic and repetitive on account of that tight-lipped self-discipline. The movie breathes slightly bit as Julie begins to come back out of her shell and take inventory of how Jeremy might need remoted her from the remainder of the world (there are a variety of hazily drawn scenes through which she begins to reconnect together with her associates), nevertheless it’s not as if she ever finds the phrases to articulate the main points of her expertise, or to point the severity of the trauma that it left behind.
And but, “Julie Retains Quiet” is so affecting exactly as a result of it refuses to turn into a film about what its namesake has to say. Quite the opposite, it is a film about what she’s capable of finding in a silence that she by no means acknowledged as such till everybody requested her to talk, and it’s due to that silence that Julie is in the end capable of uncover the facility of her personal voice.
Grade: B
Metrograph Footage will launch “Julie Retains Quiet” on the Metrograph for a one-week run starting on Friday, March 28.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Overview by David Ehrlich, through which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up one of the best new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely out there to subscribers.