If there may be one factor Brooklyn 9-9 managed to show over its eight-season run, it’s that cop comedies may be intelligent, heartfelt, and completely ridiculous on the similar time. From awkward social encounters to elaborate heists, there’s nothing the 99th Precinct hasn’t dealt with. The collection, with its sharp writing and gifted ensemble solid, made each second really feel nuanced, wealthy, chaotic, and sensible, placing a chord that has followers clamoring for extra.
It’s as a result of Brooklyn 9-9 was by no means nearly fixing crimes. It was about friendships, absurd operating gags, and surprisingly deep life classes wrapped in top-tier comedy. Followers fell in love with the precinct’s found-family improvement, Rosa Diaz’s take-no-prisoners perspective, Terry Jeffords’ dimwitted however well-meaning allure, and the lovable man-child that’s Jake Peralta.
Even now, lengthy after the ultimate episode aired, B99 continues to be rewatched, quoted, and adored. A part of what made it particular was the impeccable casting. It’s unimaginable to think about anybody else entering into their sneakers, however the unique solid has moved on to different tasks.
And whereas there is no such thing as a affirmation of such a challenge occurring any time quickly, listed below are the ten actors we predict would completely crush it in a Brooklyn 9-9 reboot.
9
Rosa Diaz – Jenna Ortega
Performed by the effortlessly cool Stephanie Beatriz, Rosa Diaz is a resident thriller of the 99th precinct. Clad in leather-based, wielding a knife, unimaginable to learn, she not solely instructions respect but additionally strikes worry into the hearts of perps. Rosa is the residing, respiration model of “don’t choose a e-book by its cowl.” Whether or not she’s scaring rookie detectives or reluctantly exhibiting glimpses of her vulnerabilities, Rosa appears to thrive in chaos, retaining secrets and techniques, and delivering one-liners with terrifying precision. She additionally shares a bizarrely loyal friendship with Boyle, which feels kinda monumental.
For this formidable and candy function, the skills of Jenna Ortega are perfect. The rising star whose work in films like X and Scream reveals she has the grit to painting a personality that feels at dwelling in harmful, high-stakes environments. Netflix’s Wednesday has demonstrated Ortega’s skill to ship deadpan humor with a fierce edge. However Ortega’s Rosa will likely be somewhat extra fashionable. She’d nonetheless trip a motorbike, however lean tougher into her enigmatic nature, make her sarcasm deeper, and her unpredictability even wilder and extra fascinating.
8
Gina Linetti – Awkwafina
The self-proclaimed “human type of the 100 emoji,” Gina Linetti is among the many geniuses of the 9-9. She’s performed by the long-lasting Chelsea Peretti, and she’s recognized for her sarcasm, confidence, sassy one-liners, and an unwavering sense of self-worth. Whereas technically the precinct’s civilian administrator, Gina by no means let one thing as trivial as her job description cease her from pursuing her ambitions. One minute she is roasting Jake, the following she’s launching a social media empire.
To play the neatest individual within the room isn’t any joke. However Awkwafina could be a dream casting for Gina. She’s obtained the comedic instincts to match Peretti’s sharp supply, however she’d additionally take Gina to new ranges of chaos and brilliance. Her work in Loopy Wealthy Asians and The Farewell, in addition to her voice roles, show that she will juggle her larger-than-life presence with moments of emotion. In a method, Awkwafina would make Gina much more outrageous but by some means extra layered.

Associated
Brooklyn 9-9: The Funniest Episodes, Ranked
Brooklyn 9-9 had many hilarious episodes that highlighted its robust solid. Listed here are the funniest episodes, ranked.
7
Terry Jeffords – Winston Duke
The 9-9’s muscle, Terry Jeffords, is delivered to life by Terry Crews. A loyal household man, with a coronary heart as huge as his biceps, and lover of yoghurt, Terry balances power with an virtually childlike enthusiasm for his workforce. Terry’s gruff exterior belies a young soul that’s keen about defending the individuals of Brooklyn. His love for his squad (and his worry of paperwork) make him relatable. And who can neglect him freaking out over his daughters’ faculty tasks or defending his favourite snack?
Whereas Terry may break down a door with ease, his true likable high quality is his emotional sincerity. And that’s what makes Winston Duke a very good match for enjoying the character in a reboot. The actor, whose breakout performances in Black Panther and Us have showcased his performing abilities, would step into Terry’s well-torn boots with no effort in any respect. He’d clearly deliver a barely completely different taste to Terry – much less over-the-top pleasure however nonetheless a loveable presence with a robust sentimental core.
6
Charles Boyle – Lewis Pullman
Charles Boyle, initially performed by Joe Lo Truglio, is Brooklyn 9-9’s “human golden retriever.” He’s equal elements endearing and overly enthusiastic. His devotion to Jake borders on heroic and keen; his ardour for obscure culinary exploits is unmatched; and the best way he’s relentlessly optimistic makes even probably the most absurd conditions downright charming. Boyle has a knack for stumbling into chaos, however he additionally is aware of methods to get out of it.
Lewis Pullman could be an intriguing option to play a personality who all the time has the 9-9’s again. He’d deliver a mixture of hilarity and sincerity to Charles Boyle. His work in Unhealthy Instances on the El Royale demonstrated his skill to play an ungainly but likable character, whereas High Gun: Maverick proved that he could make the smallest moments matter. Together with his heat display presence and knack for bodily comedy, Pullman would undoubtedly breathe new life into Boyle and reshape him right into a extra grounded character.
5
Captain Holt – Colman Domingo
Captain Raymond Holt, initially performed by the late Andre Braugher, is on the coronary heart of Brooklyn 9-9’s ensemble. The steadfast, no-nonsense, and intensely clever officer who’s additionally hilariously unaware of his personal comedic supply, Holt is a person with shocking depth and heat. The best way he maintains a stoic demeanor whereas delivering probably the most devastatingly exact insults is what made him one of many distinctive and humorous characters on tv. From his begrudgingly admiring Jake to his loyalty to the squad, Holt proved that he was by no means simply the intense boss however somebody who, in his personal bizarre method, cared deeply.
Additionally, pondering again to Holt’s iconic feud with Wuntch, the one title that involves thoughts – an actor who would deliver a brand new dimension to the character – is Colman Domingo. The actor has showcased his command and authority in tasks like Concern the Strolling Useless and Euphoria, however it’s his most up-to-date efficiency within the Tina Fey-co-created The 4 Seasons that proves he is versatile sufficient to go away room for quiet humor. As Holt, Domingo would protect that air of refined management whereas additionally including a barely extra theatrical edge to the character.
4
Kevin Cozner – Dan Levy
Kevin Cozner, performed by the always-charming Marc Evan Jackson, is extra than simply Captain Holt’s husband – he’s the executive spine of the present in a weirdly satisfying and delicate method. A refined professor of classics, he’s witty and unnervingly calm, serving as the right foil to Holt’s total persona. His clipped mannerisms are in enormous distinction with the chaos of the 99th precinct, which makes each scene he’s right away traditional.
Dan Levy looks as if an impressed selection for a reboot. His work in Schitt’s Creek proves that he can grasp the steadiness between subtle humor and delightfully awkward encounters. Levy additionally has the flexibility to ship chopping remarks with a poised however expressive demeanor, which feels tailored for Kevin. Think about Levy including a contact extra eccentric vitality although, and turning Kevin right into a bit extra unpredictable character.

Associated
Finest TV Sequence to Watch When You’re Bored
Listed here are 10 TV reveals which are good for binge-watching anytime you might be bored.
3
Scully & Hitchcock – Paul Walter Hauser & Danny McBride
This lovable, if not totally competent, duo of Scully and Hitchcock grew to become a fan favourite because of their laziness and disturbingly profound friendship. They’ve been the precinct’s most persistent forces, they usually’ve supplied shocking moments of perception. Performed by Joel McKinnon Miller and Dirk Blocker, these two by some means handle to be ineffective and sensible on the similar time. That’s, once they hassle to attempt. Their love for meals additionally stays unmatched, and let’s all agree that they’re not within the present for simply comedian aid.
Paul Walter Hauser and Danny McBride could be the last word selection for casting Scully and Hitchcock in a reboot. Hauser, recognized for Cobra Kai and Black Fowl, is understood for his expertise for infusing his characters with equal elements cluelessness and coronary heart. And his deadpan supply could be good for some doses of knowledge. McBride, alternatively, has thrived in reveals like Eastbound & Down and The Righteous Gems. His model of Hitchcock would push the character to new heights.
2
Amy Santiago – Rachel Zegler
The world of the 9-9 is fast-paced, and if there may be one officer who nonetheless stays one step forward of the sport, it’s Amy Santiago. The perfectionist, by-the-book detective whose love for buildings, binders, and academic-style competitors made her immediately lovable was performed by Melissa Fumero. Amy can be relentlessly attempting to show herself, particularly within the eyes of Captain Holt, which results in hilarious moments. However whereas she’s attempting to beat Jake in a wager or looking for the best submitting system, Santiago additionally harbors an adventurous streak.
For this function, Rachel Zegler is a charming selection. Her breakout efficiency in West Facet Story is nowhere near the style, however she’s passionate, decided, and lovely – qualities that align with Amy’s character. Zelger has additionally demonstrated her skill to play emotionally layered characters. And due to her current turns in action-heavy films like Shazam! Fury of the Gods and The Starvation Video games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, would additionally deliver a sure physicality to Amy.
1
Jake Peralta – Logan Lerman
The detective that single-handedly binds collectively the eccentric solid of 9-9 characters can be probably the most irresponsible and perpetually immature one. Kale Peralta, initially delivered to life by Andy Samberg, is an impulsive, thrill-seeking detective whose ardour for crime-solving is matched by his love for popular culture references (Die Laborious, Taylor Swift) and infantile antics. Regardless of all the time attempting to dodge obligations, Jake will get the job accomplished and proves that he is among the greatest detectives in Brooklyn. His dynamic with Captain Holt and his messy, elaborate, and unending makes an attempt to impress him contributed to a lot of the present’s humor.
Logan Lerman would deliver a contemporary twist to Jake. He’d be much less goofy, sure, however nonetheless full of allure and dedication. And the sort of beauty that might make it unimaginable for us to not root for him. Lerman has performed reluctant heroes earlier than in Percy Jackson and Hunters. He’s additionally recognized to modify between genres. In The Perks of Being a Wallflower, he infused Charlie with a slight comedic and relatable contact, so he may simply lean into Jake’s clever but troublemaking persona.